Russia on brink of ... NOPE! Russia INVADES Ukraine!

Page 1548 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

misuspita

Senior member
Jul 15, 2006
498
591
136
Yeah, it's a matter of time until you'll see a swarm of AI drones that will be almost completely independent, and that will need a lot of directed energy fire or fragmentation munition to destroy. Interesting times ahead, feels like the advent of tanks in the ww1...
 

fskimospy

Elite Member
Mar 10, 2006
85,561
50,735
136
Yeah, it's a matter of time until you'll see a swarm of AI drones that will be almost completely independent, and that will need a lot of directed energy fire or fragmentation munition to destroy. Interesting times ahead, feels like the advent of tanks in the ww1...
I think some sort of CIWS adjacent system would be highly effective against them but the main problem there is those are short range and fixed.
 
Dec 10, 2005
25,007
8,279
136
I think some sort of CIWS adjacent system would be highly effective against them but the main problem there is those are short range and fixed.
Time to bring back mobile anti-aircraft guns (and add some auto tracking) since bullets and shells are significantly cheaper than missiles.
 

K1052

Elite Member
Aug 21, 2003
47,960
37,060
136
Time to bring back mobile anti-aircraft guns (and add some auto tracking) since bullets and shells are significantly cheaper than missiles.

There actually is a lot of interest in this and with modern programmable ammunition larger caliber guns are even more effective at range. Quite a few Houthi drones have been downed by 76mm and 5inch naval guns recently. The Navy is very aware that they can't just light million dollar standard missiles for every threat and that it wastes precious magazine capacity thats needed against cruise/ballistic missiles.

The issue with using them for land defense is that anything static and effective will get smoked by ballistic missiles. So if it has to be mobile I doubt anything bigger than 57mm is practical which still probably gets you 10km of anti-aircraft range.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brainonska511
Nov 17, 2019
12,140
7,307
136
With Russia digging out their old stuff, where are all the German 88s?

(Restored) German 88 AA Flak Cannon Firing [960x636] : MilitaryPorn
 

K1052

Elite Member
Aug 21, 2003
47,960
37,060
136
So this is basically a micro SDB?

Not exactly since these laser guided seems to be the preference for these smaller munitions. SDB-I is GPS/INS.

The Ukrainian munition should dramatically increase the effectiveness of Baba Yaga missions since they can guide right into every target they want.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brycejones
Nov 17, 2019
12,140
7,307
136
The 88s were kind of a joke above, but seriously ...

What would scattered Flak do against drones? A cloud of flak played hell with planes. Drones too small? One or two pellets would take one out, no? Rather than needing several to do a plane?
 

fskimospy

Elite Member
Mar 10, 2006
85,561
50,735
136
Nice. Although when I WAG'd how much it cost for a two second squeeze on the trigger I cringed. And thinking about how much a toilet seat costs in our military aircraft, I'm guessing my estimate is horribly underpriced.
Heavy Weapons Guy approves.

1722624775951.png

Although the '$10,000 toilet seat' and '$600 hammer' thing is mostly a myth. (not that the military doesn't waste money) Basically when you buy a warplane or whatever for the sake of simplicity they spread R&D costs equally over every item in the delivery. So the R&D cost added to the radar is the same as for the included screwdriver to open up the radar.