apoppin re-evaluates nvidia [Formerly nm] ... back to x1950p

Page 13 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

tuteja1986

Diamond Member
Jun 1, 2005
3,676
0
0
OKAY this thread has turned alot of people crazy. So Lets end the fighting and go to fact :

apoppin got screwed over by Sapphire and he is know on crusade against all of ATI

Bug777 is confused

AMD share not doing good because of idiots at wall streets :( looking to drop below $14 soon.

Nvidia very happy : )

Innovation is loosing the war as Nvidia and Intel armies go ever deeper into enemy territory. NVIDIA excepts a decisive victory and Intel isn?t sure of total victory to grantee to them total market share.

Future looks bad for tech world !!
 

Paratus

Lifer
Jun 4, 2004
17,536
15,605
146
Originally posted by: tuteja1986
OKAY this thread has turned alot of people crazy. So Lets end the fighting and go to fact :

apoppin got screwed over by Sapphire and he is know on crusade against all of ATI

Bug777 is confused

AMD share not doing good because of idiots at wall streets :( looking to drop below $14 soon.

Nvidia very happy : )

Innovation is loosing the war as Nvidia and Intel armies go ever deeper into enemy territory. NVIDIA excepts a decisively victory and Intel isnt sure of total victory to grantee to them total market share.

Future looks bad for tech world !!

Sounds like a good time to buy AMD stock.
 

Keysplayr

Elite Member
Jan 16, 2003
21,211
50
91
Originally posted by: ronnn
Originally posted by: dug777

You calling me a liar?

He's our new trollo, just ignore. :wine:

Wow, the guy you have repeatedly backed up for the past few years suddenly becomes "trollo" because he bought an nvidia card and is happy with it and argue's against somebody who does not, or can not believe it? Who's the troll here?
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: keysplayr2003
Originally posted by: ronnn
Originally posted by: dug777

You calling me a liar?

He's our new trollo, just ignore. :wine:

Wow, the guy you have repeatedly backed up for the past few years suddenly becomes "trollo" because he bought an nvidia card and is happy with it and argue's against somebody who does not, or can not believe it? Who's the troll here?
thanks Keys ... yep, its really obvious the trolls *never accept change*

. . . and they tend to call you what they actually are ;)

strangely ... after years solely with ATi GPUs .. they cannot accept i really like BOTH cards
:confused:

i guess i was supposed to *hate* the GS :p
well, i don't

and i still *like* my x1950p ... but it is not *practical* for me at this time ... nor am i 100% confident with Sapphire at this time
---------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by: CaiNaM
Originally posted by: apoppin
EDIT: just saw your reply, CaiNaM makes total *sense* that nvidia would have fixed shimmering

and what is is about the Warranty ... are nvidia partners Starting to do what Sapphire does ... charge for RMA processing? or just PowerColor and ati partners? :Q

that sucks ...

well, the point i was trying to make was that it seems overall, nvidia's parters seem to offer better warranties overall.. there may be nv partner's like foxcomm that don't offer great warranties, but it was just my observation that, at least on the surface, it seems nv's partners offer better support...
it just looks like ATis' partner's warranties are getting *worse* ... i will "add it in" to my future AMD Graphics card purchase ... 'peanuts' on a new card ... but it makes the partners look *cheap* [they are] by nickel and dimeing their customers on warranty service.
======================================
Originally posted by: tuteja1986
OKAY this thread has turned alot of people crazy. So Lets end the fighting and go to fact :

apoppin got screwed over by Sapphire and he is know on crusade against all of ATI
total BS not "fact" ... i *did not* get screwed over by Sapphire ... my X1950p went the "normal RMA route" ... i still think their RMA policy "scam" stinks --it makes them look really *cheap* ... but that has *nothing* to do with their cards or changed my feelings for ATi whatsoever

Bug777 is confused
as usual ... what's new? - he argues with himself most of the time

AMD share not doing good because of idiots at wall streets :( looking to drop below $14 soon.

Nvidia very happy : )

Innovation is loosing the war as Nvidia and Intel armies go ever deeper into enemy territory. NVIDIA excepts a decisive victory and Intel isn?t sure of total victory to grantee to them total market share.

Future looks bad for tech world !!
100% beside the point ... and unrelated to this topic ... but we already know. AMD is having a streak of bad luck after a couple of years of stasis when they should have gone for intel's throat ... don't blame ME for THEIR stupidity ... and r600 is not "competitive" ... gotta be some sloppy engineering to miss something that *big* at the last hour

don't blame me for their woes ... if i was an investor, i know i'd be getting really nervous to have the CEO tell us that they don't have a competitive product and no date set for one -except "Q2"

:thumbsdown:


i just tell it like i see it ... every case is different

i know it upsets some people . ... of either religion --nvidia or ATi ... and sometimes both 'faiths' simultaneously.

too bad :p

and yeah, i DO tend to *like* what's in my rig ... after all i picked it ... and IF i am dissatisfied for ANY reason, i reserve the right to replace it with something i am happy with
:laugh:
 

DeathReborn

Platinum Member
Oct 11, 2005
2,786
789
136
All this bickering is quite pathetic.

I went from a 7800GT SLI to X1800XT CF machine without noticing anything different while PLAYING games (I don't stand there while ppl shoot at me). Using Catalyst 6.6 & FW 91.31 at the time if I recall.

Now my dad has the 7800's & he went from a FX5200, now that was noticeable. Going from the 7800GT's & X1800XT's to 8800GTS SLI wasn't that big a deal either, just much much faster.

Fact of the matter is, game PLAYERS don't pay attention to little details but instead prefer to have fun with their equipment.

Oh and apoppin, as for your 7800GS/X1950pro 3DMark 05 scores, I used to get 7300 (7800GT @ Stock 400/1000) & 8200 (7800GT @ 500/1200) using a A64 3500+. SLi was up in 11k-12k.

At earlier points you could see visible shimmering as it was really bad in some games but in later drivers it was not that visible at all. Fanboys on both sides exaggerated problems, still do.
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: DeathReborn
All this bickering is quite pathetic.

I went from a 7800GT SLI to X1800XT CF machine without noticing anything different while PLAYING games (I don't stand there while ppl shoot at me). Using Catalyst 6.6 & FW 91.31 at the time if I recall.

Now my dad has the 7800's & he went from a FX5200, now that was noticeable. Going from the 7800GT's & X1800XT's to 8800GTS SLI wasn't that big a deal either, just much much faster.

Fact of the matter is, game PLAYERS don't pay attention to little details but instead prefer to have fun with their equipment.

Oh and apoppin, as for your 7800GS/X1950pro 3DMark 05 scores, I used to get 7300 (7800GT @ Stock 400/1000) & 8200 (7800GT @ 500/1200) using a A64 3500+. SLi was up in 11k-12k.

At earlier points you could see visible shimmering as it was really bad in some games but in later drivers it was not that visible at all. Fanboys on both sides exaggerated problems, still do.
bickering?!? ... i am *defending* myself from attacks of being a *new kind* of fanboy ... an 'elitist' who only like his current card
[ridiculous, i know but it doesn't stop the fanboys for seeing me as a *traitor*] :p

and it's cool to see you - another gamer - who loves his games more than their HW they play it on
:thumbsup:

i *know* your A64-3500+ can do better than my P4 ... but my scores are well in the *ballpark* for my rig and not that far behind yours [considering].

yeah i can *see* shimmering ... barely ... i also saw it on my x850xt when i was being *critical* ... not a problem *whatsoever* in regular game play. It isn't like "wow .. shimmering, i can't play this crap" ... it doesn't distract at all unless you are looking for it and the NPCs will frag your ass, anyway while you are admiring the scenery. :D

Seriously - *either card* is welcome in my rig ... i just don't feel like upgrading my PS now - to stick my x1950p back in.
[not knowing what r660 Xfire requirements really are]

and the fanboys will continue to disagree with me ... what's new? calling ME the "new Rollo" ... i think *he* would be very amused
:confused:

:roll:
 

ronnn

Diamond Member
May 22, 2003
3,918
0
71
Originally posted by: keysplayr2003
Originally posted by: ronnn
Originally posted by: dug777

You calling me a liar?

He's our new trollo, just ignore. :wine:

Wow, the guy you have repeatedly backed up for the past few years suddenly becomes "trollo" because he bought an nvidia card and is happy with it and argue's against somebody who does not, or can not believe it? Who's the troll here?

Just stating the obvious- don't argue with someone - who would rather get personal and misrepresent facts. Is frustrating and puts one in a bad mood for no reason. As for which is the better card - the agp 7800gs or the agp x1950pro 512mb - I will leave that to reputable reviews.
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: ronnn
Originally posted by: keysplayr2003
Originally posted by: ronnn
Originally posted by: dug777

You calling me a liar?

He's our new trollo, just ignore. :wine:

Wow, the guy you have repeatedly backed up for the past few years suddenly becomes "trollo" because he bought an nvidia card and is happy with it and argue's against somebody who does not, or can not believe it? Who's the troll here?

Just stating the obvious- don't argue with someone - who would rather get personal and misrepresent facts. Is frustrating and puts one in a bad mood for no reason. As for which is the better card - the agp 7800gs or the agp x1950pro 512mb - I will leave that to reputable reviews.

thanks for the warning about yourself ... you and Dug DO get personal and regularly misrepresent facts ... like now

since you can't even comprehend what i am posting, this is for others

X1950p is - definitely and without ANY question - the faster card but is not necessarily the "better" card ...

... that *depends* on your situation ;)

in my situation, i *prefer* the GS

and if Dug really wants one, i have a brand new agp x1950p for sale ... relatively cheap :p
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
[3/5 update] i might get *stuck* with my x1950p ...

the RMA period for my 7800GS OC is coming to an end - this week ... i MUST make a decision as my x1950p is NOT selling in FS/T [even with a free game bundled with it :D]
Sapphire AGP x1950p/512MB *Brand New* returned-from-RMA factory-sealed - $220 shipped

so ... if i don't sell it, i *will* buy a $200 PS [with the 'credit' i should have at NewEgg] and stick it back in my rig [after testing the x1950p - tomorrow - to make *sure* it is not DoA]

Are there any *comparisons* or *tests* you would like me to run on my 7800GS?
-Power Supply recommendations - for SLI 8800gtx ?
or - *suggestions* ?
 

ArchAngel777

Diamond Member
Dec 24, 2000
5,223
61
91
Originally posted by: apoppin
[3/5 update] i might get *stuck* with my x1950p ...

the RMA period for my 7800GS OC is coming to an end - this week ... i MUST make a decision as my x1950p is NOT selling in FS/T [even with a free game bundled with it :D]
Sapphire AGP x1950p/512MB *Brand New* returned-from-RMA factory-sealed - $220 shipped

so ... if i don't sell it, i *will* buy a $200 PS [with the 'credit' i should have at NewEgg] and stick it back in my rig [after testing the x1950p - tomorrow - to make *sure* it is not DoA]

Are there any *comparisons* or *tests* you would like me to run on my 7800GS?
-Power Supply recommendations - for SLI 8800gtx ?
or - *suggestions* ?


Why not drop the price 20 bucks? Sure, it might be new and in the package, but very often not having a receipt will make people think twice. I'd say drop it to $200 and see if anything bites. Then save the extra money for an entire system build for when Alan Wake/Crysis comes out. Just my thoughts.
 

Killrose

Diamond Member
Oct 26, 1999
6,230
8
81
Why not ebay it with a buy now price of $225 + $15 for shipping? I did a quick check of the going prices for completed listings and they are going for $245 with $12 or more in extra shipping tacked on. I'm not sure if yours is a retail or OEM card but you could possibly do better if you throw in a few old games too.
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: ArchAngel777
Originally posted by: apoppin

Why not drop the price 20 bucks? Sure, it might be new and in the package, but very often not having a receipt will make people think twice. I'd say drop it to $200 and see if anything bites. Then save the extra money for an entire system build for when Alan Wake/Crysis comes out. Just my thoughts.
Originally posted by: Killrose
Why not ebay it with a buy now price of $225 + $15 for shipping? I did a quick check of the going prices for completed listings and they are going for $245 with $12 or more in extra shipping tacked on. I'm not sure if yours is a retail or OEM card but you could possibly do better if you throw in a few old games too.

i don't like ebay .. the hassle for the 'extra' isn't worth it

as to dropping it $20 further ... i already offered a couple of games with it ... :p

there is a POINT where you don't want to *give it away* ... any new x1950p/512M is gonna cost $40 more and that "sapphire receipt" for a $15 RMA looks to be pretty much of a hassle anyway . ...

i am going to contact NewEgg tonight and start the 7800GS RMA process ... that way i lose *no money* ... i just get to buy my PS "in advance"
[sigh]

i think i can get a "nice" PS for $200 ... and if R600 xfire really takes 'more' than that - screw them, i'll pick up the 8900s for SLI

i don't mind a GPU from either company in my rig
:thumbsup:

looks like i am going back to ATi
rose.gif



think i am gonna be any "easier" on r600 and AMD's *screw up*?
:roll:

:laugh:
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
3-7 .... it doesn't look like anyone wants it [after *full disclosure* about Sapphire, i am NOT surprised] ... so i dropped the price to $210 with a game - shipped ... final offer

ANYWAY - NewEgg offered full credit on my 7800GS OC - provided i spend $200 on a Power Supply ... so i will buy it tonight and withdraw my x1950p from FS/T

What bang-for-buck *NewEgg only* PS for ~$200 will run SLI'd 8800GTX and Core2 Duo?

help please
 

Gstanfor

Banned
Oct 19, 1999
3,307
0
0
Knew it was too good to last :D

If you want a decent power supply, grab a Thermaltake 600W (for those who like to bash thermaltake, their PSU's above 500W are in a totally different league quality wise to their 400W units - forget what you *think* you know about their quality) If you think you will be using SLi/crossfire when you upgrade, go for the 850W unit.
 

nullpointerus

Golden Member
Apr 17, 2003
1,326
0
0
Originally posted by: apoppin
3-7 .... it doesn't look like anyone wants it [after *full disclosure* about Sapphire, i am NOT surprised] ... so i dropped the price to $210 with a game - shipped ... final offer

ANYWAY - NewEgg offered full credit on my 7800GS OC - provided i spend $200 on a Power Supply ... so i will buy it tonight and withdraw my x1950p from FS/T

What bang-for-buck *NewEgg only* PS for ~$200 will run SLI'd 8800GTX and Core2 Duo?

help please

You'll need 4 6-pin PCI-E power connectors, right? This one looks like the best in your price range:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16817256009

Modular cabling, many 12V rails with high amps, 120mm fan, very good reviews, and sleeved cables. That's the one I'd pick. Well, good luck with your X1950 Pro, apoppin!

EDIT: NewEgg also stocks the Thermaltake PSUs Gstanfor mentioned.
 

happy medium

Lifer
Jun 8, 2003
14,387
480
126
Originally posted by: nullpointerus
Originally posted by: apoppin
3-7 .... it doesn't look like anyone wants it [after *full disclosure* about Sapphire, i am NOT surprised] ... so i dropped the price to $210 with a game - shipped ... final offer

ANYWAY - NewEgg offered full credit on my 7800GS OC - provided i spend $200 on a Power Supply ... so i will buy it tonight and withdraw my x1950p from FS/T

What bang-for-buck *NewEgg only* PS for ~$200 will run SLI'd 8800GTX and Core2 Duo?

help please

Thats a nice psu.
150.00$ shipped here for the same psu.

http://www.eastluna.com/hardware/details.php?id=2169
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: Gstanfor
Knew it was too good to last :D

If you want a decent power supply, grab a Thermaltake 600W (for those who like to bash thermaltake, their PSU's above 500W are in a totally different league quality wise to their 400W units - forget what you *think* you know about their quality) If you think you will be using SLi/crossfire when you upgrade, go for the 850W unit.

of course ... but i have a new *respect* for nvidia GPUs ... and if the Power requirements of r600 are true ... just *forget* AMD ... i *will* go nvidia SLI ... NO way i am having a HOT, power hungry noisy beast with a crap warranty to boot

and i like TT PSes ... even mine was excellent bang for buck - THREE years age ... but i think 600w is a real *minimum*


is even the SilverStone 750w really sufficient for a *loaded* and o/c'd Core2 duo and sli'd GTXes? ... i am guessing the 8900's will not require much more power but will allow +10% for it.

looking for 'stability' and QUIET


$210 before tax/shipping is my *budget* --and i think 800w is more 'realistic'

and it's NewEgg .. all the way ... from now on :)

it *must be* NewEgg
[that's 'how" i don't get charged 15% restocking] ;)
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: happy medium
Check out the rails on this OCZ 850 watt gameXstream. 4--- 20 amp rails

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16817341003

It's in your budget too.

that's more like it. Probably Quad-core and Sli ... i'd like to be *safe* rather than sorry --for a few bucks.

i like it .... 850w and $215 with a $30 MIR = $185 :)

but it is [relatively] quiet?
:Q

and will it *fit* in my Aspire case?:p
--i don't want to set it on top the case
:shocked:
 

happy medium

Lifer
Jun 8, 2003
14,387
480
126
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: happy medium
Check out the rails on this OCZ 850 watt gameXstream. 4--- 20 amp rails

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16817341003

It's in your budget too.

that's more like it. Probably Quad-core and Sli ... i'd like to be *safe* rather than sorry --for a few bucks.

i like it .... 850w and $215 with a $30 MIR = $185 :)

but it is [relatively] quiet?
:Q

Here is some reviews on the bottom of the home page. Looks like it has a quiet 120mm.
fan. You can use that a reference.:beer:

http://www.ocztechnology.com/products/p...xstream_power_supply-nvidia_sli_ready_
 

happy medium

Lifer
Jun 8, 2003
14,387
480
126
Originally posted by: apoppin
finally ... my 'edit' was late

will it "fit" in my Aspire case?

i ain't modifying it [much] nor do i want to set it 'on top' my case :p)
:Q

:D

I can't find the size.... I keep comming up with the quote "The highly efficient GameXStream core is sheltered in a standard dimension chassis, resulting in a smaller footprint and more legroom for system-cooling modifications.

It sounds like you'll be good to go Apoppin.:thumbsup: