Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: EpsiIon
Originally posted by: Wingznut
Originally posted by: Zogglet
I don't have a problem with RTS's, but I can't stand many RPG's. The problem is because your abilities are based on how strong your character is, not how strong you are. In an FPS, it's pure skill.
I agree. And turn-based battles make me nauseous.
It's a totally different set of "pure skill"...
FPS's require quick reactions, wheras RPG's require making the right choices and pursuing the best paths. Your character is as strong as the choices you make. Two people can be playing the exact same race and class for the exact same hours and still have very different character strenghths/traits.
They are very different genres... And both most definitely have their place in my gaming world.
The problem with a lot of RPGs is that the best path is often completely obvious. At that point, it's not about your skill in anything other than seeing the obvious.
You must be confused . . . . most FPS are "linear" and "obvious" . . . let's take Doom III as an example . . . NO ONE asked for help (well almost no one) since it was so linear and damn obvious . . . . if you get stuck, look up or down, behind something or blow something up.

:roll:
With a RPG, you are forced to THINK . . . . there are (usually) so many DIFFERENT ways to tackle an objective . . . . in this particular case, FPS can't hold a candle to RPG's
complexity.
:shocked:
edit: i believe the ONLY people putting RPG's "down" have never completed a good one.*
:shocked:
:roll:
:thumbsdown:
*heck, i was "there" a month ago . . . at that time, reading
Wingznut's comments were like 'WTH is he babbling about?!?' . . . now i know.