You can quote any article you want. I've played EVERY one of the games you've mentioned including KZ2. The responsiveness of the controls are night and day.
You can be blind all you want, and I'm all for playing whatever game people want, but don't act oblivious to the facts when someone dares to call out your game of choice.
You can say its intended and supposed to feel "weighty". It doesn't matter what bullshit reason is behind it. The FACT is they sucked and people did not like them.....intended or not intended.
It all comes down to fun vs not fun. The majority of the people in this thread hated the controls of KZ2 (including me ) and stated that they hope the controls are fixed. It took away from the game which could have been excellent but was instead just decent.