Why are (many) FPS Fans bored to tears by RTS/RPG Games?

Page 5 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Wingznut

Elite Member
Dec 28, 1999
16,968
2
0
Originally posted by: apoppin
. . . at that time, reading Wingznut's comments were like 'WTH is he babbling about?!?' . . . now i know. ;)
:)
Heh... Wait until you try a really good mmorpg such as WoW. (Didn't you say before that your internet connection prohibited you from such an addiction?)
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: Wingznut
Originally posted by: apoppin
. . . at that time, reading Wingznut's comments were like 'WTH is he babbling about?!?' . . . now i know. ;)
:)
Heh... Wait until you try a really good mmorpg such as WoW. (Didn't you say before that your internet connection prohibited you from such an addiction?)

i am in a very rural area . . . all of my neighbors are on either 2-1/2 or 5 acres and it "isn't worth it" for the cable company to install cable on our road . . . dsl is out and that leaves . . .

. . . (think - Practical) . . . 56K dial-up. :disgust:
. . . so NO MMOrpg . . . ever :p
(i like it here; bought it back in '84) :)

so credit me with "baby steps" . . . i've been enjoying FPS since there was FPS; never played D'n'D and couldn't make it past the 2nd hour of any previous RPG without crying tears of boredom . . .

. . . and now i'm thinkin' of KotOR II ;)

:D

edit: that's why i read threads i currently have minimal interest in . . . that's how i learned about KotOR . . . . the enthusiasm over it was obvious . . . and i even keep up with WoW threads. ;)
 

EpsiIon

Platinum Member
Nov 26, 2000
2,351
1
0
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: EpsiIon
Originally posted by: Wingznut
Originally posted by: Zogglet
I don't have a problem with RTS's, but I can't stand many RPG's. The problem is because your abilities are based on how strong your character is, not how strong you are. In an FPS, it's pure skill.
I agree. And turn-based battles make me nauseous.
It's a totally different set of "pure skill"...

FPS's require quick reactions, wheras RPG's require making the right choices and pursuing the best paths. Your character is as strong as the choices you make. Two people can be playing the exact same race and class for the exact same hours and still have very different character strenghths/traits.

They are very different genres... And both most definitely have their place in my gaming world. :)

The problem with a lot of RPGs is that the best path is often completely obvious. At that point, it's not about your skill in anything other than seeing the obvious.

You must be confused . . . . most FPS are "linear" and "obvious" . . . let's take Doom III as an example . . . NO ONE asked for help (well almost no one) since it was so linear and damn obvious . . . . if you get stuck, look up or down, behind something or blow something up. :p
:roll:

With a RPG, you are forced to THINK . . . . there are (usually) so many DIFFERENT ways to tackle an objective . . . . in this particular case, FPS can't hold a candle to RPG's complexity.
:shocked:

edit: i believe the ONLY people putting RPG's "down" have never completed a good one.*
:shocked:
:roll:

:thumbsdown:

*heck, i was "there" a month ago . . . at that time, reading Wingznut's comments were like 'WTH is he babbling about?!?' . . . now i know. ;)
:)

Oh, I love good RPGs. It's just that all too often you aren't really building your character. It's more like you're taking the obvious steps in you character's progression. And once you've figured out that "optimal build," there's nothing left except the story (which had better be good). With a good FPS or RTS, there's at least multiplayer. Human opponents usually provide interesting challenges, whereas solving the same puzzle over and over gets boring quickly.

BTW, I think Doom 3 is crap. I enjoyed HL2 for its interesting and varied gameplay, but I don't think I'll be playing it through again for a while. In the meantime, I'll enjoy all the mods coming out.
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: biostud
Most anticipated game EV4R!!!! :)

I'm not really into RPG and RTS either. I might give return of the king a try though.
I enjoyed playing C&C generals single player, and W40K: Dawn of war, though

now you got me curious . . . . What IS the most anticipated game . . . . ever?
(NO LINK):p
:roll:

(if i had to guess, i would have said Doom iii or HL2 were the most anticipated PC games . . . so far)

=====================
Originally posted by: EpsiIon

Oh, I love good RPGs. It's just that all too often you aren't really building your character. It's more like you're taking the obvious steps in you character's progression. And once you've figured out that "optimal build," there's nothing left except the story (which had better be good). With a good FPS or RTS, there's at least multiplayer. Human opponents usually provide interesting challenges, whereas solving the same puzzle over and over gets boring quickly.

BTW, I think Doom 3 is crap. I enjoyed HL2 for its interesting and varied gameplay, but I don't think I'll be playing it through again for a while. In the meantime, I'll enjoy all the mods coming out.

Agreed on Doom iii (crap) and HL2 (excellent; definitely try Chron of Riddick, an awesome "sleeper") Any more suggestions for RPGs i might enjoy? Next on my list is KotOR II (obviously - when it is patched and maybe bargain bin) .. . . . maybe Vampire: Bloodlines?

Yep, the "story" is paramount in a RPG . . . "action" in a FPS.

Anyway, my NEXT game is System Shock 2 . . . . (installed, patched, gfx updated and "workarounds" in place for Win2K) :)
 

Wingznut

Elite Member
Dec 28, 1999
16,968
2
0
Originally posted by: EpsiIon
Oh, I love good RPGs. It's just that all too often you aren't really building your character. It's more like you're taking the obvious steps in you character's progression. And once you've figured out that "optimal build," there's nothing left except the story (which had better be good). With a good FPS or RTS, there's at least multiplayer. Human opponents usually provide interesting challenges, whereas solving the same puzzle over and over gets boring quickly.
That's where MMORPG's really step up... The progression is incredibly dynamic and even if you do the same quests, it's not always the same experience. For example...

A few weeks ago I was on a quest (in WoW) where I had to infiltrate a Murloc camp. Unfortunately, my char wasn't strong enough to do it alone (but that didn't stop me from trying. ;) ) So, I ask to see if anyone else needs this quest and wants to help out. It's like 2am, so I didn't expect (nor get) much of a response. A minute later, a player runs through the camp and ends up getting the attention of the Murlocs. I start to follow, thinking I can help him out, when I realize that the camp is almost empty and there's my object of desire sitting there unguarded!!! So, I finished my quest never knowing if the guy survived, helped me intentionally, or was just trying to get to the other side.

That's something you'll never experience in a FPS. :cool:
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
But you do experience "surprise" in a first-person FPS and i often marvel at the cleverness at which something is implemented.

When i thought i had seen every variation of "straight" FPSes ("not hybreds") along came Chronicles of Riddick with a different way of doing just about everything . . . instead of the clumbersome "light/stealth meter" - when you are in "stealth mode" - the perspective alters and a blue tinge comes over the screen . . . . much more realistic and you get the impression you are actually "stalking" someone.

"Bullet time" in Max Payne also "grabbed" me; so the the gravity gun in HL2 (pardon the pun) . . . even a 'mindless twitch shooter' like PK/BoOH exhibited depth and surprising replay value. And of course, the hybreds, SS2 and DE (inluding Thief series) allow a much more "open-ended" experience with an excellent story.Then there are the human opponents of ONline FPS games which provide endless amusement.

Since i am stuck on dial-up - and can never experience ONline - what other RPGs are "strong" in the story like KotOR that might have good gfx also?
(remember i am a fledgling RPGer and can be discouraged easily) :roll:

 

biostud

Lifer
Feb 27, 2003
19,739
6,817
136
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: biostud
Most anticipated game EV4R!!!! :)

I'm not really into RPG and RTS either. I might give return of the king a try though.
I enjoyed playing C&C generals single player, and W40K: Dawn of war, though

now you got me curious . . . . What IS the most anticipated game . . . . ever?
(NO LINK):p
:roll:

(if i had to guess, i would have said Doom iii or HL2 were the most anticipated PC games . . . so far)


Gaaaargh
Linkyfied
 

EpsiIon

Platinum Member
Nov 26, 2000
2,351
1
0
Originally posted by: apoppin
Any more suggestions for RPGs i might enjoy?

If you've never played them, Fallout and Fallout 2 are amazing (Fallout 2 > Fallout, IMO). I got a copy of Fallout 2 on ebay several years ago for $5 shipped. Just be sure to download the patch from Interplay's site if you get Fallout 2.
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: biostud
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: biostud
Most anticipated game EV4R!!!! :)

I'm not really into RPG and RTS either. I might give return of the king a try though.
I enjoyed playing C&C generals single player, and W40K: Dawn of war, though

now you got me curious . . . . What IS the most anticipated game . . . . ever?
(NO LINK):p
:roll:

(if i had to guess, i would have said Doom iii or HL2 were the most anticipated PC games . . . so far)


Gaaaargh
Linkyfied

What was i supposed to do? . . . guess? :p
(a dead link is a dead link):frown:
:roll:

Heroes of Might and Magic V:shocked:

first of all, isn't it "strategy"?

secondly, i have the old "Might and Magic VI - The Mandate of Heaven" from '98 . . . any relation?
that game was b-o-r-i-n-g . . . . :p

++++++++++++++++++++
Originally posted by: EpsiIon
Originally posted by: apoppin
Any more suggestions for RPGs i might enjoy?

If you've never played them, Fallout and Fallout 2 are amazing (Fallout 2 > Fallout, IMO). I got a copy of Fallout 2 on ebay several years ago for $5 shipped. Just be sure to download the patch from Interplay's site if you get Fallout 2.
Isn't the gfx really dated?
 

biostud

Lifer
Feb 27, 2003
19,739
6,817
136
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: biostud
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: biostud
Most anticipated game EV4R!!!! :)

I'm not really into RPG and RTS either. I might give return of the king a try though.
I enjoyed playing C&C generals single player, and W40K: Dawn of war, though

now you got me curious . . . . What IS the most anticipated game . . . . ever?
(NO LINK):p
:roll:

(if i had to guess, i would have said Doom iii or HL2 were the most anticipated PC games . . . so far)


Gaaaargh
Linkyfied

What was i supposed to do? . . . guess? :p
(a dead link is a dead link):frown:
:roll:

Heroes of Might and Magic V:shocked:

first of all, isn't it "strategy"?

secondly, i have the old "Might and Magic VI - The Mandate of Heaven" from '98 . . . any relation?
that game was b-o-r-i-n-g . . . . :p

It's Heroes of Might and Magic V. A turnbased strategygame with elements of RPG's as you build up your heroes. Only the universe is the the same as the might and magic series, gameplay are totally different. HoMM III is probably the game I've played the most ever.

The Gaaaaargh was over my own inability to link properly :p
 

DaveSimmons

Elite Member
Aug 12, 2001
40,730
670
126
Originally posted by: EpsiIon
If you've never played them, Fallout and Fallout 2 are amazing (Fallout 2 > Fallout, IMO). I got a copy of Fallout 2 on ebay several years ago for $5 shipped. Just be sure to download the patch from Interplay's site if you get Fallout 2.
Great games, though some people can't stand the dated graphics (640x480 2D isometric).

I enjoyed their combat more than in KOTOR since instead of sitting back and letting the computer crunch numbers you play one turn at a time. Battles take longer (and difficulty is set higher than KOTOR) but every shot counts for more.

Good stories too, especially Fallout 1.

HoMM III is probably the game I've played the most ever.
Excellent game, too back HOMM IV was garbage.
 

biostud

Lifer
Feb 27, 2003
19,739
6,817
136
Originally posted by: DaveSimmons
Originally posted by: EpsiIon
If you've never played them, Fallout and Fallout 2 are amazing (Fallout 2 > Fallout, IMO). I got a copy of Fallout 2 on ebay several years ago for $5 shipped. Just be sure to download the patch from Interplay's site if you get Fallout 2.
Great games, though some people can't stand the dated graphics (640x480 2D isometric).

I enjoyed their combat more than in KOTOR since instead of sitting back and letting the computer crunch numbers you play one turn at a time. Battles take longer (and difficulty is set higher than KOTOR) but every shot counts for more.

Good stories too, especially Fallout 1.

HoMM III is probably the game I've played the most ever.
Excellent game, too back HOMM IV was garbage.

If only the AI and the netcode wasn't foobared badly in IV......... :D
 

EpsiIon

Platinum Member
Nov 26, 2000
2,351
1
0
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: EpsiIon
Originally posted by: apoppin
Any more suggestions for RPGs i might enjoy?

If you've never played them, Fallout and Fallout 2 are amazing (Fallout 2 > Fallout, IMO). I got a copy of Fallout 2 on ebay several years ago for $5 shipped. Just be sure to download the patch from Interplay's site if you get Fallout 2.
Isn't the gfx really dated?

You aren't serious, are you? Yes, the game looks old. But if you can't appreciate a game without modern graphics, you aren't a true gamer. :p
 

ponyo

Lifer
Feb 14, 2002
19,688
2,811
126
apoppin, have you tried Balder's Gate 2? Graphics are little dated but I've heard the gameplay and the story is excellent. You can pick up the collection with the expansion pack for less than $20.
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: EpsiIon
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: EpsiIon
Originally posted by: apoppin
Any more suggestions for RPGs i might enjoy?

If you've never played them, Fallout and Fallout 2 are amazing (Fallout 2 > Fallout, IMO). I got a copy of Fallout 2 on ebay several years ago for $5 shipped. Just be sure to download the patch from Interplay's site if you get Fallout 2.
Isn't the gfx really dated?

You aren't serious, are you? Yes, the game looks old. But if you can't appreciate a game without modern graphics, you aren't a true gamer. :p

so . . . do you still play Pong? . . . it is a classic and the grandfather of modern games. :p
:roll:

i really DO appreciate the suggestions (if not the snide comment) - but you must remember i am a FPS player (very definitely "spoiled" ANYWAY with the generally better gfx of the FPS over the RPG) and it is very difficult for me to play something that looks worse than the original Doom (what is it, 6x4 max res?)
:shocked:
+++++++++++++++++++++++==

Originally posted by: biostud
Originally posted by: apoppin

Heroes of Might and Magic V:shocked:

first of all, isn't it "strategy"?

secondly, i have the old "Might and Magic VI - The Mandate of Heaven" from '98 . . . any relation?
that game was b-o-r-i-n-g . . . . :p

It's Heroes of Might and Magic V. A turnbased strategygame with elements of RPG's as you build up your heroes. Only the universe is the the same as the might and magic series, gameplay are totally different. HoMM III is probably the game I've played the most ever.

The Gaaaaargh was over my own inability to link properly :p
RTS is completely foreign to me . . . . maybe that's why i couldn't figure the '98 game. :confused:

i get it about the "Gaaaaargh" . . . . i though it was a comment on my currently non-functional psychic receptors.

:D

=======================
Originally posted by: Naustica
apoppin, have you tried Balder's Gate 2? Graphics are little dated but I've heard the gameplay and the story is excellent. You can pick up the collection with the expansion pack for less than $20.

Only the 650MB demo a couple of years ago . . . . if i remember right, it's mostly 2D and the fighting is even stranger than KotOR's. :confused:

 

Xyclone

Lifer
Aug 24, 2004
10,312
0
76
Actually, I got sick of FPS's for the time being. WoW is a really good game, and definitely wins the award for replay value inmho.
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: Xyclone
Actually, I got sick of FPS's for the time being. WoW is a really good game, and definitely wins the award for replay value inmho.

unfortunately it is MMOrpg and i am stuck on dial-up. :p

i saw your other post on its addictive qualities . . . . not sure i want something so "open" and non-ending. . . . i really DO like games that have an "ending". ;)
 

Wingznut

Elite Member
Dec 28, 1999
16,968
2
0
Originally posted by: apoppin
But you do experience "surprise" in a first-person FPS and i often marvel at the cleverness at which something is implemented.
Well, sure... But that's completely different.

What you are describing is a one-time, scripted/planned event. Using the Riddick stealth perspective as an example, once you've experienced it, it never changes. If you go back and play the game again, it doesn't change.

What I was trying to describe (in WoW) is a completely dynamic event. There's no way that anyone planned for my quest to go the way it did. These type of events cannot be scripted.



As for another RPG... If you like KOTOR, you are undoubtedly going to like KOTOR 2. :)
 

biostud

Lifer
Feb 27, 2003
19,739
6,817
136
Originally posted by: apoppin


RTS is completely foreign to me . . . . maybe that's why i couldn't figure the '98 game. :confused:

i get it about the "Gaaaaargh" . . . . i though it was a comment on my currently non-functional psychic receptors.

:D

it's not RTS (Real Time strategy), it's TBS (Turn based strategy) it's quite relaxing and very addictive between playing FPS'. I would still recommend it as you should be able to find it dirt cheap in the bargain bin with all expansions. It's also a great game for playing when you have friends over as you can play hotseat, and play 2 vs 6 computers :)
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: biostud
Originally posted by: apoppin


RTS is completely foreign to me . . . . maybe that's why i couldn't figure the '98 game. :confused:

i get it about the "Gaaaaargh" . . . . i though it was a comment on my currently non-functional psychic receptors.

:D

it's not RTS (Real Time strategy), it's TBS (Turn based strategy) it's quite relaxing and very addictive between playing FPS'. I would still recommend it as you should be able to find it dirt cheap in the bargain bin with all expansions. It's also a great game for playing when you have friends over as you can play hotseat, and play 2 vs 6 computers :)

Turn-based strategy!?!?
:shocked:

i'll google that
:confused:

i guess you are talking Fallout1/2 . . . sorry, i guess - according to the elitists here - i am not a "true" gamer (i.e. i don't play text-based games :p) and even have difficulty getting "immersed" with the original Dark Engine's Gfx Engine (thief1/SS2) . . . although SS2 is OK with the improved resolutions pack . . . .
:roll:
++++++++++++++++++++++
Originally posted by: Wingznut
Originally posted by: apoppin
But you do experience "surprise" in a first-person FPS and i often marvel at the cleverness at which something is implemented.
Well, sure... But that's completely different.

What you are describing is a one-time, scripted/planned event. Using the Riddick stealth perspective as an example, once you've experienced it, it never changes. If you go back and play the game again, it doesn't change.

What I was trying to describe (in WoW) is a completely dynamic event. There's no way that anyone planned for my quest to go the way it did. These type of events cannot be scripted.

As for another RPG... If you like KOTOR, you are undoubtedly going to like KOTOR 2. :)
it may never change . . . but it never gets "old" . . . but i DO understand what you are saying . . . . you get the "human" element in the online play.

it IS unfortunate i cannot experience it (or not . . . it could be TOO addiciting)

and KotOR II is a "given" . . . IF it EVER gets patched. :p
===============================

Any other good RPGs?

Vampire: Bloodlines?
(the gfx are supposed to be first class with a good story)

--------------------------
edit:
right now, i am only taking "suggestions" . . . . i am completely immersed in another "real-time" GAME with consequences that MUST be completed by April 15 :p
(it's like a "sim" using 1040 forms) ;)

:(

the objective of this "game" is to avoid "penalties" and worst - an "audit" . . . . unfortunately this "game" gives me a lingering headache (although it is ultimately "satisfying" when you win) and although i HATE playing it, it manages to sucker me back EVERY year.
:roll:

:thumbsdown:


:D

 

Fern

Elite Member
Sep 30, 2003
26,907
174
106
right now, i am only taking "suggestions" . . . . i am completely immersed in another "real-time" GAME with consequences that MUST be completed by April 15
(it's like a "sim" using 1040 forms)



the objective of this "game" is to avoid "penalties" and worst - an "audit" . . . . unfortunately this "game" gives me a lingering headache (although it is ultimately "satisfying" when you win) and although i HATE playing it, it manages to sucker me back EVERY year.

Hmm... This game sounds familiar to me ;)

Fern (aka Tax Accountant)
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: Fern
right now, i am only taking "suggestions" . . . . i am completely immersed in another "real-time" GAME with consequences that MUST be completed by April 15
(it's like a "sim" using 1040 forms)



the objective of this "game" is to avoid "penalties" and worst - an "audit" . . . . unfortunately this "game" gives me a lingering headache (although it is ultimately "satisfying" when you win) and although i HATE playing it, it manages to sucker me back EVERY year.

Hmm... This game sounds familiar to me ;)

Fern (aka Tax Accountant)

at LEAST you MAKE money from this game :p
:roll:

(i just get to "keep" what's mine) :cookie:

;)

at least this year :)

any suggestions (after SS2) and the "Tax Game v.'04" for another good (lite) RPG?

and Fern, any impressions on HL2 yet?
 

Fern

Elite Member
Sep 30, 2003
26,907
174
106
Sorry to say I haven't got it installed yet :(

I spent this week reformating and reinstalling. I was being "aggressive" and trying to setup a triple system with 98se, w2kpro & XP. Also installing my new 6800GT and new gig of ram. Wanna do some testing/benchies.

Anyway, I think I've fouled it up. Usually when installing an OC I'll roll my cpu back to desktop speds of a 2500+. BUt since this build has been so solid with the OC I just set it back to 3200+ speeds.

I mean it ran through all benchies fine, all numbers as they should be. But last night the games I have installed so far started acting up :thumbsdown:

Now I'm reading in another post that the vcore settings for a mobile aren't quitre right. The mobile "interprets" the BIOS data differently than a desktop. The result being (according this news) is that my vcore setting of 1.55v is actually resulting in only 1.40v to the cpu. I might have a good chip, but I don't think it'll run stable @ 2200mhz with 1.40 vcore?

I can't stand instability! Looks like I've gotta start over, D@mn it :|

Hopefully, by this weekend I'll have it up (hmmm.. I've never networked win98se with w2kpro, hope thats easy. I need to get on my work network to d/l the steam stuff)

Have you gotten anywhere with SS2?

Fern
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
nope, nowhere past the first cutscene or so . . . SS2 seems to work - and save - fine - except it will just crash every now and then . . . i think it is because it was not designed for NT o/s . . . . if it gets really bad, i will do a dual-book with Win98SE . . . but NOT until my taxes are done . . . i managed to mess up my computer one year just before April 15 and had to do an extension while i sorted everything out . . . i'm taking no [extra] chances this year. :p

good luck with your reinstall if necessary . . . did you try boosting the vcore anyway? ~10% seems pretty "safe".

i don't think it is hard to network win98se with win2k - you just don't get all the functionality of 2 XP'd or 2 - networked win2k systems.

i know you're gonna love your new videocard . . . . i am looking to get one probably Late Summer . . . also the reload times are much better with a GB of RAM.