Originally posted by: Armitage
Originally posted by: MAME
Originally posted by: Armitage
Originally posted by: MAME
Originally posted by: Armitage
Originally posted by: MAME
are you starting to realize how little grades matter in the real world?
Grades do matter in the real world - college admissions, first job out of college, etc. But they mean jack for these kinds of summer jobs.
college != real world
:roll: It's more "real world" then H.S. - if nothing else, it's an important stepping stone to the "real world" and grades do matter for college admissions.
I spoke to all my peers about grades in the workplace, EVERY single one said that they were never asked about grades nor did the employer really care. They have tests in the interviews that tell more than grades ever could.
My peers are working for a wide range of companies: Google, Apple, O'Reilly, Adobe, etc.
Exact opposite of my experience - I've never heard anybody giving tests in interviews for any level position in my field (aerospace engineering). I have been asked about college GPA in interviews.
Grades aren't very important once you're a few years out and have some experience/references. But for an entry level job, they are definitely considered. I know that for certain, as I've been involved in the hiring process.
The problem is a person's GPA does not correspond with their intelligence. Therefore, especially in my field (CS), tests and questions are mandatory for the hiring process and are infinitly more telling than any GPA. Friends of mine who work at Agilent were taking tests for 8! hours for an entry level position
So what exactly does a high GPA measure? I'd argue that it indicates a mastery of the subject matter presented. Which in itself may be of little use - I rarely if ever use the material I learned in undergrad, or even grad school. What it indicates is an ability & willingness to learn and a drive to be succesful at it. You can come by it in two ways in my experience - lots of hard work by a moderatly bright person (ie. strong work ethic), or little effort by someone very intelligent. I'd say that either trait is highly sought after depending on the environment, and most people are somewhere between those extremes.
Regarding testing ... I can't imagine a single test - even one 8 hours long - being a good predictor of success in the jobs I've had. None of them have involved stuff taught in undergrad programs to more then a supeficial level. The only thing I could see testing on is math. What has been important is a strong work ethic, the ability to learn quickly and independently, creativity, and the ability to do research. At the entry level, you look for that, then grow your own so to speak. Academic performance certainly doesn't address all of that, except at the graduate level, but I'd take somebody who stuck it out and did well over 4 years at a good school over somebody that manages to do very well in a single test. It might be the right answer for some positions, but nothing that I've worked in.