Atheism in a year

Page 7 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Attrox

Golden Member
Aug 24, 2004
1,120
0
0
Too lazy to get involved in this obvious flamefest.
May the iPod god someday shines his light on your iPod-less life so that you may understand the truth.
 

Cerb

Elite Member
Aug 26, 2000
17,484
33
86
Originally posted by: Attrox
Too lazy to get involved in this obvious flamefest.
May the iPod god someday shines his light on your iPod-less life so that you may understand the truth.
Gurck = (God-iPod)/p
This is the holy grail of modern technology! Right in ATOT: the equation to make a perpetual motion machine! :D
(couldn't resist)
 

Stojakapimp

Platinum Member
Jun 28, 2002
2,184
0
0
You're saying that the lives of the saints and the thousands of miracles they have performed are just natural occurences? Just because you have no knowledge of this doesn't mean it hasn't existed. Remember, ignorance is bliss
 

Cerb

Elite Member
Aug 26, 2000
17,484
33
86
Originally posted by: Stojakapimp
You're saying that the lives of the saints and the thousands of miracles they have performed are just natural occurences? Just because you have no knowledge of this doesn't mean it hasn't existed. Remember, ignorance is bliss
There are several classes of beliefs here:
1. You believe they happened, and are natural.
2. You believe they happened, and some intermediary(sp) was involved, such as God.
3. You believe they happened, but are not natural, thus blinding your mind to the possibility that the universe is more complex than we know, and that we are actually an integral part of it.
4. You believe that the invention of some thing such as Satan (yes, a single prime evil that attempts to defy God was an invention of the church, long ago), and that it had a part.
5. You believe they didn't happen, and/or attempt to rationalize them into a closed worldview.
6. Somebody is bound to split hairs and eek out a sixth class, so here it is :).

1, 3, and 5 do not require any deity. 1 accepts that 'miracles' happen, are not bad, are perfectly acceptable, and still does not require a deity.
 

Stojakapimp

Platinum Member
Jun 28, 2002
2,184
0
0
Originally posted by: Cerb
Originally posted by: Stojakapimp
You're saying that the lives of the saints and the thousands of miracles they have performed are just natural occurences? Just because you have no knowledge of this doesn't mean it hasn't existed. Remember, ignorance is bliss
There are several classes of beliefs here:
1. You believe they happened, and are natural.
2. You believe they happened, and some intermediary(sp) was involved, such as God.
3. You believe they happened, but are not natural, thus blinding your mind to the possibility that the universe is more complex than we know, and that we are actually an integral part of it.
4. You believe that the invention of some thing such as Satan (yes, a single prime evil that attempts to defy God was an invention of the church, long ago), and that it had a part.
5. You believe they didn't happen, and/or attempt to rationalize them into a closed worldview.
6. Somebody is bound to split hairs and eek out a sixth class, so here it is :).

I wasn't trying to just make the point for Christianity. It's just a good reminder that we most likely do not know everything about the universe that we can, so ruling out the possibility of a diety seems like a stretch
 

Cerb

Elite Member
Aug 26, 2000
17,484
33
86
Originally posted by: Stojakapimp
Originally posted by: Cerb
Originally posted by: Stojakapimp
You're saying that the lives of the saints and the thousands of miracles they have performed are just natural occurences? Just because you have no knowledge of this doesn't mean it hasn't existed. Remember, ignorance is bliss
There are several classes of beliefs here:
1. You believe they happened, and are natural.
2. You believe they happened, and some intermediary(sp) was involved, such as God.
3. You believe they happened, but are not natural, thus blinding your mind to the possibility that the universe is more complex than we know, and that we are actually an integral part of it.
4. You believe that the invention of some thing such as Satan (yes, a single prime evil that attempts to defy God was an invention of the church, long ago), and that it had a part.
5. You believe they didn't happen, and/or attempt to rationalize them into a closed worldview.
6. Somebody is bound to split hairs and eek out a sixth class, so here it is :).
I wasn't trying to just make the point for Christianity. It's just a good reminder that we most likely do not know everything about the universe that we can, so ruling out the possibility of a diety seems like a stretch
Ruling it out: yes. Making the existence of a deity irrelavent: no.
 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: Vic
Did Stalin kill his millions for religion? No. Hitler? No.
:confused:

Originally posted by: shilala
Originally posted by: Gurck
One of the biggest problems facing religion's credibility is the complete lack of evidence supporting the existence of a deity or deities.

This is why it's called "faith".
There's no supporting evidence that the sun will come up tomorrow, either.
I suppose the sun lacks credibility, eh?
No, the sun is observable daily.

I think it's extremely arrogant of humans to assume that they can understand everything.
As do I, which is one reason I find the church so disgusting. From running culture-destroying missionaries to instilling the belief in followers that everyone but them is a heathen destined for hell, the arrogance they display is second to none.

It's something of a contradiction to assume something doesn't exist because we can't see it or apply numbers to it.
We also don't see pink elephants or dragons, do they exist on earth as well? If you answer yes, please share those mushrooms with me ;)

I can feel it. That's enough for me. I don't understand it, nor do I need to.
Of course you do, most of us are genetically programmed to. An inclination toward religion was an evolutionary advantage in our not too distant past.
 

MrDudeMan

Lifer
Jan 15, 2001
15,069
94
91
Originally posted by: exdeath
I believe in physics.

oh please :roll: physics has nothing to do with this, and it doesnt explain jack squat. if you "believe" in physics, then you believe in something we dont even have a grasp on yet. almost everything in physics is a theory that is mostly true. people that say they believe in "physics" piss me off. i have no problem with you if you dont believe in God, but come on :roll:
 

sao123

Lifer
May 27, 2002
12,653
205
106
First.
Everyone who claims that we should not believe in the existance of a God because we cannot offer any evidence supporting any claim about him should consider this:

String theory claims that there are some 7 odd dimentions that exist in addition to our 4 we live in -in spacetime. We have no evidence they exist except a mathmatical model which their existance seems to solve certain "problems" with our previous models of space, time & gravity. Our best scientists & mathematicians cannot even test this theory let alone prove it in any evidence providing manner, yet we still believe it is true.

It is impossible to prove the existance of a God, until you experience him. In order to experience him, it is a requirement to have faith to believe that he exists. Who knows, maybe he lives in one of those 7 undiscovered dimentions.


Let me put forth the following hypothesis then. Since you say there is no scientific way to prove that God exists. But, what if there is a God and the only way to find out if he exists is to exercise faith that he exists. And, God is waiting for you to try to exercise a little faith even though it flies in the face of scientific logic. You don't ever try, what would be your answer when you face God after you die and he asks why you didn't exercise even a small amount of faith in him?

I would say, "In case you weren't aware, you gave me 5 senses. None of them indicated that you existed. Sorry."
He gave you an imagination - the ability to think & reason above and beyond the limited abilities of your senses. I mean, you do believe in other things that you cannot experience with your 5 senses. Right?


I'm must be one of those non-rabid atheists. I don't require proof that god exists, I just need some good evidence.

What would you accept as evidence? Not that I really care. I have no desire to save anyone's soul, as I believe that people can only save themselves, both in this life and any life later (if that exists). I'm just wondering what you would require. I imagine it would be something impossible, and thus would simply demonstrate an immature close-minded attitude.

Isn't one of the premises of Christianity that God is omnipotent? (I haven't been to church in eight years, but I'm pretty sure I remember at least that much )

If so, then would it really be that unreasonable to expect something otherwise considered "impossible", as far as proof that he exists?

If God did excercise something impossible/miracle that every one witessed one of two things would occur. The first, which probably happens a lot anyway, is that people who are obssessed atheists would simply attempt to rationalize the nonrational and would draw a conclusion they were comfortable with.



I was once pretty close to being aethiestic.
Call it heresay if you like, But I have personally whitnessed a few of such maracles. But no-one is going to believe it because I say it. The only way to prove it enough to believe in it (just like for myself) is to truely experience it. On 3 occasions, unexplainable(by logical terms, but explainable through prayer to God) things have happened to people at my church (currently or previously).

1)One of my friends from the past named Jason. He was injured in a ATV accident, where he drove himself into an invisible wire clothsline. the impact crushed his larynix and shattered the vibrational bones entirely. the doctors performed 3 surgeries to reconstruct his throat. They said he'd never talk again because half his voicebox is missing. Not more than 6 months later he had a full recovery. His voice was as good as new, full range singing. The doctors were amazed and said this could only be the work of a God.

2)An elderly man I know was in a car accident. He was paralized from the waist down. Spinal cord completely severed. The doctors said he would never walk or have feeling in his legs again. Once again, this man is walking today completely healed.

3)Even, I myself believe I was miraculuosly healed through prayer 2 years ago. I had been sick & urinating blood for a while, and went to the Nephrologist. I was diagnosed as having near Kidney failure. They did sample testings, & a tissue biopsy. I was suffering from a degenerative kidney disease, and there was no cure, no treatments available... soon I would be doomed to a life of dialysis 4 days a week. I went to a healing service at my church. I immediately felt better. I had a followup appointment a few weeks later. My Kidneys were restored from 15% working to 100% working. I never had 1 dialisys appontment. Since then I have had yearly kidney testing & have been trouble free. This disease didnt just go into dormant stage, it was completely gone. Every last trace.


You dont see the evidence in maracles because you fail to believe. and you fail to believe because you do not see the evidence... (Chicken and the Egg Cycle?) It is up to you to take the first step. If your awaiting God to reveal himself to you, your going to be waiting a long time.
 

TheBDB

Diamond Member
Jan 26, 2002
3,176
0
0
Originally posted by: sao123
First.
Everyone who claims that we should not believe in the existance of a God because we cannot offer any evidence supporting any claim about him should consider this:

String theory claims that there are some 7 odd dimentions that exist in addition to our 4 we live in -in spacetime. We have no evidence they exist except a mathmatical model which their existance seems to solve certain "problems" with our previous models of space, time & gravity. Our best scientists & mathematicians cannot even test this theory let alone prove it in any evidence providing manner, yet we still believe it is true.

It is impossible to prove the existance of a God, until you experience him. In order to experience him, it is a requirement to have faith to believe that he exists. Who knows, maybe he lives in one of those 7 undiscovered dimentions.


Let me put forth the following hypothesis then. Since you say there is no scientific way to prove that God exists. But, what if there is a God and the only way to find out if he exists is to exercise faith that he exists. And, God is waiting for you to try to exercise a little faith even though it flies in the face of scientific logic. You don't ever try, what would be your answer when you face God after you die and he asks why you didn't exercise even a small amount of faith in him?

I would say, "In case you weren't aware, you gave me 5 senses. None of them indicated that you existed. Sorry."
He gave you an imagination - the ability to think & reason above and beyond the limited abilities of your senses. I mean, you do believe in other things that you cannot experience with your 5 senses. Right?


I'm must be one of those non-rabid atheists. I don't require proof that god exists, I just need some good evidence.

What would you accept as evidence? Not that I really care. I have no desire to save anyone's soul, as I believe that people can only save themselves, both in this life and any life later (if that exists). I'm just wondering what you would require. I imagine it would be something impossible, and thus would simply demonstrate an immature close-minded attitude.

Isn't one of the premises of Christianity that God is omnipotent? (I haven't been to church in eight years, but I'm pretty sure I remember at least that much )

If so, then would it really be that unreasonable to expect something otherwise considered "impossible", as far as proof that he exists?

If God did excercise something impossible/miracle that every one witessed one of two things would occur. The first, which probably happens a lot anyway, is that people who are obssessed atheists would simply attempt to rationalize the nonrational and would draw a conclusion they were comfortable with.



I was once pretty close to being aethiestic.
Call it heresay if you like, But I have personally whitnessed a few of such maracles. But no-one is going to believe it because I say it. The only way to prove it enough to believe in it (just like for myself) is to truely experience it. On 3 occasions, unexplainable(by logical terms, but explainable through prayer to God) things have happened to people at my church (currently or previously).

1)One of my friends from the past named Jason. He was injured in a ATV accident, where he drove himself into an invisible wire clothsline. the impact crushed his larynix and shattered the vibrational bones entirely. the doctors performed 3 surgeries to reconstruct his throat. They said he'd never talk again because half his voicebox is missing. Not more than 6 months later he had a full recovery. His voice was as good as new, full range singing. The doctors were amazed and said this could only be the work of a God.

2)An elderly man I know was in a car accident. He was paralized from the waist down. Spinal cord completely severed. The doctors said he would never walk or have feeling in his legs again. Once again, this man is walking today completely healed.

3)Even, I myself believe I was miraculuosly healed through prayer 2 years ago. I had been sick & urinating blood for a while, and went to the Nephrologist. I was diagnosed as having near Kidney failure. They did sample testings, & a tissue biopsy. I was suffering from a degenerative kidney disease, and there was no cure, no treatments available... soon I would be doomed to a life of dialysis 4 days a week. I went to a healing service at my church. I immediately felt better. I had a followup appointment a few weeks later. My Kidneys were restored from 15% working to 100% working. I never had 1 dialisys appontment. Since then I have had yearly kidney testing & have been trouble free. This disease didnt just go into dormant stage, it was completely gone. Every last trace.


You dont see the evidence in maracles because you fail to believe. and you fail to believe because you do not see the evidence... (Chicken and the Egg Cycle?) It is up to you to take the first step. If your awaiting God to reveal himself to you, your going to be waiting a long time.

Man I hate when people say god could live in some tiny dimension, as they use science to try to justify their mysticism.

And those are pathetic examples of miracles as well.
 

sao123

Lifer
May 27, 2002
12,653
205
106
And those are pathetic examples of miracles as well.

not sure what other type of Miracle you might be looking for...

Sorry that I couldnt just part the atlantic ocean for you to walk across it. you'd be lucky too, I dont think I could hold my hands up as long as Moses did.
Eh, you'd probably just blame it on the moon for some weird tidal pattern anyways.


I know that my healing was nothing myself, the doctors or of anyone elses doing. No Medicine, no Surgery... And my kidneys didna just instantly heal themselves...
I'm pretty sure it was a miracle.
 

Jeff7181

Lifer
Aug 21, 2002
18,368
11
81
Originally posted by: BlinderBomber
Why does religion prevail? I think every needs something to believe in. Whether its the Biblical God, math, shoelaces or jellybeans. Everybody needs to have faith. Without faith, life is empty. So why attack religion if it hasn't done anything bad to you? Why try to convince people God doesn't exist? Just let them have faith in something.

I'm sure the OP has faith is SOMETHING. Everybody does.

I agree with this idea... but not the wording.

I think people need to believe there's a reason they're here... a reason they're aware that they're here... and a reason they can contemplate why they're here. Afterall... what incentive is there to being "good" and doing the "right" thing if there's no ultimate reward in the end? Although I don't really consider myself a religious person and don't really associate myself with a religion, I'm sure glad some people do. I think the fear of the ultimate punishment, hell, is what keeps a lot of people from doing some very bad things. Unfortunately religion also inspires people to do some very bad things... some people actually believe the Muslim religion tells them it's not only ok, but it's their duty to kill those who don't believe in what they believe.
 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Seems like you're attributing the unknown to god, sao123. This is a pretty common thing among the religious, so you're certainly not alone. Your "examples" assume that 1) your retellings are 100% accurate 2) doctors know everything there is to know about the human body and 3) they were being entirely truthful instead of preparing family & friends for the worst while really hoping for the best.

Originally posted by: Jeff7181
Originally posted by: BlinderBomber
Why does religion prevail? I think every needs something to believe in. Whether its the Biblical God, math, shoelaces or jellybeans. Everybody needs to have faith. Without faith, life is empty. So why attack religion if it hasn't done anything bad to you? Why try to convince people God doesn't exist? Just let them have faith in something.

I'm sure the OP has faith is SOMETHING. Everybody does.

I agree with this idea... but not the wording.

I think people need to believe there's a reason they're here... a reason they're aware that they're here... and a reason they can contemplate why they're here. Afterall... what incentive is there to being "good" and doing the "right" thing if there's no ultimate reward in the end? Although I don't really consider myself a religious person and don't really associate myself with a religion, I'm sure glad some people do. I think the fear of the ultimate punishment, hell, is what keeps a lot of people from doing some very bad things. Unfortunately religion also inspires people to do some very bad things... some people actually believe the Muslim religion tells them it's not only ok, but it's their duty to kill those who don't believe in what they believe.

Me personally? I have faith in nothing :) My best guess as to why I'm a relatively good person is that it's due to mostly genetic code, with a little logic thrown in. I don't think the fear of hell does much, criminals tend to be among the most religious people - I quote Biggie Smalls (RIP): "real-life beginner killers praying god forgive us for being sinners" (from Sky's the Limit).
 

Jeff7181

Lifer
Aug 21, 2002
18,368
11
81
One thing that bugs me about people who believe in god is how they use god to explain the unexplained. A person gets killed in a car accident by a drunk driver... why? "It was god's will." Pffft... maybe they were just in the wrong place at the wrong time, thanks to the drunk driver. But... "it was part of god's plan for them." :roll:
</religion bashing>
 

sao123

Lifer
May 27, 2002
12,653
205
106
is how they use god to explain the unexplained

So then how do you explain miracles? Do they just not exist and everything is explainable?

If God did excercise something impossible/miracle that every one witessed one of two things would occur. The first, which probably happens a lot anyway, is that people who are obssessed atheists would simply attempt to rationalize the nonrational and would draw a conclusion they were comfortable with.
Whoever posted this is definately correct. Aethiest dont have evidence to support the existance of God because they dont want it.
 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: sao123
is how they use god to explain the unexplained

So then how do you explain miracles? Do they just not exist and everything is explainable?

In a word, yes. I know it sounds boring, but then reality often does. This is why we enjoy ghost stories, tales of UFOs, etc.

Originally posted by: sao123
Aethiest dont have evidence to support the existance of God because they dont want it.
This from someone who just got done telling us that there is no evidence; that it requires faith? ;)
 

sao123

Lifer
May 27, 2002
12,653
205
106
This from someone who just got done telling us that there is no evidence; that it requires faith?

I believe what I said was...
It is impossible to prove the existance of a God, until you experience him. In order to experience him, it is a requirement to have faith to believe that he exists.

Without faith there is no evidence, no experience. With faith, evidence exists, you can experience it. Aethiest cannot see or experience the evidence because they do not have the faith to believe in it.
 

jagec

Lifer
Apr 30, 2004
24,442
6
81
Originally posted by: Jeff7181
One thing that bugs me about people who believe in god is how they use god to explain the unexplained. A person gets killed in a car accident by a drunk driver... why? "It was god's will." Pffft... maybe they were just in the wrong place at the wrong time, thanks to the drunk driver. But... "it was part of god's plan for them." :roll:
</religion bashing>

yeah, those people are pretty stupid. That, or more deterministic than they realize.

Originally posted by: Gurck
Seems like you're attributing the unknown to god, sao123. This is a pretty common thing among the religious, so you're certainly not alone. Your "examples" assume that 1) your retellings are 100% accurate 2) doctors know everything there is to know about the human body and 3) they were being entirely truthful instead of preparing family & friends for the worst while really hoping for the best.

The problem with both atheists and Christians is that neither of them really use Occam's razor. I won't deny that Christians often stretch scientific evidence to try to make it fit creationism, but atheists also stretch things like sao123 mentioned to try to make it fit their views (and I've heard much more extreme stories than that from personal witnesses). Every so often, things happen in the world that completely defy explanation, and trying to come up with some ludicrous juxtaposition of effects to explain it is just as bad as the Christians claiming erosion effects were all caused by a giant flood.

It reminds me of MIB, with the stereotypical government coverups of UFOs with far-fetched swamp gas explanations for something that is clearly out of the ordinary. Everyone KNOWS the explanation is really weak, but it's good enough to keep them from having to challenge their current set of beliefs, so they choose to buy it.

Evidence just doesn't convince people like it should.
 

TheBDB

Diamond Member
Jan 26, 2002
3,176
0
0
Originally posted by: sao123
This from someone who just got done telling us that there is no evidence; that it requires faith?

I believe what I said was...
It is impossible to prove the existance of a God, until you experience him. In order to experience him, it is a requirement to have faith to believe that he exists.

Without faith there is no evidence, no experience. With faith, evidence exists, you can experience it. Aethiest cannot see or experience the evidence because they do not have the faith to believe in it.

I think I may agree with you on this one. People certainly can convince themselves of the stupidest $hit.
 

Cerb

Elite Member
Aug 26, 2000
17,484
33
86
Originally posted by: sao123
is how they use god to explain the unexplained
So then how do you explain miracles? Do they just not exist and everything is explainable?
Miracles, like coincedences, are simply a way of explaining that we haven't figured enough out about ourselves or the universe, to this point. Called it unexplainable, or unsovlable, helps make it so.
 

Machine350

Senior member
Oct 8, 2004
537
0
0
Christian vs. Atheist. If Atheist is right, Christian ceases to exist, loses nothing. If Christian is right, Atheist spends an eternity in hell by his/her own choice, loses everything. Big gamble if you ask me.
 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: jagec
atheists also stretch things like sao123 mentioned to try to make it fit their views
Evidence just doesn't convince people like it should.
His examples are anecdotal. Anecdotes and a few agenda-fueled studies are all they can come up with. That's not evidence.

It reminds me of MIB, with the stereotypical government coverups of UFOs with far-fetched swamp gas explanations for something that is clearly out of the ordinary. Everyone KNOWS the explanation is really weak, but it's good enough to keep them from having to challenge their current set of beliefs, so they choose to buy it.
Quoting a movie is actually an excellent example of my point. Real-life mundane things are, obviously, nothing out of the ordinary. We crave excitement in our lives; it's why I play way too many video games, it's why many people watch way too much TV & too many movies, why some (a shrinking number, unfortunately) read a lot, and why in the past, before many of these things were available at all, or as available as they are today, many people turned to religion. We still see a good example of it being an alternative to boredom in the fact that people in rural areas are more likely to be religious and have religion play a larger role in their lives than those in urban areas.
 

TheBDB

Diamond Member
Jan 26, 2002
3,176
0
0
Originally posted by: Machine350
Christian vs. Atheist. If Atheist is right, Christian ceases to exist, loses nothing. If Christian is right, Atheist spends an eternity in hell by his/her own choice, loses everything. Big gamble if you ask me.

:roll:

If you don't believe that I am god you are going to suffer worse than hell. Do you believe I am god? Big gamble if you ask me...