your thoughts on the p4 extreme

Page 5 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Budman

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
10,980
0
0
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
Originally posted by: Budman
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
Originally posted by: Budman
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
Originally posted by: Budman
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
Being that I am the coolest guy in this forum and people envy my CPU, now they can envy my LCD as well. :beer:

Why dont you go in your User profile and then go to personal options & enable Allow Others to Rate You:.

Then we can let the people decide how cool they think you are. :roll:

I just voted you #1. :)

Turn yours on you coward.

It is on you coward.

No it isnt

you dont tell me what to do without saying the magic word. :lips:





This word?
Or this one?
Maybe this one ?
 

Mik3y

Banned
Mar 2, 2004
7,089
0
0
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
Originally posted by: Mik3y
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
Originally posted by: Budman
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
Originally posted by: Budman
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
Being that I am the coolest guy in this forum and people envy my CPU, now they can envy my LCD as well. :beer:

Why dont you go in your User profile and then go to personal options & enable Allow Others to Rate You:.

Then we can let the people decide how cool they think you are. :roll:

I just voted you #1. :)

Turn yours on you coward.

It is on you coward.

felix, no one likes you.

mik3y all know who you like. what did tasque say again? :heart:

if i remember correctly, tasque said that you were stupid and didnt want your idiotic advice.

of course, everybody knows i like kristin kreuk. :heart:
 

FelixDeCat

Lifer
Aug 4, 2000
31,075
2,706
126
Originally posted by: Budman
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
Originally posted by: Budman
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
Originally posted by: Budman
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
Originally posted by: Budman
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
Being that I am the coolest guy in this forum and people envy my CPU, now they can envy my LCD as well. :beer:

Why dont you go in your User profile and then go to personal options & enable Allow Others to Rate You:.

Then we can let the people decide how cool they think you are. :roll:

I just voted you #1. :)

Turn yours on you coward.

It is on you coward.

No it isnt

you dont tell me what to do without saying the magic word. :lips:


This word?
Or this one?
Maybe this one ?


Sorry. Try again.
 

FelixDeCat

Lifer
Aug 4, 2000
31,075
2,706
126
Originally posted by: Mik3y
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
Originally posted by: Mik3y
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
Originally posted by: Budman
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
Originally posted by: Budman
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
Being that I am the coolest guy in this forum and people envy my CPU, now they can envy my LCD as well. :beer:

Why dont you go in your User profile and then go to personal options & enable Allow Others to Rate You:.

Then we can let the people decide how cool they think you are. :roll:

I just voted you #1. :)

Turn yours on you coward.

It is on you coward.

felix, no one likes you.

mik3y all know who you like. what did tasque say again? :heart:

if i remember correctly, tasque said that you were stupid and didnt want your idiotic advice.

of course, everybody knows i like kristin kreuk. :heart:


No he said you were having a secret love affair with mark. :lips: I didnt agree with him, but at least someone likes you.

Everyone likes me however. :thumbsup:
 

karlreading

Member
Aug 17, 2004
109
0
0
i have to say this: this felix blokes a bit of a knob end :)
no ones having a go at the p4EE, there just laying down the facts: its overpriced in comparison to the power it offers. BIG TIME!!
and,heres one for ya: when intel reles the 6xx series ( p4ee under diffrent name - 2meg cache ) do you think they will charge a premium for that, or will it be much more moderatly priced part as its not called Extremly Expensive!!! ( and looks like it will be more mainstream ).

Oh, and before i get accused of bieng a AMD Fan Boy - ( which of course i am ), ill agree that the fx-53 is also just as guilty as the EE of bieng superflouse and overpriced, but, to AMD's - and every one not called felix's credit, yes, the unlocked mulipliers r a bonus :)

what would intrest me is how well felix's EE would go against my 3200+ clawhammer @ 2.5GHz......... ( which cost me £140 )
karlos
 

FelixDeCat

Lifer
Aug 4, 2000
31,075
2,706
126
Originally posted by: karlreading
i have to say this: this felix blokes a bit of a knob end :)
no ones having a go at the p4EE, there just laying down the facts: its overpriced in comparison to the power it offers. BIG TIME!!
and,heres one for ya: when intel reles the 6xx series ( p4ee under diffrent name - 2meg cache ) do you think they will charge a premium for that, or will it be much more moderatly priced part as its not called Extremly Expensive!!! ( and looks like it will be more mainstream ).

Oh, and before i get accused of bieng a AMD Fan Boy - ( which of course i am ), ill agree that the fx-53 is also just as guilty as the EE of bieng superflouse and overpriced, but, to AMD's - and every one not called felix's credit, yes, the unlocked mulipliers r a bonus :)

what would intrest me is how well felix's EE would go against my 3200+ clawhammer @ 2.5GHz......... ( which cost me £140 )
karlos

Blimey! Heres a :beer: for ya! :)
 

Markfw

Moderator Emeritus, Elite Member
May 16, 2002
27,324
16,155
136
Originally posted by: karlreading
i have to say this: this felix blokes a bit of a knob end :)
no ones having a go at the p4EE, there just laying down the facts: its overpriced in comparison to the power it offers. BIG TIME!!
and,heres one for ya: when intel reles the 6xx series ( p4ee under diffrent name - 2meg cache ) do you think they will charge a premium for that, or will it be much more moderatly priced part as its not called Extremly Expensive!!! ( and looks like it will be more mainstream ).

Oh, and before i get accused of bieng a AMD Fan Boy - ( which of course i am ), ill agree that the fx-53 is also just as guilty as the EE of bieng superflouse and overpriced, but, to AMD's - and every one not called felix's credit, yes, the unlocked mulipliers r a bonus :)

what would intrest me is how well felix's EE would go against my 3200+ clawhammer @ 2.5GHz......... ( which cost me £140 )
karlos
Well, since you are running only 100 mhz below the new 4000+, and 100 over the 3800+, I would guess 3900+, whcih means in games at least your would beat Felix's match in theory, since at the same rated speed, the Athlon64 wins out against the P4 and EE. But it is senseless to argue that with Felix, he would just call you a troll like us.
 

Mik3y

Banned
Mar 2, 2004
7,089
0
0
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
Originally posted by: karlreading
i have to say this: this felix blokes a bit of a knob end :)
no ones having a go at the p4EE, there just laying down the facts: its overpriced in comparison to the power it offers. BIG TIME!!
and,heres one for ya: when intel reles the 6xx series ( p4ee under diffrent name - 2meg cache ) do you think they will charge a premium for that, or will it be much more moderatly priced part as its not called Extremly Expensive!!! ( and looks like it will be more mainstream ).

Oh, and before i get accused of bieng a AMD Fan Boy - ( which of course i am ), ill agree that the fx-53 is also just as guilty as the EE of bieng superflouse and overpriced, but, to AMD's - and every one not called felix's credit, yes, the unlocked mulipliers r a bonus :)

what would intrest me is how well felix's EE would go against my 3200+ clawhammer @ 2.5GHz......... ( which cost me £140 )
karlos

Blimey! Heres a :beer: for ya! :)

felix, you are such an idiot. you dont believe benchmarks, reviews, and other facts about amd vs intel. all you believe in is your bias towards intel, which is pretty stupid. you call so many of us trolls, but what about posts like the one i just quoted? you seem like a troll to me.
 

FelixDeCat

Lifer
Aug 4, 2000
31,075
2,706
126
Originally posted by: Mik3y
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
Originally posted by: karlreading
i have to say this: this felix blokes a bit of a knob end :)
no ones having a go at the p4EE, there just laying down the facts: its overpriced in comparison to the power it offers. BIG TIME!!
and,heres one for ya: when intel reles the 6xx series ( p4ee under diffrent name - 2meg cache ) do you think they will charge a premium for that, or will it be much more moderatly priced part as its not called Extremly Expensive!!! ( and looks like it will be more mainstream ).

Oh, and before i get accused of bieng a AMD Fan Boy - ( which of course i am ), ill agree that the fx-53 is also just as guilty as the EE of bieng superflouse and overpriced, but, to AMD's - and every one not called felix's credit, yes, the unlocked mulipliers r a bonus :)

what would intrest me is how well felix's EE would go against my 3200+ clawhammer @ 2.5GHz......... ( which cost me £140 )
karlos

Blimey! Heres a :beer: for ya! :)

felix, you are such an idiot. you dont believe benchmarks, reviews, and other facts about amd vs intel. all you believe in is your bias towards intel, which is pretty stupid. you call so many of us trolls, but what about posts like the one i just quoted? you seem like a troll to me.

I dont even know or care who are. You wouldnt be in this thread if you didnt post in it - so dont!



 

EightySix Four

Diamond Member
Jul 17, 2004
5,122
52
91
This is totally sad, even to a 14 year old... Have you guys ever heard this quote?

"Arguing over the internet is like the special olympics... Even if you win you are still retarded..."

You "adults" need to learn this one more than even I do, I know I've gotten into some arguments on the net like this, but this is bleedin rediculous. PEOPLE ARE COMING HERE FOR HELP AND YOU GIVE THEM THIS USELESS B$ STFU AND GET OVER IT!

People come here for help:
1. felix, until you backup your claims, stfu, cuz your not helping
2. Everone else just ignore him, help the people that need it and give solid backup to your claims, people will see the solid back up and make THEIR OWN DECISION

just my useless 2cents
 

karlreading

Member
Aug 17, 2004
109
0
0
the trouble is, thers fan boy-ism and then theres just thinking that your clever.

I love AMD. I think there great, personally i hate intel, and i say that without question or remourse.

That said im also fair. I dont mind admiting that when it comes to photoshop and encoding with some codecs, the p4 does come out better than any of the k8's. I also dont mind admiting that Hyperthreading is a very trick piece of kit. But then i have to admit that ( in true happy fan boy sense ) that the k8 is very strong in games. Its also very strong in linux kernal compiling and many other things the k8 has a lead over intels best.

but come on felix, be a man and admit this, and we'll respect you a lot more: yes, your happy with your EE, yes, its a prestigiouse chip, yes it sounds really good to tell your friends, and yes, its very fast. but YES a p4 560 is cheaper, more desirable and and faster and, more importantly, delivers far more for your £'ssss. That coupled with the fact, if you want a pc for bragging rights, surley the p4 560's lga-775 pakage, pci-e and ddr2 marchitecture sound a lot more impressive to your friends ( if thats what gets u going). I know from the rig that i have got, i would be a lot more " jelouse " of someone who had a fully loaded 560/ddr2/pci-e rig than a p4-ee/i875/ddr400 rig, as there the cutting edge tech, and, IMHO, thats far more impressive than paying twice the price for a cpu thats not as quick, runs older tech and a northwood core but has 2 meg of cache. dont forget you could prolly get a i915 mob and half of the ddr2 for your system with the diff between the 560 and the EE.
karlos

 

iwantanewcomputer

Diamond Member
Apr 4, 2004
5,045
0
0
yeah, tom just posts tons of synthetic benchmarks that a) are chosen to perform better on intel systems than on amd, and 2) show the same thing over and over whenever intel wins, he just picks a lot of similar benchmarks and posts them, and when amd wins, there is one benckhmark

nobody around here trusts toms site cause look at 90% of the other revieew sites and they are different conclusions than toms
 

PsharkJF

Senior member
Jul 12, 2004
653
0
0
Ya know, common practice for showing others what you have posted on a message board is not to show them edited topics with the first post removed by the OP.

In other words, Felix, nobody knows what you posted, and therefore, who was at fault for getting flamed, because you decided to edit it out. Brilliant!

That being said, Felix, you have not offered any provable counters to my logic. In fact, this time, you are resorting to personal attacks. In a place where you are attepting to provide logical proof that your purchase and promotion of the Pentium 4 Extreme Edition CPU was one that gave you the best amount of performance, price not included, resorting to personal attacks means you lose the argument. Calling everyone on this forum trolls means you lose.

In fact, that is true for any intellectual argument - personally attacking the opponents character and not their position is addressing nothing.
 

Markfw

Moderator Emeritus, Elite Member
May 16, 2002
27,324
16,155
136
Originally posted by: crazySOB297
Can we please make his thread the end of the "Felix Fights"?
You have a good point, hoever, Felix will never stop posting "fud", and that is why everybody here is trying to make sure the OP understands that Felix is the 1 in a 1000 that is out out line, so (in your own words, and good ones at that) the Op CAN get some useful information, and believe its true! Virtually every reply in this thread (other than Felix) had some kind of useful information in it (and no I didn't count)

On-topic: again everyone else here says:
1) The FX-53 is king in gaming (at the same amount of OC'ing)
2) In the Intel court, the 560 is a better value
3) In the AMD court the 3800 is a better value
4) The P4EE is a rediculous amount of money to pay for not the best performer.

And last, most people think (including Anand) that at the moment AMD is the better value in most all monetary segments. (value, mainstream, and top end)

 

Zebo

Elite Member
Jul 29, 2001
39,398
19
81
Originally posted by: crazySOB297
Can we please make his thread the end of the "Felix Fights"?

...blame society for the criminals behavoir? Na he get whats coming, take a look.
 

Mik3y

Banned
Mar 2, 2004
7,089
0
0
Originally posted by: Markfw900
Originally posted by: crazySOB297
Can we please make his thread the end of the "Felix Fights"?
You have a good point, hoever, Felix will never stop posting "fud", and that is why everybody here is trying to make sure the OP understands that Felix is the 1 in a 1000 that is out out line, so (in your own words, and good ones at that) the Op CAN get some useful information, and believe its true! Virtually every reply in this thread (other than Felix) had some kind of useful information in it (and no I didn't count)

On-topic: again everyone else here says:
1) The FX-53 is king in gaming (at the same amount of OC'ing)
2) In the Intel court, the 560 is a better value
3) In the AMD court the 3800 is a better value
4) The P4EE is a rediculous amount of money to pay for not the best performer.

And last, most people think (including Anand) that at the moment AMD is the better value in most all monetary segments. (value, mainstream, and top end)

beautifully said :)
 

FelixDeCat

Lifer
Aug 4, 2000
31,075
2,706
126
I leave the thread for one second and trolls pop out of their holes!

I have proven that I am the man. What I say is the truth. Everyone is jealous of me and my CPU and LCD.

I win, again. :wine:

ps. Id like to thank my suporters out there. Lots of :heart: to you! :)
 

Mik3y

Banned
Mar 2, 2004
7,089
0
0
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
I leave the thread for one second and trolls pop out of their holes!

I have proven that I am the man. What I say is the truth. Everyone is jealous of me and my CPU and LCD.

I win, again. :wine:

ps. Id like to thank my suporters out there. Lots of :heart: to you! :)

I leave the thread for one second and Felix poops out of his hole!

Felix, all you have proven is that you are a queer woman. What you say are lies. The only thing everyone is jealous about is the fact that you are the epitome of an idiot. its so sad no one can be on top of things like you can, *sigh*.

Actually, you lose again. :wine:

P.S. I'd like to thank Felix's opposers out there. Lots of :heart: to you! :)
 
Jan 31, 2002
40,819
2
0
Your choice of CPU doesn't piss me off, Felix.

It makes me shake my head at your blatant disbelief of reality.

But no, it doesn't piss me off.

- M4H
 

DAPUNISHER

Super Moderator CPU Forum Mod and Elite Member
Super Moderator
Aug 22, 2001
32,117
32,692
146
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
I leave the thread for one second and trolls pop out of their holes!

I have proven that I am the man. What I say is the truth. Everyone is jealous of me and my CPU and LCD.

I win, again. :wine:

ps. Id like to thank my suporters out there. Lots of :heart: to you! :)
You keep ringing that bell Felix, and we'll need a mop n here soon ;)

 
Jan 31, 2002
40,819
2
0
Originally posted by: DAPUNISHER
Originally posted by: FelixDeKat
I leave the thread for one second and trolls pop out of their holes!

I have proven that I am the man. What I say is the truth. Everyone is jealous of me and my CPU and LCD.

I win, again. :wine:

ps. Id like to thank my suporters out there. Lots of :heart: to you! :)
You keep ringing that bell Felix, and we'll need a mop n here soon ;)

I told you to stop after a dozen :beer:, but you just wouldn't listen. :p

- M4H