How do you guys like the Ipod Mini?

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

MrChad

Lifer
Aug 22, 2001
13,507
3
81
Originally posted by: Gurck
It's invalid because if sound quality in a DAP is unimportant to you, you can spend as little as half as much on a same-capacity non-Apple player.

Out of curiosity

iPod Mini 4 GB $199
iPod Mini 6 GB $249

Creative Zen Micro 4 GB $199 - $20 mail-in rebate
Creative Zen Micro 6 GB $249

iRiver H10 5 GB $279

Dell Pocket DJ 5 GB $199

Am I missing something here? Where can I find a 4 GB player for $99, or a 6 GB player for $125 dollars, as you have claimed?
 

Sunner

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
11,641
0
76
Originally posted by: Gurck
Originally posted by: Sunner
Originally posted by: Gurck
Originally posted by: Sunner
More mindless Apple bashing, how refreshing.
Mindless? I've backed up my statements. More mindless fanboyism seems more like it ;)
Actually I don't own a single Apple product, though from what I've seen, the iPod is a fairly nice player, albeit a bit overpriced, not my kind of player though.
I do respect their products though, the G5 PowerMac's are awesome boxes, and I'd love to have one, a G5 iMac would do nicely for my parents, and OS X is bar none the best desktop OS I've ever used.

I agree their products are overpriced, but so are BMW's, that doesn't make BMW's bad cars(except the new ones are ugly as $hit).
I called you a fanboy becuase while I made statements and backed each one up (I'm guessing you never took a debate course?), you contributed not a single thing to the argument, posting only to insult me because you don't share my opinion and were unable to counter it. Weak.

I didn't bother since you tend not to listen to them.
Kinda like the debates where you claim Foobar sounds better than Winamp, even though the developers themselves say this is only placebo.

Weak indeed.

Oh and no, I've never taken a debate course.
I don't need one to see you obviously harbour some kind of deep hatered for Apple though, kinda like people who will mindlessly bash Microsoft, IBM, Linux, or whatever they like to bash.
Me, I just don't care about companies, I used to hate Macs, now they're awesome machines albeit expensive, I used to hate IBM, I still don't like DB2, but they make alot of other really good stuff, etc etc.

All I've seen you touting in this thread is you oppinion.
 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: Oyeve
I bought the ipod because of its size, capacity, sound and ease of use.
Iaudios are smaller or the same size, depending on the model. There are competing products with the same capacity as any model ipod. As mentioned, it's one of the worst sounding. Other manufacturers, contrary to popular belief, actually do not go out of their way to make their products difficult to use. Only someone with very little tech savvy would have trouble with the interface on most players.
The whole Zen line, IMO, is crap. I dont care if it cost cheaper, they are made of crappy material, the interface stinks on all of the models and they are too big. The ipod has all the features I need.
There are manufacturers other than Creative, you know ;) We've gone over the issue of features and why it's not a valid argument for the ipod. Continuing to harp on points which have been refuted and begging off of the thread just tells me you know you have no valid points. Why can't you just admit you're giving in to the herd instinct and Apple's advertising & image? You want to have what everyone else has. You want to appear "kewl" to your "frendz".
Originally posted by: MrChad
Originally posted by: Gurck
It's invalid because if sound quality in a DAP is unimportant to you, you can spend as little as half as much on a same-capacity non-Apple player.

Out of curiosity

iPod Mini 4 GB $199
iPod Mini 6 GB $249

Creative Zen Micro 4 GB $199 - $20 mail-in rebate
Creative Zen Micro 6 GB $249

iRiver H10 5 GB $279

Dell Pocket DJ 5 GB $199

Am I missing something here? Where can I find a 4 GB player for $99, or a 6 GB player for $125 dollars, as you have claimed?
I said "as little as half". The example of this is the 40gb Zen Xtra at $200 vs. the 40gb ipod at $400.
 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: AlphaQ
I believe you get 15% off as a student.
And of course life ends at 22 when most people no longer are students. Those old, crusty 23+ year olds don't listen to music anyway, they just sit around in their wheelchairs, talking about the goold old days and debating which is better - Fixodent or Polygrip... :roll:
 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: Sunner
I didn't bother since you tend not to listen to them.
Kinda like the debates where you claim Foobar sounds better than Winamp, even though the developers themselves say this is only placebo.

Weak indeed.
Weak attempt to save face. You haven't addressed how "mindless" was an insult or how it was a false description because I backed up my points. You painted yourself into a corner here, simply put you posted only to insult and called someone with a valid argument mindless when your own statement was mindless, as it wasn't backed up with anything. I've said it before & will again - AT's elite members are disproportionately more pompous and less mature than posters without said status. Linked because I know you, lacking an argument, will twist my words and claim I said this about all elite members when I did nothing of the sort.
 

Sunner

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
11,641
0
76
Originally posted by: Gurck
Originally posted by: Sunner
I didn't bother since you tend not to listen to them.
Kinda like the debates where you claim Foobar sounds better than Winamp, even though the developers themselves say this is only placebo.

Weak indeed.
Weak attempt to save face. You haven't addressed how "mindless" was an insult or how it was a false description because I backed up my points. You painted yourself into a corner here, simply put you posted only to insult and called someone with a valid argument mindless when your own statement was mindless, as it wasn't backed up with anything. I've said it before & will again - AT's elite members are disproportionately more pompous and less mature than posters without said status. Linked because I know you, lacking an argument, will twist my words and claim I said this about all elite members when I did nothing of the sort.

See my edit.

And I fail to see what my title has to do with anything? :confused:
That aside, you can ask a number of members of these forums if they think I'm pompous and/or immature, you might be surprised, or maybe not, I honestly don't know since I've never asked.
 

MrChad

Lifer
Aug 22, 2001
13,507
3
81
Originally posted by: Gurck
Originally posted by: MrChad
Originally posted by: Gurck
It's invalid because if sound quality in a DAP is unimportant to you, you can spend as little as half as much on a same-capacity non-Apple player.

Out of curiosity

iPod Mini 4 GB $199
iPod Mini 6 GB $249

Creative Zen Micro 4 GB $199 - $20 mail-in rebate
Creative Zen Micro 6 GB $249

iRiver H10 5 GB $279

Dell Pocket DJ 5 GB $199

Am I missing something here? Where can I find a 4 GB player for $99, or a 6 GB player for $125 dollars, as you have claimed?
I said "as little as half". The example of this is the 40gb Zen Xtra at $200 vs. the 40gb ipod at $400.

That argument may hold for higher capacity MP3 players (such as the 40 GB iPod vs. the Zen Xtra), but iPod Minis are clearly priced competitively.
 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: Sunner
See my edit.

And I fail to see what my title has to do with anything? :confused:
That aside, you can ask a number of members of these forums if they think I'm pompous and/or immature, you might be surprised, or maybe not, I honestly don't know since I've never asked.
I don't care what other people think, this is part of why I don't see the appeal of the ipod in the first place. Fact of the matter is you mindlessly insulted me for being mindless when in fact I'd provided examples for each argument I made. "If you can't win, call them names on teh intarweb" seems to be gaining popularity as an approach to debates :(
 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: MrChad
That argument may hold for higher capacity MP3 players (such as the 40 GB iPod vs. the Zen Xtra), but iPod Minis are clearly priced competitively.
You may be right, I've read up mainly on 20+ gb models, as it's the only capacity which interests me.
 

Sunner

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
11,641
0
76
Originally posted by: Gurck
Originally posted by: Sunner
See my edit.

And I fail to see what my title has to do with anything? :confused:
That aside, you can ask a number of members of these forums if they think I'm pompous and/or immature, you might be surprised, or maybe not, I honestly don't know since I've never asked.
I don't care what other people think, this is part of why I don't see the appeal of the ipod in the first place. Fact of the matter is you mindlessly insulted me for being mindless when in fact I'd provided examples for each argument I made. "If you can't win, call them names on teh intarweb" seems to be gaining popularity as an approach to debates :(

Where di you provide any facts about anything?
You complained about the design, I agree, I don't like it, but that's just an oppinion.
You complained about the sound, most people won't care, it sounds ok as far as portable players go, most anyone won't care.
You complained about the price, products are worth as much as people will pay, if people would pay $10K for it, thats what it would be worth.

And so forth, everything so far has been your oppinion, and obviously many people disagree with you.

You're the one who threadcraps in every iPod thread, please point to the vast number of threads where I crap?
 

Aganack1

Senior member
May 16, 2002
331
0
0
Originally posted by: Gurck

Originally posted by: copperbottom
ipod mini has problems and sound issues
Yes it does

look at the date on the article that was about 2 months after any one could really get thier hand on it. I had one and yes it did it they sent me a new one and i have beat that one up something fierce and no problems. My wife has one and no problems there. everyone i know that has one purchased (from Apple) after june of 2004 has no problem with them.
 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: Sunner
Where di you provide any facts about anything?
You complained about the design, I agree, I don't like it, but that's just an oppinion.
You complained about the sound, most people won't care, it sounds ok as far as portable players go, most anyone won't care.
You complained about the price, products are worth as much as people will pay, if people would pay $10K for it, thats what it would be worth.

And so forth, everything so far has been your oppinion, and obviously many people disagree with you.
Aside from my opinion on its looks & my feelings on the statement it makes about you to others, all of my points (the majority of them) have been factual. Not opinions, not complaints. It does not play ogg or flac. It does have 0.42% THD as measured through the headphone jack. Etcetera... these are not opinions.
You're the one who threadcraps in every iPod thread, please point to the vast number of threads where I crap?
Threadcrapping is having a dissenting opinion? If you want a circle jerk where no one's allowed to disagree, make your own thread and state this explicitly in the original post (or post in P&N). Who said you crap in threads? I certainly didn't. I said you mindlessly insulted me for being mindless when my post was nothing of the sort.
 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: Aganack1
Originally posted by: Gurck

Originally posted by: copperbottom
ipod mini has problems and sound issues
Yes it does
look at the date on the article that was about 2 months after any one could really get thier hand on it. I had one and yes it did it they sent me a new one and i have beat that one up something fierce and no problems. My wife has one and no problems there. everyone i know that has one purchased (from Apple) after june of 2004 has no problem with them.
I've searched & found nothing about them fixing it. Until I do, I'll assume it hasn't been addressed. Even if it has been or will be, it's quite telling that they shipped such an expensive player with such a cheap headphone jack. It's just one more example of where the money's really going.. (hint: it's not toward quality components or quality assurance)
 

CraigRT

Lifer
Jun 16, 2000
31,440
5
0
iPod = junk.
any other MP3 player would be favorable in my eyes.
this is coming from a guy who bought a 20gb iPod for his GF. :thumbsdown:
 

Aganack1

Senior member
May 16, 2002
331
0
0
Well i Love my Mini i wish i had a new one for the 18 hour battery life, but what can you do. OH well. I've used other ones and they are ok, but for me the look, feel and easy use makes the the ipod mini the best choice for me.
 

debts

Junior Member
Mar 21, 2005
5
0
0
I'd like to buy an ipod, but i haven't because:

I'm unsure of the sound quality e.g. frequency response
There's no EQ
No drag and Drop support
I'm not sure if you can use your ipod to store non-audio files
The horror stories about bad batteries and poor customer service.

It really sucks for serious consumers because no product seems to have all the features i'm looking for, the muvo for example, doesn't have the capacity as some of the other players... if it did, i'd take that one in a hearbeat.
 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: daniel1113
Originally posted by: Gurck
I said "as little as half". The example of this is the 40gb Zen Xtra at $200 vs. the 40gb ipod at $400.

:confused:

iPod 20GB - $290

Zen Touch 20GB - $230


iPod 40GB - $330

Zen Xtra 40GB - $250

Where is this $200 price difference? Looks like the iPod has about a $80 premium on the Zen Xtra, which isn't bad considering the size difference.
"Click here for price"
error '80004005'

Unspecified error

/basket/additem.asp, line 70
Besides, like many, many people, I've been screwed by buy.com and will never shop there again.
 

daniel1113

Diamond Member
Jun 6, 2003
6,448
0
0
Originally posted by: Gurck
"Click here for price"
error '80004005'

Unspecified error

/basket/additem.asp, line 70

Is that your response? Try clicking the "Add to basket" button instead of the "click for price" link. Or you can just take my word for it.
 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: Fishers Web
Originally posted by: CraigRT
iPod = junk.
any other MP3 player would be favorable in my eyes.
this is coming from a guy who bought a 20gb iPod for his GF. :thumbsdown:
Did you do that before or after you started hating iPods???
Like the BMW example, this is another one where it's fully understandable. Keeping the g/f happy > ensuring she has a decent player.
 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: daniel1113
Originally posted by: Gurck
"Click here for price"
error '80004005'

Unspecified error

/basket/additem.asp, line 70

Is that your response? Try clicking the "Add to basket" button instead of the "click for price" link. Or you can just take my word for it.
And where might that button be? :confused:
 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: daniel1113
iPod 40GB - $331.55

Zen Xtra 40GB - $224.19

... or do you not shop at Amazon either? :roll:
Actually no I don't :p Someplace that's not up front about things, especially important things such as the price of what they're selling, doesn't get my business. Same with sub-8 ratings at resellerratings.com, such as Amazon's and especially buy.com's.

Btw while it's generally a bit more, the Zen Xtra can be found for $200 and under new. It was this price about a month ago at one of the big chain stores (bb, cc, compusa), I forget which.