This is fscked up... restaurants adding added tip to your credit card billl

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

episodic

Lifer
Feb 7, 2004
11,088
2
81
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: miri
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: George P Burdell
whenever i tip in cash, i make sure i fill in 0.00 as the tip, and fill in the total as well. that way, they can't screw with you

If I were gonna screw you, I'd just add a 1 to the front of your 0.00.

People that do this are gonna do it regardless.

And that would be credit card fraud, which is a felony in most states.



Well, yea. That is the point of the OP. They committed fraud by writing some amount in the tip section.

Um, no. You need to read the thread again.



Umm, no. .. I just read the OP again. It said that they added a tip to his bill without agreement. That is a fraud.
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,087
18,583
146
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: miri
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: George P Burdell
whenever i tip in cash, i make sure i fill in 0.00 as the tip, and fill in the total as well. that way, they can't screw with you

If I were gonna screw you, I'd just add a 1 to the front of your 0.00.

People that do this are gonna do it regardless.

And that would be credit card fraud, which is a felony in most states.



Well, yea. That is the point of the OP. They committed fraud by writing some amount in the tip section.

Um, no. You need to read the thread again.



Umm, no. .. I just read the OP again. It said that they added a tip to his bill without agreement. That is a fraud.

NO, they did not.

READ THE THREAD to understand what is happening. If it helps, just read my posts.
 

episodic

Lifer
Feb 7, 2004
11,088
2
81
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: miri
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: George P Burdell
whenever i tip in cash, i make sure i fill in 0.00 as the tip, and fill in the total as well. that way, they can't screw with you

If I were gonna screw you, I'd just add a 1 to the front of your 0.00.

People that do this are gonna do it regardless.

And that would be credit card fraud, which is a felony in most states.



Well, yea. That is the point of the OP. They committed fraud by writing some amount in the tip section.

Um, no. You need to read the thread again.



Umm, no. .. I just read the OP again. It said that they added a tip to his bill without agreement. That is a fraud.

NO, they did not.

READ THE THREAD to understand what is happening. If it helps, just read my posts.


Ok in bold:
So basically i went to this place called Lyons for dinner with a friend. I paid the bill, it was $30. She put in 5 bucks (a 5 dollar note) on the table and we left. 15% of $30 is $4.5.. now i see i got a bill for 34.46 on my online statement.
grrrr... so basically they tipped themselves $9.46 holy sh*t!


So, if they wrote in 5 dollars on the tip section of his credit card receipt that he signed, not in his presence, without his agreement - then this is fraud.
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,087
18,583
146
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: miri
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: George P Burdell
whenever i tip in cash, i make sure i fill in 0.00 as the tip, and fill in the total as well. that way, they can't screw with you

If I were gonna screw you, I'd just add a 1 to the front of your 0.00.

People that do this are gonna do it regardless.

And that would be credit card fraud, which is a felony in most states.



Well, yea. That is the point of the OP. They committed fraud by writing some amount in the tip section.

Um, no. You need to read the thread again.



Umm, no. .. I just read the OP again. It said that they added a tip to his bill without agreement. That is a fraud.

NO, they did not.

READ THE THREAD to understand what is happening. If it helps, just read my posts.


Ok in bold:
So basically i went to this place called Lyons for dinner with a friend. I paid the bill, it was $30. She put in 5 bucks (a 5 dollar note) on the table and we left. 15% of $30 is $4.5.. now i see i got a bill for 34.46 on my online statement.
grrrr... so basically they tipped themselves $9.46 holy sh*t!


So, if they wrote in 5 dollars on the tip section of his credit card receipt that he signed, not in his presence, without his agreement - then this is fraud.

Why are you refusing to read the thread and stop making a fool of yourself?

At least the OP has the excuse of not being online when this was explained. You on the other hand have ALL the info in front of you, but refuse to read it.
 

trinketsummoner

Senior member
Aug 24, 2004
695
1
81
To the people that say restaurants are adding 15% when they run your card, who gives them the right to do that? They arent owed a tip, they have no right to authorise more than whats printed on the check. YOU, as a customer, make the choice, not them. And is running more on a card than whats printed even legal? I dont see any small print on any place ive eaten say that, unless its a big party or something.
 
Oct 9, 1999
15,216
3
81
im wating to see if its the preauthorization charge..usually ifi get a preauthorization, its usually 1$ or something. That goes away after a few days. But i am monitoring.
 

miri

Diamond Member
Jun 16, 2003
3,679
0
76
Originally posted by: trinketsummoner
To the people that say restaurants are adding 15% when they run your card, who gives them the right to do that? They arent owed a tip, they have no right to authorise more than whats printed on the check. YOU, as a customer, make the choice, not them. And is running more on a card than whats printed even legal? I dont see any small print on any place ive eaten say that, unless its a big party or something.

Its just a preauthorization charge, not a actual charge to the credit card
 

waggy

No Lifer
Dec 14, 2000
68,143
10
81
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: miri
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: George P Burdell
whenever i tip in cash, i make sure i fill in 0.00 as the tip, and fill in the total as well. that way, they can't screw with you

If I were gonna screw you, I'd just add a 1 to the front of your 0.00.

People that do this are gonna do it regardless.

And that would be credit card fraud, which is a felony in most states.



Well, yea. That is the point of the OP. They committed fraud by writing some amount in the tip section.

Um, no. You need to read the thread again.



Umm, no. .. I just read the OP again. It said that they added a tip to his bill without agreement. That is a fraud.

NO, they did not.

READ THE THREAD to understand what is happening. If it helps, just read my posts.


Ok in bold:
So basically i went to this place called Lyons for dinner with a friend. I paid the bill, it was $30. She put in 5 bucks (a 5 dollar note) on the table and we left. 15% of $30 is $4.5.. now i see i got a bill for 34.46 on my online statement.
grrrr... so basically they tipped themselves $9.46 holy sh*t!


So, if they wrote in 5 dollars on the tip section of his credit card receipt that he signed, not in his presence, without his agreement - then this is fraud.

Why are you refusing to read the thread and stop making a fool of yourself?

At least the OP has the excuse of not being online when this was explained. You on the other hand have ALL the info in front of you, but refuse to read it.

While i think you are right that this is just a authorization type deal it does happen. I took some friends to Ruby Tuesday a few years back. The service was really bad. It took the girl 45 min to just bring us drinks then another 20 to get the dinner oder for us! She then screwed up the order and we had to beg another waitress to get us the tab so we could get out.

the bill came to $60 something and change. I scratched out the tip part of the receipt and just paid the bill amount.

We did throw down a few dollers on the table.

We left. The next day we notice that they had a $70 amount from ruby Tuesday. WE called the bank and they said its just a pre-authorization it will be right in a day or two. So we waited a week and it never went down.

WE called the bank back and they said that is what they submitted it for. So we called ruby Tuesday at first we got the run around from the manager. Then i got the regional manager involved. He went to the store and looked up the receipt. It showed $10 tip in the tip part (in different ink) with a slash through it.

He asked me and the wife to come in for a free dinner while there he gave me a $50 gift card to Ruby Tuesday also plus credited my card back the $10.
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,087
18,583
146
Originally posted by: waggy
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: miri
Originally posted by: episodic
Originally posted by: George P Burdell
whenever i tip in cash, i make sure i fill in 0.00 as the tip, and fill in the total as well. that way, they can't screw with you

If I were gonna screw you, I'd just add a 1 to the front of your 0.00.

People that do this are gonna do it regardless.

And that would be credit card fraud, which is a felony in most states.



Well, yea. That is the point of the OP. They committed fraud by writing some amount in the tip section.

Um, no. You need to read the thread again.



Umm, no. .. I just read the OP again. It said that they added a tip to his bill without agreement. That is a fraud.

NO, they did not.

READ THE THREAD to understand what is happening. If it helps, just read my posts.


Ok in bold:
So basically i went to this place called Lyons for dinner with a friend. I paid the bill, it was $30. She put in 5 bucks (a 5 dollar note) on the table and we left. 15% of $30 is $4.5.. now i see i got a bill for 34.46 on my online statement.
grrrr... so basically they tipped themselves $9.46 holy sh*t!


So, if they wrote in 5 dollars on the tip section of his credit card receipt that he signed, not in his presence, without his agreement - then this is fraud.

Why are you refusing to read the thread and stop making a fool of yourself?

At least the OP has the excuse of not being online when this was explained. You on the other hand have ALL the info in front of you, but refuse to read it.

While i think you are right that this is just a authorization type deal it does happen. I took some friends to Ruby Tuesday a few years back. The service was really bad. It took the girl 45 min to just bring us drinks then another 20 to get the dinner oder for us! She then screwed up the order and we had to beg another waitress to get us the tab so we could get out.

the bill came to $60 something and change. I scratched out the tip part of the receipt and just paid the bill amount.

We did throw down a few dollers on the table.

We left. The next day we notice that they had a $70 amount from ruby Tuesday. WE called the bank and they said its just a pre-authorization it will be right in a day or two. So we waited a week and it never went down.

WE called the bank back and they said that is what they submitted it for. So we called ruby Tuesday at first we got the run around from the manager. Then i got the regional manager involved. He went to the store and looked up the receipt. It showed $10 tip in the tip part (in different ink) with a slash through it.

He asked me and the wife to come in for a free dinner while there he gave me a $50 gift card to Ruby Tuesday also plus credited my card back the $10.

Then that is fraud. But in most cases, it is merely a pre-authorization as I'm sure it is in this case.
 

badet77

Guest
Sep 28, 2003
139
0
71
The same thing happened to me when I went to Red Lobster. The waitress gave herself a very gerenerous tip. I contacted the manager of the restaurant and they gave me a giftcard with the amount she took. But I did not want the amount she took, I wanted her to get in BIG trouble because she shouldn't be messing with people's signed credit card slip. I contacted the main office and they just gave me another giftcard.

But I do know that if your group is 8 or more, it is required to leave at least 15% tip. And I also know that some servers will automatically add that to the bill hoping you won't notice and give them double tip.
 

sao123

Lifer
May 27, 2002
12,653
205
106
read the fine print on the menu...
it probably says... 15% gratuity added to your bill.
Its not illegal, and yes many of the finer dining places do it.
 

zerocool1

Diamond Member
Jun 7, 2002
4,486
1
81
femaven.blogspot.com
Originally posted by: Lyfer
Only time I seen this is when you have 5 or more in a group.

but I think there was some law passed in NYC I think regarding tipping and it being constant regardless of quality of service.Then again it might be shens.
 

Metron

Golden Member
Oct 16, 2003
1,163
0
0
Every large restaurant I've visited in the Dallas Metro area is doing this.

Realize that they are pre-authorizing the total plus 20%. The actual amount charged is coming through later. I picked up a large "to go" order recently ( I don't tip on to go orders ), and I found they had charged the extra 20% when I checked my online bank. Later in the week when the actual charge was processed, the amount was correct.

I agree with Amused (and Visa Merchant Services) that restaurants SHOULD NOT be doing this. The best way is to contact your bank or credit card company and complain.
 

ahurtt

Diamond Member
Feb 1, 2001
4,283
0
0
Originally posted by: badet77
The same thing happened to me when I went to Red Lobster. The waitress gave herself a very gerenerous tip. I contacted the manager of the restaurant and they gave me a giftcard with the amount she took. But I did not want the amount she took, I wanted her to get in BIG trouble because she shouldn't be messing with people's signed credit card slip. I contacted the main office and they just gave me another giftcard.

But I do know that if your group is 8 or more, it is required to leave at least 15% tip. And I also know that some servers will automatically add that to the bill hoping you won't notice and give them double tip.

That is what I have always seen. . .if they are going to add a tip to the check automatically it usually says so on the menu. And then it is only if you have a party of 6-8 or more people. I totally disagree with this policy too because it does not promote good service. The waiter already knows they are guaranteed that tip so they can just give you crappy service.
 

ColdFusion718

Diamond Member
Mar 4, 2000
3,496
9
81
Originally posted by: C6FT7
Sheesh you're fretting over five dollars. Get over it!

It's the principle of things. People get away with stuff like this because people just "get over it." Sheesh!
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,087
18,583
146
It STILL amazes me that people are refusing to read the thread and understand the difference between the wrongly assumed fraud the OP is claiming, and a very common pre-authorization that shows up as "pending" until the real charge comes through.
 

birdpup

Banned
May 7, 2005
746
0
0
Originally posted by: Amused
It STILL amazes me that people are refusing to read the thread and understand the difference between the wrongly assumed fraud the OP is claiming, and a very common pre-authorization that shows up as "pending" until the real charge comes through.

And it still amazes me how you assume the OP's charge is a pre-authorization charge and loudly proclaim it as such without knowing for sure.

So far as I know, pre-authorization charges do not show up on the monthly bill. If a pre-authorization charge does show up on a monthly bill, it is time to get a new credit card from a different bank.
 

Pepsei

Lifer
Dec 14, 2001
12,895
1
0
Originally posted by: Amused
It STILL amazes me that people are refusing to read the thread and understand the difference between the wrongly assumed fraud the OP is claiming, and a very common pre-authorization that shows up as "pending" until the real charge comes through.


sometimes people post before they read the whole thing. which is likely the longer the thread becomes.
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,087
18,583
146
Originally posted by: birdpup
Originally posted by: Amused
It STILL amazes me that people are refusing to read the thread and understand the difference between the wrongly assumed fraud the OP is claiming, and a very common pre-authorization that shows up as "pending" until the real charge comes through.

And it still amazes me how you assume the OP's charge is a pre-authorization charge and loudly proclaim it as such without knowing for sure.

So far as I know, pre-authorization charges do not show up on the monthly bill. If a pre-authorization charge does show up on a monthly bill, it is time to get a new credit card from a different bank.

And your complete lack of reading comprehension amazes me.

The OP stated:

now i see i got a bill for 34.46 on my online statement

Later in the thread he admitted he saw that charge online within a day of eating there.

I have shown that it is very common for restaurants to do this and in the vast majority of cases, it's a pre-authorization.

Soooooo, how much would you like to bet it IS a pre-authorization?
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,087
18,583
146
Originally posted by: Pepsei
Originally posted by: Amused
It STILL amazes me that people are refusing to read the thread and understand the difference between the wrongly assumed fraud the OP is claiming, and a very common pre-authorization that shows up as "pending" until the real charge comes through.


sometimes people post before they read the whole thing. which is likely the longer the thread becomes.

Otherwise known as the "Skoorb Effect."