Ancalagon44
Diamond Member
- Feb 17, 2010
- 3,274
- 202
- 106
This movie was based on the theory that ALL time happens simultaneously. That any conceivable timeline that can happen, will happen. But still, most of the possibilities of time event occurring tend to be the same unless changed forcefully.
The effect they were going for with Kitty maintaining her projection of Wolverines consciousness to be broadcast back in time, is that the time stream is that the flow time is the same, and that all time runs at the same time. Meaning, the mind can be inserted into any point in time, but once inserted, goes with the flow of time after that insertion until taken out. They inserted him into a time spot to do a job that would take a couple of days to complete. Something that would have killed any other mutant.
The changes wouldn't be instant in that their time is actually a different timeflow. What Kitty and the others were doing is realizing in their timeflow, they lost. They knew they were dead. Instead, Wolverines' actions were to alter one possible timeflow so that there was not a possible alternate timeline where there were no invincible Sentinels. That was the effect they were after and knew the other way to do it was to make the people believe that Trask's project was in no way the good option for dealing with mutant, and to keep Mystique out of his hands as well.
Once the goal is reached, Kitty lets Wolverine's consciousness slipped out of the historic timeline, and it ends up back in the now altered "present" line. For Wolverine, he knows what happens with the Sentinel program that made invincible Sentinels that kills everyone.
As for Magneto's versus Mystiques motives at the end, it's pretty simple. Magneto wanted to stop the war before it starts by slaughtering all that could possibly make the invincible Sentinels. If you take out the only enemy resources that could create the Sentinels, they can't be made. Thus the mutants will win the war. Magneto at that time was still a megalomaniac in that regards and wanted to still see the extinction of human kind. There was no changing that aspect of his character in the 70's. Magneto was really not ever a good "person" as his anger against humanity set in early in his life.
Mystique originally is a good person though that gets corrupted eventually by the loses of her friends by humanity. This movie was centered around her "turning" point against humanity. Where she makes her first kill against a human, which was Trask, and then would eventually go on to be more and more evil killing a lot more indiscriminately. So at this point, Charles Xavier, has some influence on her actions with his words. Although she is not fully evil yet, she does still have her on "mission" in mind to save mutant kind and her friends. She just isn't so evil yet that she believes saving mutants at any cost, which includes murder of anyone, at that point in history. So she listens and is finally swayed by Charles' plea at the end.
And why does her actions change things? Well it shows that while mutants can be powerful and can be almost unstoppable if they decide to attack humanity, based off Magnetos actions to try to kill the president and his cronies, it also shows they can be stopped if you make friends with other mutants who are just as powerful. It also shows they have weaknesses too. That none of the mutants are as invincible as they seem to be to paranoid humans. It also allows Xavier to start using his mental powers earlier than he normally would be to start influencing high people in high places to look into the bad actions of those around them. Such as Trask. Which if you saw the paper in the movie, Trask is arrested for treason of selling out secrets to various countries in his bid to get money for his Sentinel program.
Personally I felt the motives for the characters and their actions in the movie was perfectly spot on considering the actual comics along with their pasts up to that point. Which is why I loved the movie so much.
But time does not flow at the same speed - Wolverine spends at least a week back in the past, and there is absolutely no way that Kitty maintains the connection for anywhere near that long. She gets injured quite badly when Wolverine is in Paris - how could she survive for another few days with such a bad injury, without being able to seek proper medical attention? And besides, the two time streams are not flowing simultaneously - it makes absolutely no sense that they would have to wait for Wolverine to wake up. As soon as his consciousness goes back, a massive change would result. The change would not be in flux because the time streams are not occurring simultaneously - how could they? If they were, then Wolverine's actions could not influence the current timeline, and there is no way that Kitty could hold the connection for that long.
Put yourselves in the Presidents shoes - you have just seen how powerful mutants can be. Would you want to trust Xavier, himself a potentially extremely dangerous mutant who can influence minds? Or would you want to trust a human, who is like you, who can develop weapons to confront this new threat?
There is no way that a human President is going to say "Okay!" and just put his faith in some mutant allies. No way in hell.
Put it another way - after 9/11, if there was another terrorist group that claimed to be allies of the US, and claimed to be against Al Qaeda, would you trust them, or would you trust your own military?
Put yourselves in the Presidents shoes - you have just seen how powerful mutants can be. Would you want to trust Xavier, himself a potentially extremely dangerous mutant who can influence minds? Or would you want to trust a human, who is like you, who can develop weapons to confront this new threat?
There is no way that a human President is going to say "Okay!" and just put his faith in some mutant allies. No way in hell.
Put it another way - after 9/11, if there was another terrorist group that claimed to be allies of the US, and claimed to be against Al Qaeda, would you trust them, or would you trust your own military?