I really wanted to like this game, but it just isn't doing it for me. It seriously is like Guiild Wars with a monthly fee tacked on. The funny thing is I didn't mind Tortage that much (although it's not something I'd like to go through again with an alt. character). The places after Tortage are a lot worse IMO. It really started to feel like a single player game, going long stretches without seeing a single person. The fact there's a ton of instancing in this game doesn't help in that regard. Quests after Tortage have gone completely downhill. Generic, travel across the map quests, gather X, slaughter Y. It's a poor rehash of WoW's system.
The combat seems like a breath of fresh air at first, but then just grows tedious after the first few levels. I can only imagine the kind've pain your fingers will feel after an epic boss encounter. I can't comment on PVP since I'm only level 27, but it doesn't sound like there's a whole lot of reward in that regard.
Even on the official AOC boards, it seems like a lot of people feel this way. I haven't seen this much negative reaction for a new MMORPG in a long, long time. I feel like I wasted 50 bucks, pisses me off..