• We should now be fully online following an overnight outage. Apologies for any inconvenience, we do not expect there to be any further issues.

Question for those in relationships regarding email privacy

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

sixone

Lifer
May 3, 2004
25,030
5
61
Originally posted by: lightpants
Originally posted by: mcvickj
I don't share passwords with anyone for any reason. They will go with me to my grave.

Bosco...?


A client of mine called me this morning, she was having some connectivity problems with her email account. I talked her through fixing it. She then asked me if there was anyway she could keep her husband from reading her email. They share a computer but have different user accounts and separate email addresses. I thought to myself "...hmmm...I wonder what is going on there???"
I told her how to set up a password on her user account. Then she told me that her husband reads the email she gets from her daughter. She and her daughter have been discussing Christmas gifts for him and she didn't want him to know what he was getting. She then asked how to remove the password after Christmas was over.
I think that was a legitimate reason to keep her husband from reading her email.

Heaven forbid she should tell her husband that they're discussing Christmas, and he should butt out. :roll:
 

sixone

Lifer
May 3, 2004
25,030
5
61
Originally posted by: JonnyBlaze
Originally posted by: sixone
We have one addy for our families to use, and a couple of junk accounts. They're all set up in our e-mail client, so all messages are there for either/both of us to read, from either computer.

My husband got a couple of messages recently from his buddy's college age daughter. You better bet I read those, but I would have been very surprised if they'd been less innocent than they were.

you should have had to read them then. you were expecting more.

I thought it was odd that she would e-mail him, since she hadn't done that before. She has a thing for his brownies. :D

 

RandomFool

Diamond Member
Dec 25, 2001
3,913
0
71
www.loofmodnar.com
I think my girlfriend knows my passwords...I told them to her but i don't know if she remembers them. I know here but don't check it..i trust her She snoops occasionally when on my pc and knows i know she does. It doesn't bother me i've got nothing to hide.
 

sao123

Lifer
May 27, 2002
12,653
205
106
you guys just dont seem to get the concept of marriage.

Genesis 2:24 For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and they will become one flesh.


in marriage there is no privacy.
One flesh. Unity. No subdivisions. No Individuality. No privacy.
 

blahter

Senior member
Oct 11, 2005
215
0
0
i used to know my ex-girlfriends email password but i wouldn't open her inbox unless she asked me to(calls me and asks me to read some info to her).
don't know if she's changed her password or not
 

Sphexi

Diamond Member
Feb 22, 2005
7,280
0
0
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: mcvickj
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: mcvickj
I don't share passwords with anyone for any reason. They will go with me to my grave.

I'm going to go out on a limb here and guess that you aren't married and never have been?

Correct. I'm only 24. But I see no reason why being married would change my opinion on this subject. This is no different than having a joint banking account and a seperate account.

God it's tough being right all the time. :laugh:

My wife and I have joint checking and savings accounts (no seperate accounts). What's your point?

Nice to see some people still trusting each other. I'm the same way with my wife, I see no reason to hide money from her, or vice-versa.
 

oboeguy

Diamond Member
Dec 7, 1999
3,907
0
76
Originally posted by: Sphexi
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: mcvickj
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: mcvickj
I don't share passwords with anyone for any reason. They will go with me to my grave.

I'm going to go out on a limb here and guess that you aren't married and never have been?

Correct. I'm only 24. But I see no reason why being married would change my opinion on this subject. This is no different than having a joint banking account and a seperate account.

God it's tough being right all the time. :laugh:

My wife and I have joint checking and savings accounts (no seperate accounts). What's your point?

Nice to see some people still trusting each other. I'm the same way with my wife, I see no reason to hide money from her, or vice-versa.

++
 

Stuxnet

Diamond Member
Jun 16, 2005
8,392
1
0
Originally posted by: Jeraden
So, I was just wondering how other couples handled things. Do you have the passwords and just not check, keep them private, read each others mails. Just curious what everyone else thinks about my predicament.

Sounds to me like some mindgames are in order.

But seriously, if she's reading your email, there's a problem. If she's pissed because she's now unable to read your email, there's a BIIIIIG problem.

I can just hear the argument now:

"Honey, did you change your email passwords."

"Yep"

"WTF?! Don't you trust me!"

"You're the one reading my email. Don't you trust me?"

"Don't change the subject you lying cheating bastard!"

 

Stuxnet

Diamond Member
Jun 16, 2005
8,392
1
0
Originally posted by: sixone
Originally posted by: Jeraden
Well, I left out a lot of details, but the sequence of events were:
- realized she was reading emails
- told her I was going to change my password because I was not comfortable with that. Discussions ensued, I did not change it yet
- found out later that she was still reading them even after previous discussion, so then I changed it and we had further discussions/arguments.

Why do you care if she reads your e-mails? Why do you expect her to misunderstand? What are you doing that makes you uncomfortable with your wife seeing it?

She is not your problem.

So you don't think spouses should have any expectation of privacy? It's interesting that you haven't even begun to address the issue of distrust flowing from the OP's wife... or is that "not the issue"?
 

shimsham

Lifer
May 9, 2002
10,765
0
0
Originally posted by: jbourne77
Originally posted by: sixone
Originally posted by: Jeraden
Well, I left out a lot of details, but the sequence of events were:
- realized she was reading emails
- told her I was going to change my password because I was not comfortable with that. Discussions ensued, I did not change it yet
- found out later that she was still reading them even after previous discussion, so then I changed it and we had further discussions/arguments.

Why do you care if she reads your e-mails? Why do you expect her to misunderstand? What are you doing that makes you uncomfortable with your wife seeing it?

She is not your problem.

So you don't think spouses should have any expectation of privacy? It's interesting that you haven't even begun to address the issue of distrust flowing from the OP's wife... or is that "not the issue"?



give up. youd have better luck walking through a brick wall.
 

Stuxnet

Diamond Member
Jun 16, 2005
8,392
1
0
Originally posted by: shimsham
Originally posted by: sixone
Originally posted by: shimsham
Originally posted by: sixone
Originally posted by: Jeraden
Well, I left out a lot of details, but the sequence of events were:
- realized she was reading emails
- told her I was going to change my password because I was not comfortable with that. Discussions ensued, I did not change it yet
- found out later that she was still reading them even after previous discussion, so then I changed it and we had further discussions/arguments.

Why do you care if she reads your e-mails? Why do you expect her to misunderstand? What are you doing that makes you uncomfortable with your wife seeing it?

She is not your problem.

right. always the mans fault since hes up to no good, huh?

would you like your husband listening in on coversations with your friends? what if they are telling you something personal that they didnt want anyone else to know and expected you to keep it in confidence?

When did I ever address anyone other than the OP? And where did confidential information come from? The OP didn't mention it, and neither did I.

Try again.


since when was it a requirement to be directly addressed in a public conversation on a public forum?

the confidential information is an instance where the op wouldnt want the wifey to read his emails, but wouldnt be hiding anything evil from her to cause mistrust on her part.

heres one that may be a little easier. what if he was talking about a gift to get his wife for christmas or an anniversary?

the point is, just because he doesnt want her reading his emails doesnt mean that hes hiding something or doing something he shouldnt be. people that cant understand that are the ones with the trust issues.

DING DING DING!

 

Stuxnet

Diamond Member
Jun 16, 2005
8,392
1
0
Originally posted by: Jeraden
She definitely has some trust issues, but I don't think that means I need to automatically cave in to her every demand just to appease her.

I agree with you 100%, and I'm pretty shocked by some of the responses here, which pretty much blame you for the whole scenario.

To me, this is indicative of a jealous/posessive person, regardless of whether it's a man or a woman.

Originally posted by: Jeraden
You need more than just 1 person to talk to in life.

Unfortunately, some spouses/boyfriends/girlfriends can't accept that fact... and if they're ever forced to deal with it, they can even sometimes get violently angry (just watch COPS).

My sister is actually like this to a degree. I love her to death, but she's very posessive of my brother-in-law. The guy can't cross the street without checking in yet he's never done anything to violate her trust. She simply just MUST know exactly what he's doing at all times.

Originally posted by: Jeraden
I think privacy is still important and a marriage doesn't mean that you need to feel like you are under 24/7 FBI Surveillance.

Again, I agree. My wife and I are close, but we also have our space. We have common friends and we each have a few of our own. People need that. Our individual space isn't huge by any means, but we're not wading around in each other's personal email, letters, phone calls, etc. Like I said before, it wouldn't even occur to either one of us to wedge our way into the middle of a private discussion. If I was meant to be a part of that discussion, I would have been invited.

And here's a newsflash to folks like sixone: I don't have to be hiding something to be bothered by the fact that you're pathologically suspicious. My wife and I have access to each other's email accounts, but if either of us we're found snooping around in the other's, there'd be major problems. That's just stupid, and shame on you for coming down on someone who felt betrayed by such actions.
 

Stuxnet

Diamond Member
Jun 16, 2005
8,392
1
0
Originally posted by: sixone
Well, if these friends are her friends too, you shouldn't be talking about her with them behind her back. Especially women friends. E-mail is not your only option for venting, so find another way.

Your hiding emails from her won't help with her trust issues - it's only going to aggravate the situation, and she'll work harder to 'monitor' you.

Seems your knee-jerk reaction is to tell her to just get over it, but that's no way to treat your wife. Maybe the two of you need to take this to a professional, instead of escalating the situation.

Sixone, you blow my mind. For no tangible/apparent reason whatsoever, you're treating this guy like HE'S the one responsible for all of this.

I'm curious as to what you would have said to him had the original post read "I compulsively snoop into my spouse's life for no justifiable reason... tell me what I should tell her to do to make me feel better".

You would have told him to man up.

If this was me and my wife I'd tell her to seek professional help... and I'd expect the same response from her. Trying to pin this adolescent behavior and the resulting argument on the OP is rediculous. And telling him that his reaction (which was very reasonable by just about any standard) was "no way to treat is wife" (especially after she was caught snooping in his email even AFTER he tried discussing it with her like adults) is downright LAUGHABLE.
 

SP33Demon

Lifer
Jun 22, 2001
27,928
143
106
Tell her it's none of her business. It's YOUR relationship with your women and/or guy friends, not your wife's. Some things are still kept personal, including your relationship with your friends. Would it bother you if your wife hopped on the phone everytime one of your friends called, and told you what you could and could not say to them? There's a reason why "guys night out" does not include the old lady. Yes, most of everything you do will be shared and united as one, but not when it comes to personal relationships with friends.
 

NikPreviousAcct

No Lifer
Aug 15, 2000
52,763
1
0
That's how I found out that bitch was cheating on me, but it was also the first time I'd ever done so. She'd already betrayed my trust, so I didn't fvcking care.
 

SP33Demon

Lifer
Jun 22, 2001
27,928
143
106
Originally posted by: sixone
We have one addy for our families to use, and a couple of junk accounts. They're all set up in our e-mail client, so all messages are there for either/both of us to read, from either computer.

My husband got a couple of messages recently from his buddy's college age daughter. You better bet I read those, but I would have been very surprised if they'd been less innocent than they were.
Sounds like someone feels threatened by the young, college aged girl. Is there any reason for this insecurity? I'd advise that you: a) either talk about why you feel so threatened by this girl with your husband or b) seek a relationship counselor.

 

AnyMal

Lifer
Nov 21, 2001
15,780
0
76
Any relationship that's lacking trust is doomed. I established early on with my wife that no passwords will be shared/surrendered. I trust her completely and expect the same from her. Marriage is a two-way street.
 

sixone

Lifer
May 3, 2004
25,030
5
61
Originally posted by: jbourne77
Originally posted by: sixone
Well, if these friends are her friends too, you shouldn't be talking about her with them behind her back. Especially women friends. E-mail is not your only option for venting, so find another way.

Your hiding emails from her won't help with her trust issues - it's only going to aggravate the situation, and she'll work harder to 'monitor' you.

Seems your knee-jerk reaction is to tell her to just get over it, but that's no way to treat your wife. Maybe the two of you need to take this to a professional, instead of escalating the situation.

Sixone, you blow my mind. For no tangible/apparent reason whatsoever, you're treating this guy like HE'S the one responsible for all of this.

I'm curious as to what you would have said to him had the original post read "I compulsively snoop into my spouse's life for no justifiable reason... tell me what I should tell her to do to make me feel better".

You would have told him to man up.

If this was me and my wife I'd tell her to seek professional help... and I'd expect the same response from her. Trying to pin this adolescent behavior and the resulting argument on the OP is rediculous. And telling him that his reaction (which was very reasonable by just about any standard) was "no way to treat is wife" (especially after she was caught snooping in his email even AFTER he tried discussing it with her like adults) is downright LAUGHABLE.

If you hadn't noticed, we don't have both spouses here, so I can't address any comments to her. I'd have lots of questions for her as well, which would have determined what I would have said to her. But if you need to make some stuff up, pray continue.

The OP said he says he has nothing to hide, but wants to hide it anyway. That make sense to you? That is a huge red flag, if you're paying attention.

If you want to have private things in your marriage, then marry a woman that wants the same expectation. This thread is about a couple that doesn't have the same expectations, and the reasons why don't really matter. If the OP wants to keep his wife, and I have no reason to think he doesnt, he can man up and do what it takes to keep it and keep it solid. Or not.

 

sixone

Lifer
May 3, 2004
25,030
5
61
Originally posted by: Nik
That's how I found out that bitch was cheating on me, but it was also the first time I'd ever done so. She'd already betrayed my trust, so I didn't fvcking care.

But you already knew something was up before you looked, didn't you?

 

kami333

Diamond Member
Dec 12, 2001
5,110
2
76
Depends on the relationship. But I make it pretty clear from the beginning that I expect/need a certain amount of privacy.
 

Stuxnet

Diamond Member
Jun 16, 2005
8,392
1
0
Originally posted by: sixone
If you hadn't noticed, we don't have both spouses here, so I can't address any comments to her. I'd have lots of questions for her as well, which would have determined what I would have said to her. But if you need to make some stuff up, pray continue.

I've not made anything up. You've left virtually no room for error/poor judgement by the other spouse. Nearly all of what you've said has in some way implicated the OP in causing the mistrust. You've barely stopped short of flat-out asking "so what did you do to justify her violating your privacy"... of course, that's probably because you don't think he deserves any in the first place. Heaven forbid you leave any room for "well, maybe she just flatout screwed up for no good reason at all". Heaven forbid you take the OP's word for what actually happened. You surely wouldn't want to entertain that scenario...

Originally posted by: sixone
The OP said he says he has nothing to hide, but wants to hide it anyway. That make sense to you? That is a huge red flag, if you're paying attention.

What doesn't make sense to me is your sensationalization of what's been said. He simply wants a small degree of privacy, as do I. I have nothing to hide in the walls of my home, but I don't want FBI kicking in my door every Tuesday just to make sure I'm not running a meth lab. The same goes for my wife. 99% of my email consists of online shopping transactions. The other 1% is email from my wife, my sisters, other family, and friends... I wouldn't have a problem showing this stuff to anyone as long as it was MY choice to do so. I don't have to have anything to hide, per se, to take issue with my spouse, in an act of subterfuge, reading my email. If that doesn't smack of distrust I don't know what does. I would take that as a serious personal insult and would see it as a doomsday sign with regard to our marriage. I'm sure my wife wouldn't feel any different if the tables were turned, and I'd be ashamed of myself if she caught me reading her email.

I'm just curious as to where you'd draw the line. Do you stalk your husband? Do you follow him wherever he goes? Do you have a problem with spouses who do that? I mean, if people have nothing to hide, what's the problem?

Psycho, if you ask me. No offense to the OP's wife, but people who do that need a life. People who think it's justified need counseling.

Originally posted by: sixone
If the OP wants to keep his wife, and I have no reason to think he doesnt, he can man up and do what it takes to keep it and keep it solid. Or not.

Your true colors. Interesting that you didn't pose the possibility of his wife wanting to keep her husband, "woman'ing up", and doing what it takes to keep HIM... such as not reading email that wasn't sent to her.

And this, posted by you earlier, is lame:

E-mail is not your only option for venting, so find another way.

So because his wife will read his email, you're saying he should just find a way to communicate with people that she can't access. In a way you're acknowledging his right to a degree of privacy, but that it's up to him to do it in a manner that's impossible for his wife to intercept. Why is it so unreasonable for him to just expect her to respect his email privacy? Who in the world promotes this sort of behavior and distrust?

The flip-side is your justification of her reading that email. Suppose he decides to go to a bar to talk to his friends. I suppose you think it's reasonable for her to tail him there and grab a booth next to his and listen?

This is pretty wacky stuff when you really think about it.




 

sixone

Lifer
May 3, 2004
25,030
5
61
Originally posted by: jbourne77
Originally posted by: sixone
If you hadn't noticed, we don't have both spouses here, so I can't address any comments to her. I'd have lots of questions for her as well, which would have determined what I would have said to her. But if you need to make some stuff up, pray continue.

I've not made anything up. You've left virtually no room for error/poor judgement by the other spouse. Nearly all of what you've said has in some way implicated the OP in causing the mistrust. You've barely stopped short of flat-out asking "so what did you do to justify her violating your privacy"... of course, that's probably because you don't think he deserves any in the first place. Heaven forbid you leave any room for "well, maybe she just flatout screwed up for no good reason at all". Heaven forbid you take the OP's word for what actually happened. You surely wouldn't want to entertain that scenario...

Originally posted by: sixone
The OP said he says he has nothing to hide, but wants to hide it anyway. That make sense to you? That is a huge red flag, if you're paying attention.

What doesn't make sense to me is your sensationalization of what's been said. He simply wants a small degree of privacy, as do I. I have nothing to hide in the walls of my home, but I don't want FBI kicking in my door every Tuesday just to make sure I'm not running a meth lab. The same goes for my wife. 99% of my email consists of online shopping transactions. The other 1% is email from my wife, my sisters, other family, and friends... I wouldn't have a problem showing this stuff to anyone as long as it was MY choice to do so. I don't have to have anything to hide, per se, to take issue with my spouse, in an act of subterfuge, reading my email. If that doesn't smack of distrust I don't know what does. I would take that as a serious personal insult and would see it as a doomsday sign with regard to our marriage. I'm sure my wife wouldn't feel any different if the tables were turned, and I'd be ashamed of myself if she caught me reading her email.

I'm just curious as to where you'd draw the line. Do you stalk your husband? Do you follow him wherever he goes? Do you have a problem with spouses who do that? I mean, if people have nothing to hide, what's the problem?

Psycho, if you ask me. No offense to the OP's wife, but people who do that need a life. People who think it's justified need counseling.

Originally posted by: sixone
If the OP wants to keep his wife, and I have no reason to think he doesnt, he can man up and do what it takes to keep it and keep it solid. Or not.

Your true colors. Interesting that you didn't pose the possibility of his wife wanting to keep her husband "woman'ing up" and doing what it takes to keep HIM... such as not reading email that wasn't sent to her.

So what did your husband do to violate your trust? I'm sure you must have a fantastic reason for reading his email...

And this, posted by you earlier, is lame:

E-mail is not your only option for venting, so find another way.

So because his wife will read his email, you're saying he should just find a way to communicate with people that she can't access. In a way you're acknowledging his right to a degree of privacy, but that it's up to him to do it in a manner that's impossible for his wife to intercept. Why is it so unreasonable for him to just expect her to respect his email privacy?

The flip-side is your justification of her reading that email. Suppose he decides to go to a bar to talk to his friends. I suppose you think it's reasonable for her to tail him there and grab a booth next to his and listen?

This is pretty wacky stuff when you really think about it.

If you can't get past what you think I said, to see what I did say, then 'wacky' is the right word.