vegetarians/vegans.. why?!

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Excelsior

Lifer
May 30, 2002
19,047
18
81
Originally posted by: Mookow
Originally posted by: Excelsior
Originally posted by: Mookow
Yes, I have seen a slaughterhouse when I was visiting cousins, I was taken to one (his job). I've field dressed several deer/boar/rabbits/*lots of animals, you get the point*. I still like my steak rare. I think the bigger problem than eating too much meat is "eating too much sh!t food and then not getting any exercise". Looking at your stats, 8 more women per year per 100K people doesnt seem like much. The gap is admittedly higher for men, but still I think that lack of exercise is more of a factor.

The field dressing doesn't apply here. Did you enjoy your stay at the slaughterhouse? I would agree that eating too much sh!t food and not getting exercise will lead to bad health, but you can't tell me that the fact that americans eat more redmeat and high fat meats has no effect.

I didnt see my visit as substantially worse than I did field dressing a deer. Same idea, much larger scale. If you want fresh meat, something has to die. Much like in a house, if you want it vermin free, at some point you may have to kill some mice or a few roaches. On occasion a particular animal is not put down correctly and suffers unnecessarily, but they do die faster than any of the several deer I have had to help track down, because some dumb mother****er got buck fever and gut shot it or otherwise made a bad shot.

EDIT: I didnt say no effect, I just think that eating a diet high is red meat and getting exercise is healthier than eating a diet without red meat and thinking a strenuous upper body workout is lifting the phone reciever to answer 3 calls in 15 minutes.

The much large scale part, is exactly where the problem lies. Would you not consider the particular animal who suffered of any importance at all? Put that one per day, per slaughterhouse, and you'd have many thousands. Just trying to put it into perspective. Not to mention what they feed the cows.

And don't compare roaches to even mice. Bug to a small mammal? We've never had to kill any mice on our property.
 

DWW

Platinum Member
Apr 4, 2003
2,030
0
0
I was a vegetarian for a long period of time then I just had a big craving for steak and hamburger one day. I gave in and love it. I figure its natural and that my body requires it, with the added omnivoreness of humans. Yes such food can be bad for you but hell you die anyhow so enjoy your life. I'd think that I'd live longer eating beef and not going to school in Toronto then the other way around.
 

TheShiz

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
3,846
0
0
we have to eat living organisms to survive. by being a vegetarian you are choosing to eat more distant relatives than the more recent ones like other mammals. I don't get offended by what people choose to eat.

Don't forget the great myth, that the earth is here for us humans, we are the pinnacle of evolution on the planet. we are not simply the byproduct of molecules trying to protect and copy themselves, or are we? Anyway, bon appetit.


two books on my recommended list, anyone with a genuine curiosity about the world we live in should read:

The Selfish Gene
Ishmael
 

PowerMacG5

Diamond Member
Apr 14, 2002
7,701
0
0
Originally posted by: lirion
I don't like to eat meat that looks like meat. It just feels weird. It's not a moral decision, so I don't care what anyone else eats.


Edit: Let me qualify that a bit. I don't like to eat meat at all. If there's a meat item available that's just really, really good, I'll eat some. If something still has the bones or skin I won't touch it. I can hardly stand to look at a boiled chicken, and the smell makes me gag. I don't eat fried chicken either, but I'll eat chicken on a sandwich in patty form. It's just a weird psychological problem. I'm weird, I know.
Pretty much the same here. I will not eat chicken legs off the bone, but will gladly have a hero with it (same with Turkey). I also for some reason don't eat much steak, but love hamburgers. I also don't eat ham, etc... It's weird, but that's how I am.
 

JoeKing

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
10,641
1
81
Originally posted by: KraziKid
Originally posted by: lirion
I don't like to eat meat that looks like meat. It just feels weird. It's not a moral decision, so I don't care what anyone else eats.


Edit: Let me qualify that a bit. I don't like to eat meat at all. If there's a meat item available that's just really, really good, I'll eat some. If something still has the bones or skin I won't touch it. I can hardly stand to look at a boiled chicken, and the smell makes me gag. I don't eat fried chicken either, but I'll eat chicken on a sandwich in patty form. It's just a weird psychological problem. I'm weird, I know.
Pretty much the same here. I will not eat chicken legs off the bone, but will gladly have a hero with it (same with Turkey). I also for some reason don't eat much steak, but love hamburgers. I also don't eat ham, etc... It's weird, but that's how I am.

when eating those patties of chicken and "beef" you should imagine the huge machines that strip the meat from the BONE and the smell of the plant as the boiled parts are mulched and regurgitated through.... often with bone marrow and cartilage getting through :p
 

Sunner

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
11,641
0
76
Originally posted by: oboeguy
My question is, "Meat eaters, why?" :D

Yum, I love pretty much any kind of meat, fish, bird, cow, I don't care, it's all good :)
Well, except for snails and oysters and such, I don't eat stuff that resembles snot too much, animal or not.
I don't like most vegetables too much though, I like cucumber and paprica, plus some oriental stuff that I don't even know what it's called, but sallad, tomatoes and stuff like that, that's a no-no to me.

I exercise quite a bit and stay in good shape, so the health aspect is a non issue to me.
Besides, I couldn't care less if I die at 70 or 75 instead of 80 or 90, 75 years of good eating is better than 90 years of vegetables to me personally.

I don't care what others eat though, if others wanna eat veggies that's none of my business, and I couldn't care less, I just expect people to show me the same courtesy.
I've never understood why some people always feel the urge to involve themselves in stuff that's clearly none of their business.
 

dman

Diamond Member
Nov 2, 1999
9,110
0
76
Originally posted by: caitlion
i know there are a few vegetarians/vegans here.. i was just wondering why you choose to not eat meat (or in some cases any animal by-products)? is it a moral thing or do you just not like it?

personally, i just dont like most meat and have had some gross experiences with it. if i try to eat it occasionally, it hurts my stomach, too.

also, (i thought of this because of the milk thread), if it is a moral thing, do you force your beliefs on other people? i obviously dont, because its not a moral issue for me... i couldnt care less if anyone else eats meat... but it really pisses me off that just because i dont eat meat, everyone ASSUMES that im going to hate them for it and try to get the whole world not to.

Unfortunate but that's the stereotype that comes along with being a vegetarian. The folks that I know who don't eat meat have never made an issue out of it for those who do. In fact, it's usually the carnivores amongst us that make it a point to harass the vegans of the world.

I've been cutting down on the red meat for health reasons (cholestoral) but I still eat it in moderation. The whole mad-cow thing has me a bit concerned as well, feel like I'm playing russian roulette now whenever I have a burger/etc. I know the odds are low but the meat industry would have you believe they are very low and the animal rights activits and consipiracy theorists would have you believe they aren't so low. Who knows.

 

Thraxen

Diamond Member
Dec 3, 2001
4,683
1
81
With things like Mad Cow disease lurking everywhere not eating beef seems prudent.

It's not exactly "lurking everywhere". Beef is still very safe to eat, especially in the USA.
 

athithi

Golden Member
Mar 5, 2002
1,717
0
0
I am a vegetarian because I was brought up as one. When I had my chances to try non-vegetarian food, I didn't find it particularly tastier than vegetarian food. Plus, most people that eat pork seem to have bad BO as a result - mostly any meat does that, IMHO. I don't even use the microwave in my office because sometimes people cook some really nasty smelling non-veg stuff in it. There are other meats that look and smell tasty. I've always drooled at the way Obelix eats a boar :eek: Thanksgiving turkeys look so golden crisp and delicious as do buffalo wings. But somehow, the idea of biting into flesh and blood never appeals to me. I never try to convince people of the benefits of vegetarianism unless they see some reason to advocate non-vegetarianism to me. I guess coming from South India, where most people are vegetarians (mostly cultural, partly economic reasons - meat is more expensive in India than vegetables), has a lot to do with it too. I have not seen the variety that South Indian vegetarian food has in any other cuisine. When there's so much good food to be eaten, I see no reason to eat dead animal parts.
 

Fausto

Elite Member
Nov 29, 2000
26,521
2
0
Originally posted by: Thraxen
With things like Mad Cow disease lurking everywhere not eating beef seems prudent.

It's not exactly "lurking everywhere". Beef is still very safe to eat, especially in the USA.
Especially if you buy certified organic beef.

 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: Mookow
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: caitlion


i know, but you said vegetarians not vegans. i was just kidding anyway :p
So was I . . . now most of us know more that we wanted to about this subject.
;)
rolleye.gif

:D

Stop with the nested quotes already!
Why? They got you paying for the xtra bandwith?

:p

rolleye.gif


 

AsianriceX

Golden Member
Dec 30, 2001
1,318
1
0
Originally posted by: Fausto
Originally posted by: Thraxen
With things like Mad Cow disease lurking everywhere not eating beef seems prudent.

It's not exactly "lurking everywhere". Beef is still very safe to eat, especially in the USA.
Especially if you buy certified organic beef.

After having a heated debate about this with my g/f, I decided to do some late night research on how the US safeguards the public against Mad Cow Disease. From what I can remember, certified organic beef is no safer than mass produced beef.
 

Thraxen

Diamond Member
Dec 3, 2001
4,683
1
81
After having a heated debate about this with my g/f, I decided to do some late night research on how the US safeguards the public against Mad Cow Disease. From what I can remember, certified organic beef is no safer than mass produced beef.

The bottom line is that BSE is not prevalent, at all, in the USA. And the US does take safeguards to ensure that it does not get imported.
 

desy

Diamond Member
Jan 13, 2000
5,447
216
106
LOL Like curried everything doesn't smell nasty! with or without the meat ;)
I don't think your GMO pesticide, herbicide laced veggies are much better for you than meat, sorry. . . .
I think BOTH are safe, humans have never lived longer or healthier in industrial culture.
Fact is varitety of food and year round availablity has some cost/benfits to it. . . .
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: AsianriceX
Originally posted by: Fausto
Originally posted by: Thraxen
With things like Mad Cow disease lurking everywhere not eating beef seems prudent.

It's not exactly "lurking everywhere". Beef is still very safe to eat, especially in the USA.
Especially if you buy certified organic beef.

After having a heated debate about this with my g/f, I decided to do some late night research on how the US safeguards the public against Mad Cow Disease. From what I can remember, certified organic beef is no safer than mass produced beef.
Sure it is . . . no antibiotics, no growth-hormones, no pesticide contaminated feed, no dirty crammed feedlots, and NO GROUND UP RESIDUES OF OTHER COWS (finally banned for all USA beef). :p

PLUS, you can trace each "organic" cow back to its birthplace.

rolleye.gif




 

Fausto

Elite Member
Nov 29, 2000
26,521
2
0
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: AsianriceX
Originally posted by: Fausto
Originally posted by: Thraxen
With things like Mad Cow disease lurking everywhere not eating beef seems prudent.

It's not exactly "lurking everywhere". Beef is still very safe to eat, especially in the USA.
Especially if you buy certified organic beef.

After having a heated debate about this with my g/f, I decided to do some late night research on how the US safeguards the public against Mad Cow Disease. From what I can remember, certified organic beef is no safer than mass produced beef.
Sure it is . . . no antibiotics, no growth-hormones, no pesticide contaminated feed, no dirty crammed feedlots, and NO GROUND UP RESIDUES OF OTHER COWS (finally banned for all USA beef). :p

PLUS, you can trace each "organic" cow back to its birthplace.

rolleye.gif
Yep. You just have to watch the labels. The rules are different for stuff labeled "all natural" or similar as opposed to "certified organic".

 

AsianriceX

Golden Member
Dec 30, 2001
1,318
1
0
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: AsianriceX
Originally posted by: Fausto
Originally posted by: Thraxen
With things like Mad Cow disease lurking everywhere not eating beef seems prudent.

It's not exactly "lurking everywhere". Beef is still very safe to eat, especially in the USA.
Especially if you buy certified organic beef.

After having a heated debate about this with my g/f, I decided to do some late night research on how the US safeguards the public against Mad Cow Disease. From what I can remember, certified organic beef is no safer than mass produced beef.
Sure it is . . . no antibiotics, no growth-hormones, no pesticide contaminated feed, no dirty crammed feedlots, and NO GROUND UP RESIDUES OF OTHER COWS (finally banned for all USA beef). :p

PLUS, you can trace each "organic" cow back to its birthplace.

rolleye.gif

Do you have any links to any studies done comparing the safety of organic to mass produced Beef?
 

Fausto

Elite Member
Nov 29, 2000
26,521
2
0
Originally posted by: AsianriceX
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: AsianriceX
Originally posted by: Fausto
Originally posted by: Thraxen
With things like Mad Cow disease lurking everywhere not eating beef seems prudent.

It's not exactly "lurking everywhere". Beef is still very safe to eat, especially in the USA.
Especially if you buy certified organic beef.

After having a heated debate about this with my g/f, I decided to do some late night research on how the US safeguards the public against Mad Cow Disease. From what I can remember, certified organic beef is no safer than mass produced beef.
Sure it is . . . no antibiotics, no growth-hormones, no pesticide contaminated feed, no dirty crammed feedlots, and NO GROUND UP RESIDUES OF OTHER COWS (finally banned for all USA beef). :p

PLUS, you can trace each "organic" cow back to its birthplace.

rolleye.gif

Do you have any links to any studies done comparing the safety of organic to mass produced Beef?
Here. Go nuts.

 

labrat25

Senior member
Jan 7, 2004
557
0
0
because someone once made the arguement to me that if we (as humans) have evolved as far as we say we have, why do we still eat meat? there are far better ways to get protein, etc

i just felt like trying it and now there are enough good reasons to keep going that i do

and vegetarians don't eat fish! it's vegitarianism, not lent!