*EDIT* Mac vs. PC Flame war

Page 8 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Wahsapa

Diamond Member
Jul 2, 2001
3,004
0
0
Originally posted by: TheGeek
Originally posted by: deathkoba
Originally posted by: sparkyclarky
Originally posted by: deathkoba
$2100 isn't bad at all for one of the best laptops money can buy. It runs a dependable and robust operating system that's easy to troubleshoot (in the rare case should you need to) and it looks quite beautiful. Other pluses include ability to run the latest and greatest graphics applications smoothly since the system is designed from the ground up for real design. It's also based on Unix which is far more stable than WinBLOZE eXPEE. Dells are cheap but just LOOK at them. They're built like toys, heavy and extremely ugly. The only decent laptops on the PeeCee world I've seen are the Thinkpads but they are similarly priced as the Powerbooks. I have a Thinkpad T23 and getting an X41 in the very near future. The only difference being I'm 26 and buy these things myself : ) I'd get a Powerbook when my job requires one which may be real soon if I get this job tomorrow...

You do realize that calling Windows XP "WinBLOZE eXPEE" and a PC "PeeCee" does nothing to strenghten your credibility as a neutral judge of computing hardware/software from which others should take advice?

Most of my computers are PeeCees and that's how I learned to pronounce them :roll:

OP, don't listen to these guys, they're just jealous and insecure about their cheap computers especially the AMD fanboys who constantly taunt how much superior their platform of choice is over others but always manage to throw in the word "value" into their argument. They're just cheap or poor bastards who have no idea what tailoring really means or just don't have the mental capacity to appreciate something of fine taste...hence the really fast movement of the "Hot Deals" forum :roll:

Value is important though..but it's just one of many things to consider when purchasing anything.

Here's what I've learned from these "hot deals."

What good is a cheap $700 PC laptop when it isn't something YOU REALLY want? What good is it if it doesn't do what you intend on using it for very well even if it meant it'll sort of get you by? What good is it when you don't even like looking at it? $700 in that case would simply be a WASTE of money.

Get what YOU WANT and forget about the extra bit of cash you've spent and just enjoy the freakin thing.

You already love your current Mac and decided on the platform as it suites your needs.

Get the Powerbook however the hell you can.

Thank you. finally someone with a maturity level

AHAHAHHAHAAH!!

i bet nobodys ever told that to deathkoba before


edit: and i saw this a couple posts down

Originally posted by: Schadenfroh
Originally posted by: TheGeek
Originally posted by: suse920
Originally posted by: TheGeek
Originally posted by: HamburgerBoy
Originally posted by: TheGeek
My windows PC crashed today and i wasnt even using it. it just randomly crashed to the BSOD.

Upgrade from Windows 95 plz.

Im running XP. thanks though

learn how to use the OS then.

if you can read, i wasnt even using it. it was just sitting there

My windows xp machine has not crashed in weeks and i have not rebooted it in a month.

1. Is your hardware overheating?
2. Do you have malware?
3. Are you having driver problems?

response:
things OS X users don't have to worry about...
 

konakona

Diamond Member
May 6, 2004
6,285
1
0
Originally posted by: 91TTZ
Originally posted by: TheGeek
Originally posted by: Ornery
...the Mini was only $600

Christ, you could have gotten SO MUCH PC for less than that! You are such a typical Mac hype swallower, I'd be embarrassed to death if I were your dad!

Have you ever even used a Mac?? You sound like a Windows hype swallower.

I've used a Mac. I just can't get into them. No offense to people, but the interface seems a bit "fruity" or "metrosexual" to me. I just don't like it. Too artsy and flamboyant.

that, and slow, less responsive, unintuitive and so on. Time and again I post my observation of what goes on at our school's computer cluster : people form a line to avoid OS X rigged macs and use XP rigged dells instead. so much for being user friendly and superior.
 

suse920

Diamond Member
Feb 7, 2005
6,889
0
0
Originally posted by: DurocShark
Originally posted by: TheGeek
Originally posted by: EyeMNathan
Why cant you buy a computer under 18? Did you mean you don't have any money of your own?

How am I suppose to buy a $2100 laptop?? It's not that I don't have the money, its that I have no way to buy it (ex. credit card).


My 14 year old son has a debit card on his personal account.

wow they let him do that? At 15 i could only get an atm card.
 

imported_goku

Diamond Member
Mar 28, 2004
7,613
3
0
Originally posted by: TheGeek
A few months ago, I convinced my dad to let me buy a Mac Mini. I am under 18, thus I cant buy it myself. After a few months of use, I've decided I want to completely "switch" and sell my Windows PC for a 15" Powerbook. Whereas the Mini was only $600, the Powerbook will be about $2100. My Dad hasn't changed his standpoint that Mac's suck, so that makes things harder.

His arguments against:
Its a waste of money (?????)
Macs Suck

My arguments for:
I want it
Wont use as much electricity
I Hate Windows, Love OS X
Wont have to borrow his laptop again.
I'll show him http://www.xvsxp.com/

One of my ideas to help sway his mind is to let him use my Mini for a few days to prove that Macs dont suck. Anyone else have any other ideas for me? Thanks.

*EDIT* Cliff Notes
1. Post a simple problem on ATOT.
2. Flame war

This feels like it's a repost for some disturbing reason. It's practically word for word, I remember a post like this a while back and now it's back agian! (Checks OP post date and it's confirmed, this is a new post.)
 

imported_goku

Diamond Member
Mar 28, 2004
7,613
3
0
Originally posted by: vegetation
If you want to impress your dad, find the cheapest celeron-m system you can get. I'll bet he get it for you.

What happened to people purchasing used IBM laptops? :confused:
 

tami

Lifer
Nov 14, 2004
11,588
3
81
Originally posted by: daniel1113
Originally posted by: tami
Originally posted by: TheGeek
I'll show him http://www.xvsxp.com/

that's a cool website.

Yeah, it really puts the final nail in the whole OS X vs XP debate.

i'm not saying it's the ultimate decision maker. it just gives an interesting perspective. i wouldn't make any deductions based on a single opinion. but if it helps him, then it's good enough.
 

imported_goku

Diamond Member
Mar 28, 2004
7,613
3
0
Originally posted by: AmberClad
$2100 for a machine you can't even game on. Are you nuts???

You could buy a cheapo laptop, and have enough left over to buy or build a pimped out gaming desktop.

I would agree with both of your Dad's points. Apple's producted are far overpriced and generally used by people who value pretty looks over substance/value and buy what's "in".

Since you say that Windows suck, I would have to assume that you're not a gamer, since the selection of Mac games is very limited and generally released much later than PC versions. Which begs the question what you're going to use the laptop for. If it's to do word processing and use the web, then you're even more nuts to ask your Dad to spend $2100 on it.

Finally a sane person with a very very good point! You make your point and you appear to be rational! Bravo!
 

imported_goku

Diamond Member
Mar 28, 2004
7,613
3
0
Originally posted by: Lorn
Originally posted by: mchammer
If you really want an Apple so bad, you should sell everything and get a G5 tower. A powerbook would be just as slow as a mini.

I am extremely happy with my G5. It is quick as hell when multitasking between Soundtrack Pro, Final Cut Pro and Motion. Not to mention that Logic Pro 7 has the hands down best audio engine I've ever used for audio production. Add in other applications designed for the mac, like Cinema 4D, Sketchup, DVD Studio Pro and Digital Performer and you have everything you need for a multimedia task. Oh, and include an incredible case with both function and style...

Gaming is minor at best on it, though. I play Halo, UT2004, AA, Call of Duty, Medal of Honor, Black Hawk Down, Doom 3 and Splinter Cell but that's about it. That is why I built myself a PC for gaming. It is much louder, much uglier and much more cluttered, but it can churn out beautiful frames very well - much better than my G5.

I work on my G5 and play on my PC.

If you think that's fast, try a P4, it'll knock the socks off of it. I think there was a news article on anandtech about how the developers for the mac platform tried out the Intel macs and they talked about how they were "very fast".
 

secretanchitman

Diamond Member
Apr 11, 2001
9,352
23
91
wow...i think you should just get whatever you want. forget what all these people are saying, well, most of them. its your money, your parents, your everything. just think what you really want and what you are/will really going to do with it. think about price, features, casing (power/i - titanium/plastic i think), and whatnot. just go with whatever you think is right.
 

AmberClad

Diamond Member
Jul 23, 2005
4,914
0
0
Originally posted by: secretanchitman
wow...i think you should just get whatever you want. forget what all these people are saying, well, most of them. its your money, your parents, your everything. just think what you really want and what you are/will really going to do with it. think about price, features, casing (power/i - titanium/plastic i think), and whatnot. just go with whatever you think is right.



I'm sure he knows what he wants. Thing is, his original post, before the edit, explicitly asked us for ways to convince his Dad to help him buy a Powerbook. You ask for an opinion, you'll get it.
 

thirdlegstump

Banned
Feb 12, 2001
8,713
0
0
If you think that's fast, try a P4, it'll knock the socks off of it. I think there was a news article on anandtech about how the developers for the mac platform tried out the Intel macs and they talked about how they were "very fast".

The article talks about OS X on Apple's Intel Dev. hardware and not Windows. If you've ever done any serious work on both platforms you'll find that OS X does multitasking FAR smoother than Windows XP could ever dream of doing. IE: Simply insert a CDROM into a Windows box while you're doing something requiring realtime system attention and you'll see something absolutely wonderful..not.

Gaming will always be more efficient and abundant on the popular consumer majority platform but there ARE people who uses computers for far more different tasks that actually makes them MONEY. That's when these things become TOOLS and the right tools will often cost more money than a hack tool. It'll reward you back later. Now that tool doesn't have to be a Mac, it could be a Playstation for all I care.

That's the end of the discussion as I'm right and you're all wrong who dare to think otherwise.

I'm not even a Mac "fan" in any sense of the word btw.

Also what's so wrong about wanting something eh? We all want something and if it's possible to own it, why the hell not?
 

Robor

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
16,979
0
76
Originally posted by: 91TTZ
Apple does a great job advertising and catering to a very specific market. The problem is that I hate just about all of their commercials and products. Everything seems to have a "fruity" quality to them that I just find weird and awkward. That's probably that same thing that draws some people to them.

Just as pink T-shirts and popped collars appeals to some guys, it strongly turns others off. Apple is the pink T-shirt/popped collar crowd.


Sure pink shirts and popped collars (why did those come back?) are great but don't forget that your hair needs frosted tips to go with them! ;) :p

 

konakona

Diamond Member
May 6, 2004
6,285
1
0
Originally posted by: deathkoba
If you think that's fast, try a P4, it'll knock the socks off of it. I think there was a news article on anandtech about how the developers for the mac platform tried out the Intel macs and they talked about how they were "very fast".

The article talks about OS X on Apple's Intel Dev. hardware and not Windows. If you've ever done any serious work on both platforms you'll find that OS X does multitasking FAR smoother than Windows XP could ever dream of doing. IE: Simply insert a CDROM into a Windows box while you're doing something requiring realtime system attention and you'll see something absolutely wonderful..not.

Gaming will always be more efficient and abundant on the popular consumer majority platform but there ARE people who uses computers for far more different tasks that actually makes them MONEY. That's when these things become TOOLS and the right tools will often cost more money than a hack tool. It'll reward you back later. Now that tool doesn't have to be a Mac, it could be a Playstation for all I care.

That's the end of the discussion as I'm right and you're all wrong who dare to think otherwise.

I'm not even a Mac "fan" in any sense of the word btw.

Also what's so wrong about wanting something eh? We all want something and if it's possible to own it, why the hell not?

I totally agree with you on choosing the proper tool thing, but wanting something double the cost just because you dont like XP sounds a bit out of place to me. Sure, it is his money, but preference for OS is not really a task-oriented mindset. IMO, this so-called "multitasking" thingy has much less significance to end-users whose tasks arent really time ciritical.
 

ryan256

Platinum Member
Jul 22, 2005
2,514
0
71
For me the arguement of whether macs are better than PCs is like the arguement of whether cats are better than dogs. Both are great. They are just for different people.
I work at a college campus where I support both Windows 2000/XP and Mac OS9/X systems. The following opinions are based on experiences supporting these systems. OS9 is garbage. There is so much it can't do that I'm not even going to bother enumerating them. OSX on the otherhand isn't too bad. It works and does what its supposed to for the most part. For the mac zaelots out there that say OSX is far more reliable and crash proof than windows.. BS!! I have worked with several OSX systems that crashed repeatedly. The worst part about OSX crashes is the system doesn't give you any indication about what went wrong. It simply states an error occured and your system has to restart. As for really getting into the guts of the system and modifying it the way you want I still think windows is easier. I'm sure the same can be accomplished on the mac as the core of OSX is essentially linux (FreeBSD I think?), I just thing registry edits are easier. The inclusion of Active Directory support for OSX.4 was a good idea as this makes the systems much more usable in an office environment. Oh... and Apple, enough of the damn broadcast protocols! I can understand still supporting Appletalk for the sake of backwards compatability, but Rendezvous is just stupid! All you need is TCP/IP.

In the end though it all really boils down to what you want from the computer.
 

Trader05

Diamond Member
Mar 1, 2000
5,096
20
81
Yeah, if i had a kid and he/she wanted a mac, i wouldn't pay for it. Plain and simple
 

EmperorIQ

Platinum Member
Sep 30, 2003
2,003
0
0
didn't read the whole thread.

are you going to college soon? If so, wait for a student discount then! you'll get a 15inch power book for 1600 or so.
 

imported_goku

Diamond Member
Mar 28, 2004
7,613
3
0
Originally posted by: deathkoba
If you think that's fast, try a P4, it'll knock the socks off of it. I think there was a news article on anandtech about how the developers for the mac platform tried out the Intel macs and they talked about how they were "very fast".

The article talks about OS X on Apple's Intel Dev. hardware and not Windows. If you've ever done any serious work on both platforms you'll find that OS X does multitasking FAR smoother than Windows XP could ever dream of doing. IE: Simply insert a CDROM into a Windows box while you're doing something requiring realtime system attention and you'll see something absolutely wonderful..not.

Gaming will always be more efficient and abundant on the popular consumer majority platform but there ARE people who uses computers for far more different tasks that actually makes them MONEY. That's when these things become TOOLS and the right tools will often cost more money than a hack tool. It'll reward you back later. Now that tool doesn't have to be a Mac, it could be a Playstation for all I care.

That's the end of the discussion as I'm right and you're all wrong who dare to think otherwise.

I'm not even a Mac "fan" in any sense of the word btw.

Also what's so wrong about wanting something eh? We all want something and if it's possible to own it, why the hell not?


Deathkoba, after getting to know you, I've started to realise your posts aren't serious and I find you to be amusing :) No but seriously though, there is plenty of PC only software making people so much money that I'm sure makes "movie producers" look like homeless hobos.
 

g8wayrebel

Senior member
Nov 15, 2004
694
0
0
Originally posted by: TheGeek
Originally posted by: DaWhim
what is with the kids these day? too spoiled and now they are whining on atot. :roll:

get a friiking job and buy whatever you please with your own money.

/thread.

If people could read, you'd see that I have the money but don't want to buy it at the store b/c of outrageous taxes and dont have a credit or debit card to purchase online. Plus, I don't want to go behind my dads back and buy something that he didn't give me permission too. that would be disrespectful.


Use direct withdrawal from checking with Paypal.
 

Fox5

Diamond Member
Jan 31, 2005
5,957
7
81
Originally posted by: TheGeek
A few months ago, I convinced my dad to let me buy a Mac Mini. I am under 18, thus I cant buy it myself. After a few months of use, I've decided I want to completely "switch" and sell my Windows PC for a 15" Powerbook. Whereas the Mini was only $600, the Powerbook will be about $2100. My Dad hasn't changed his standpoint that Mac's suck, so that makes things harder.

His arguments against:
Its a waste of money (?????)
Macs Suck

My arguments for:
I want it
Wont use as much electricity
I Hate Windows, Love OS X
Wont have to borrow his laptop again.
I'll show him http://www.xvsxp.com/

One of my ideas to help sway his mind is to let him use my Mini for a few days to prove that Macs dont suck. Anyone else have any other ideas for me? Thanks.

*EDIT* Cliff Notes
1. Post a simple problem on ATOT.
2. Flame war

The only advantage Macs have over PCs is maybe style if you prefer their style, and maybe the OS if you prefer the OS. No hardware advantage, they don't use less power, they aren't cheaper, they don't have as many features.

If you wait a few months, at least you can get Macs running Centrino, and thus get equal hardware to PC and closer to matching pricecs and equal power consumption/heat generation.

Why do you hate Windows so much? Just to tell you, there are GUI replacements for Windows that mimic the Mac interface like 99%. And if it's just a "I don't wanna use Windows!" thing then there is Linspire and Mandrake, both Linux distros made to be easy to use.

BTW, as far as stability, I've found that Windows XP SP2 is the most stable Windows ever(even above Server 2003), at least when kept clear of virii and spyware, and using good hardware.(go cheap on the hardware and you're asking for problems, at least on the Mac you can't go cheap on hardware) As far as smoothness, I'd imagine that a dual core system with tons of ram > any mac. Anyhow, I've found XP SP2 is actually even more stable than any Linux distro I've used. Even just in casual use of those, I somehow manage to have those crash on me within a few days of use.
I'd imagine macs are about as stable as you can get though, they only have like 3 hardware sets to support.

Anyhow, if you must must have a mac, wait for Mac Intel.
 

imported_goku

Diamond Member
Mar 28, 2004
7,613
3
0
Originally posted by: Fox5

I'd imagine macs are about as stable as you can get though, they only have like 3 hardware sets to support.

I disagree, they have to support many sets of hardware though they've designed all of their systems so it doesn't really matter. Macs are IMO very very unreliable for how proprietary they are. I mean windows has to support tons of configurations and be stable while the mac has to support many many fewer configurations. For such a proprietary setup, I expect the systems to be super reliable but they're not and it's quite sad to see something crash on something it was DESIGNED for.
 

dquan97

Lifer
Jul 9, 2002
12,010
3
0
Save up your $$ and use it to finance your college. After you graduate and get a job, treat yourself to a mac.