Originally posted by: EvilComputer92
Originally posted by: jbourne77
Originally posted by: Fenixgoon
^^ UT99 is easily the best in the UT series still.
... because ... ?
It was the only game in the series that did everything right. It had none of the floatyness and weapon nerfing of UT2004 and still has the best UI of any UT game. It's mod community is practically unparalleled to this day. At it's height it was one of the most played online games.
UT3 really did have great gameplay, it's just that everything surrounding the main game made it feel like a rushed console port.
Also I don't think arena shooters are dead just yet. COD4 is pretty much an arena shooter with a modern warfare coating and it has a large player base.
I agree with most of what you said, but you didn't say much substantive regarding
why UT99 it was popular. Stating that it "did everything right" and was "one of the most played games" is accurate, but non-definitive. I believe it was popular because it represented innovation on numerous levels; it was earth-shattering progress in terms of gaming. Duplicating that kind of progress today is much more difficult; but of course, the UT series has never aimed to redefine anything since UT99, anyway.
I agree that the interface around UT3 sucks and is very consolish, but I have a hard time buying into that as a reason for its failure. People buy games to play the games, not to tool around in the menus. UWindows would rock, but if people really just want an OS to play with, download Linux.
As for UT2k4, you hit the nail on the head for me. I actually didn't like UT2k3 or UT2k4 very much, though I did author a number of mods (ProZoomInstagib and UAdminMod). Modding was the only reason I hung around. The floatiness was awful, and they've fixed UT3 in that regard. This is one reason why UT3 is very UT99-like, so we're left wondering if UT3 is so panned because of its interface or, perhaps, a less obvious reason.
COD4 is certainly an arena shooter; no argument there... but it innovated the hell out the genre, whereas UT3 is a candied-up UT99. Granted, most people (thought they) wanted a candied up UT99, but deep down, their expectations are higher these days and nostalgia is, as I said before, clouding their judgment. Let's also not forget that fantasy-style shooters aren't nearly as popular these days as military shooters.
If you take the interface out of the picture, there's really nothing to complain about with regard to UT3. The gameplay is rock solid and the maps are great. Yet it's still unpopular. I contend it's simply a sign of the times.