Skyclad1uhm1
Lifer
- Aug 10, 2001
- 11,383
- 87
- 91
Without flaming, to my opinion you cannot truly believe without having questioned and challenged every detail of it.
Or at least I cannot.
Or at least I cannot.
Originally posted by: Netopia
Out of deference to Metalloid15 I'll not be responding to further debate in this thread. If someone has a burning desire to continue, start a new thread and PM me an invite and I'll be happy to continue there.
Metalloid15, I appologize for my part in the disruption.
Joe
Originally posted by: Antisocial-Virge
nd I would really like to spread it to non-Christians.is there a refferal bonus?![]()
Originally posted by: Metalloid15
The incompetence on this forum is beyond my understanding.
Would you guys like me to start a private topic for just the 6 of you so you can flame each other without ruining my thread?
Originally posted by: Jzero
Would you guys like me to start a private topic for just the 6 of you so you can flame each other without ruining my thread?
Originally posted by: bthorny
Why don't you just start up a yahoo group or something.
and tell people if they are interest to go there and sign up
I for one highly believe in the seperation of Anandtech and Church.
Originally posted by: Jzero
Sorry, Metalloid15. I don't have much tolerance for ValsalvaYourHeartOut and QTArrythmic (as if we can't figure out it's just one guy anyway) after their history in Hot Deals. I'll let you deal with them derailing your thread as you see fit.
Originally posted by: MercenaryForHire
I love this thread.
If it works properly, it'll cut the number of religion threads down to nothing, and have the added benefit of keeping the "born-agains" happy.
So should I start a "Born Again Ditched Religion" thread in the sake of being fair? We could all join up and flame away, and you wouldn't have to hear anything of it.
- M4H
Originally posted by: Netopia
The publication is demonstrating a key principle of evolution. Since evolution takes billions of years, it is impossible for scientists to demonstrate a situation that you suggest.
Quite true. So one has to ask one's self... "if science demands 'proof' and yet there is something that it cannot prove via the scientific method, why does it treat this thing as fact and not as faith in a possible theory?" Belief in something unprovable is faith, regardless of whether that thing is material or spiritual.
If evil is the end result of sin, then for God to not allow evil to exist would be akin to asking why, when you let go of a ball over a deep hole, does God allow it to fall in. It is the nature of things that every action has an equal and opposite reaction. If one does something that is in direct oppostion to God (the good) then the result of this action is bad (evil). If God did not allow for this, then He would have made us all robots without the ability to do anything except what He knows is good. A loving God desires loving relationships with His creations; not to be the ultimate control freak. He lets us (singularly and corporately) make our own decisions and suffer the consequences for those decisions... both singularly and corporately.Example, how is it that a truly loving God would allow "evil" to exist, or His true followers to go through misery and pain.
The question that we SHOULD be asking ourselves is VERY close to what you asked... why would a loving God allow any of US who are evil to exist with Him eternally? That is the real question. The true answer to your question is probably that He shouldn't allow evil to exist... he should nuke us all because at one point or another each of us has done something which resulted in evil. But He is a loving parent, giving each of us time to turn away from what we've done and accept His forgiveness in Christ; He took the punishment on Himself. Only a truly loving God would be willing to be long suffering and put up with the bad so that in the end some might be saved instead of all being done away with.
As for misery and pain... I make no bones about the fact that these things are incredibly hard to stomach. From a strictly physical level these things seem to be the most evil things that exist. But look at the first century Christians who were being fed to lions... and walked out into the arena singing and praising God. What ODD behaviour! So odd in fact that some Roman soldiers were so taken by it that they themselves wanted to understand the peace these people had... and some of them also ended up being saved. Why were these people not cursing God for their situation? Faith!
Look at "Fear Factor".... people are willing to do all sorts of terrifying, discusting, sickening things to gain some money that will soon be gone. What would those people do for 100 Billion dollars? Would they be willing to engage in even more outrageous endevours? Probably. Why? Because the things they are going through are of less value to them than the prize that they hope for... and only ONE of them gets the prize! Consider Christians who are suffering now but having a faith, a conviction, a knowledge.... that what is currently going on is of FAR less value to them than the prize that they hope for (eternal life with God). What if they knew that showing others their suffering in a gracious and peaceful way might lead others to the grand prize also? Amazing love that a person would willingly suffer in order to try an help someone else gain the Grand Prize. In order to understand why He would allow His true followers to suffer, I would suggest reading some of the accounts of those followers. The "Voice of the Martyrs" has a nice book entitled "Jesus Freak" which has the story of dozens who have GLADLY suffered... isn't that weird? GLADLY SUFFERING....
People question the Bible and its interpretation all the time. The longer I live the more I understand things and realize that I've understood them less well in the past. The Christian walk is MUCH like that of being a scientist. The Bible even tells us to test what we hear... make sure it fits and is true and not to simply believe because it has been told to us. In fact, it says that to do so is "more noble" than not testing. I sometimes drive even other Christians crazy because I play devil's advocate with the Scriptures, looking for inconsistancies and things that don't fit or why something should be interpreted one way and not another. And from that, my knowledge and understanding grows.... isn't that just what a scientist does?Unlike the Bible, scientific publications are open for public criticism and debate. People have the right and are encouraged to question the validity of scientific research. Therefore, science is the best the way to pursue the truth about life.
If you look at science, it has often in the past said that something is so, and then later recants because of new knowledge. Science is willing to make absolute statements based on current knowledge only... and it then allows itself to be proven wrong. What if instead, science would only say that "from what we currently know, we think that maybe this or that are fact... but we'll never really know because there is always new data that may come and change our thinking."? If science would take that view... which is a more valid view than constantly changing what "facts" are.... they would have to be willing to admit that there may be a spirit realm which is currently undetectable and immeasurable. They would take the spirit realm and religion into consideration even though they can neither prove nor measure them. You may say that science cannot do that, but observe that quantum physics says that there may be as many as 10 dimensions (string theory) or even 11 dimensions (M-Theory)... but only THREE dimensions can be observed and measured! One has to wonder why it's ok in science to have "faith" in things unproven and to use the immaterial and immeasurable to prove theory... but ONLY if it doesn't include the spiritual.
Hmmmm..... sounds like you are describing the use of evolution to describe how life came into being... which evolution doesn't even deal with. It's much easier to say "billions and billions of years and so it all evolved" and expect people to simply believe because the number of years is so large. Time doesn't explain anything.... except to those who are willing to put "faith" in it. JoeHowever, back then, this was the only type of explanation the average person could comprehend, and it "seemed to make sense." Besides, it's much easier to have ideas spoonfed to you by others than to come up with original ideas. Why not. What the heck.
Originally posted by: QTArrhythmic
Man... this post was so darned good it needed to be repeated!![]()
I pop in from time to time whenever there's a religious thread. It's quite sad most of the time, since the unbelievers are often extremely vocal and downright rude (and they say Bible-thumpers cram stuff down THEIR throats??) and have quick, pat answers to everything. Not to most of them are factual, but common.
I don't just BELIEVE in Jesus (even the devils believe, and they tremble!) I FOLLOW Him. I try my best to walk the walk and keep in constant contact. I've changed over the last five years, to the point where I can look back and see the person I used to be - and I don't like him. I like the person I am now, though I realize I still have some weaknesses I need help with... the journey is far from complete.
For the atheists and agnostics visiting, I'd like to say something; I was once exactly as you. I knew all the answers, thought Christianity was silly (though I could never quite deny the existance of God...) and thought that Science had ALL the answers. Yeah, all that common knowledge is proven stuff - everyone knows the earth is billions of years old, everyone knows we evolved from monkey-thingy, everyone knows.....
..... guess what? I've done some research. Most of this "common knowlegde" is not based on fact, only theory - most of them very unproven.
I've never, ever been one to make a decision lightly (you should see my history in the Video card forums!) so to actually make the official decision to not just believe, but to actually FOLLOW Jesus was one that took some careful planning and research. What I found over the last 5 years has shocked me and changed my whole world, and I've still only scraped the surface. Archaeology, history, science, other literature and more... the more I learn, the more the Bible seems constant and unchanging - and accurate! Just seeing the historical events planned out well in advance of the Bible's writing was nothing short of astounding! (The whole Nebuchadnezzar statue... read the book of Daniel as well as the book of Revealation which is closely related in this case.)
I know my Bible fairly well, but I'm no expert. I have to get in the habit of studying more regularly... easier to do if I wasted less time with computer games. :frown:
In fact, I have a prayer request for me to get over my darn-near-addiction to computer games. I haven't written a new song in almost 3 years now, though I have PLENTY of time to waste with strategy games....
Anyways, I'll be happy to assist where I can, and happy to contribute - even at the risk (as usual) of condemnation by other Ananders. Heck, with some of the stuff I've said elsewhere, at least two "political-religious" groups have probably got me marked for death.![]()
If you don't want Christianity discussed on this thread then why do you post responses that beget discussion?
Originally posted by: QTArrhythmic
Q]
And if you want to call me ignorant, that's fine, everyone is ignorant about some aspect of life. In constrast, I pursue the truth whereas you seem to be okay with being bent over, all lubed up, with your head in the sand.
Have a nice day.
Originally posted by: bluemaxAin't that lovely folks?![]()
Remember, the same kind of skepticism should hold for SCIENCE findings as well!
Sad to say, though, that there are MANY (the vast majority) that will blindly accept whatever they are told - especially if it sounds plausible or just from enough mouths to make them think it's "common knowledge" that "everybody knows".
Evolution makes a good example here. Darwin himself was revolted by how his simple theory of a species adapting to its environment was taken from him and turned into "there is no God, only monkey-man!"
Scientists would have you believe that evolution is a proven fact, yet they still search for "the missing link".
That missing link is the entire chain from monkey to modern man... NOTHING exists by way of evidence.
Plenty has been falsified though... entire skeletons have been man-made around a tiny fragment of skull cap in one case, a single tooth in another (later proven to be a common pig's tooth), another, simply an five-foot-something old man with terrible arthritis.
But hey, it's common knowledge that we evolved from monkey-thinkgs, right? Right?
whether or not you will spend eternity with God (not floating on clouds... more "common knowlege" (aka ignorance) this time on the part of many people, Christian and non.) or be with the condemned who will be extinguished by fire. (Not suffering for eternity like "common knowledge" and album covers would have you believe.) Hey, eternal life in Hell would still be "eternal life" wouldn't it? Let's face it... most people out there DON'T THINK. That's why TV is such a hit.![]()
Originally posted by: Metalloid15
Valsalva, please PM bluemax and speak to him, so that it doesn't take up thread space.
Thank you.
Originally posted by: ValsalvaYourHeartOut
Originally posted by: Metalloid15
Valsalva, please PM bluemax and speak to him, so that it doesn't take up thread space.
Thank you.
I notice that you did not ask bluemax and other "Christians" to take their comments to PM, only me and QT. I think that is terribly inconsistent of you to ask only people who disagree with aspects of Christianity to be silent, which only further exemplifies how close-minded certain Christians can be. Most of you talk about your "Christian walk" and describe how you've continually challenged your beliefs and in the process, further convinced yourself of the truth. In reality, you've only pressed your palms tightly to your dainty ears whenever anyone brings up points that clearly invalidate your system of beliefs and never gave these counterarguments an ounce of consideration. Regardless, Bluemax and others in this thread have made remarks that I find objectionable, and I am merely responding to them. Just because you started this thread does NOT give you the right to censor responses -- this is Anandtech, not Metalloidotech...
Valsalva
