Why do people want the game to fail so much?
Man I hate looking at the IW forum. It's full of spoiled whiners telling people to pirate, thinking cheating is funny, wanting IW to go out of business. Unreal.
Because to many this game represents a singular danger to PC gaming as we have known it. Should this game succeed, this is the future of PC gaming - cheapo console ports limited to those commands implementable on consoles, small levels, no customization abilities, no dedicated servers, and no content not generated by the developer and paid for by the gamer, all for the same high price as the console versions but without the resale ability. That this is coming from a developer whose company was built on PC gamers' dollars makes it that much worse, it's like a betrayal.
I agree with Malak though, writing reviews slamming a game you haven't played is bogus. I'm not buying it, but I'm not reviewing it either, or saying it's not a fun game. (Personally I'm not playing a shooter without leaning, but others may enjoy it tremendously and appreciate the simplification of the controls.) And I'm certainly not advocating that people steal it. That's just wrong. Either buy it or don't buy it, tell people why you think they should or should not buy it, but none of us is entitled to it for free.