How can you not buy a macbook?

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

speg

Diamond Member
Apr 30, 2000
3,681
3
76
www.speg.com
Originally posted by: KeypoX
Its window management sucks. But is very pretty.

It is inferior because the way you can window manage is horrible. Also in linux you can use scale (Scale = > version of expose). Thats just one example... many more that have to deal with customization and other aspects.

I like to play with osx, but its the worse of the 3. Both in security (fact based on security reports) and usability (more opinion based, but the facts back it up, IE: Window management).

Expose, spaces, app switcher, what more do you want? Do you have any links to these security reports? I feel a hundred times safer on my Macbook than I do on my Windows box. Same goes for usability.

 

Demo24

Diamond Member
Aug 5, 2004
8,356
9
81
Just don't take one apart. I'm in the process of attempting to fix a friends screen on their macbook, and boy is it hell to take the damn thing apart. It's no wonder they cost so much when they have all these damn specialty screws all over the place. I feel for the people making them.

Also the first computer I've need online picture instructions to tell me how to disassemble it. I wonder if Apple designs their products to be as difficult as possible to repair. :disgust:
 

iGas

Diamond Member
Feb 7, 2009
6,240
1
0
Originally posted by: PottedMeat
Originally posted by: dbk
Originally posted by: iGas
My sister thought that she is being smart by talked her 15 year old son into buying a macbook for $1400 CAD. Tax and other software bring the macbook to just under $2K (poor kid was coned out of his hard earned money from working at Wendy's).

Being a mean uncle that I'm, I put the kid & his snotty mom in their place by showed them that I can do what ever his Mac could on a more powerful Linux laptop for less than $500 CAD.

tell them to return that shit or resell it.. at least the macs retain their value :p

Would you rather have her spend the $2k and have the kid crawling to apple for help or she can save $1500 and have the kid come to you for help?
She didn't spend $2k. It is the kid money that he earned at his summer & weekend job.

And, I would gladly help the kid out if he asked.....heck I would have purchase a laptop with Linux and give it to the kid if he asked me.

 

iGas

Diamond Member
Feb 7, 2009
6,240
1
0
Originally posted by: KeypoX
Originally posted by: halik
Originally posted by: KeypoX
Originally posted by: uclaLabrat
Yeah, I think it's fairly well explained. Macs are nice, sure, if you don't mind paying 60-100% more than you need to for the same amount of computing power. Then again, if you buy your PC's based on the fact that they're "thin and shiny/sleek" then you have other problems....but if it works for you, then by all means, go ahead.

lol... "I ll buy anything shinny and made by apple "

Eh honda civic will get you from A to B too, but people still buy Porsches...

Just like with everything in life, good industrial design, UI and materials go for premium money.

Indeed but Porsches still give you advantages. While a mac creates disadvantages, in most cases.

And of course porsches dont have the same insides as hondas. Unlike macs which have same insides as dells, hps, etc.
IMHO, Porsches might get you laid more often than Macbook.
 

jman19

Lifer
Nov 3, 2000
11,225
664
126
Originally posted by: DeviousTrap
Originally posted by: DrPizza
Gee, I've gotta agree with the OP here. When you compare a $1000 macbook to a $400 laptop, the macbook wins hands down.

Now compare your $1,00 macbook to this $900 Dell. And yes I know that this one doesn't have the webcam so it doesn't match spec-for-spec, but there are tons of other configs available.

WHOOSH
 

TridenT

Lifer
Sep 4, 2006
16,800
45
91
Originally posted by: child of wonder
A friend of mine made the switch to Mac. Bought a Mac Air, 24" Mac PC thing, etc.

We're not friends anymore.

Because he won the lottery and he decided to have cooler friends?

Originally posted by: reallyscrued
Wow.

Lots of sarcasm meter calibration needed in this thread.

Indeed.

Originally posted by: DrPizza
Gee, I've gotta agree with the OP here. When you compare a $1000 macbook to a $400 laptop, the macbook wins hands down.

Originally posted by: FleshLight
Originally posted by: MagnusTheBrewer
Originally posted by: Martin
I'm been looking for a laptop, so I went to Best Buy tonight. They had a shitload of regular laptops and all of them paled in comparison to the macbooks. Since all laptops have more or less the same innards, the fit, finish and packaging is what really set them apart. The windows laptops ranged from OK to gaudy, ugly and tacky and not a single one of them was as thin as the macbook. I'm typing this on a 5 year old T42 - its in a nice slim 1" package, why the hell is Apple seemingly the only one making thin laptops?

Anyway, if I can't find one on craigslist and save a few bucks, I'll probably go pick up the 13" macbook tomorrow.

ORLY

Everybody knows this.

Originally posted by: halik
Originally posted by: KeypoX
Originally posted by: uclaLabrat
Yeah, I think it's fairly well explained. Macs are nice, sure, if you don't mind paying 60-100% more than you need to for the same amount of computing power. Then again, if you buy your PC's based on the fact that they're "thin and shiny/sleek" then you have other problems....but if it works for you, then by all means, go ahead.

lol... "I ll buy anything shinny and made by apple "

Eh honda civic will get you from A to B too, but people still buy Porsches...

Just like with everything in life, good industrial design, UI and materials go for premium money.

People who buy Porsches have ass loads of money... They also are usually getting a car with far better performance than your typical.

Originally posted by: KeypoX
Originally posted by: halik
Originally posted by: KeypoX
Originally posted by: uclaLabrat
Yeah, I think it's fairly well explained. Macs are nice, sure, if you don't mind paying 60-100% more than you need to for the same amount of computing power. Then again, if you buy your PC's based on the fact that they're "thin and shiny/sleek" then you have other problems....but if it works for you, then by all means, go ahead.

lol... "I ll buy anything shinny and made by apple "

Eh honda civic will get you from A to B too, but people still buy Porsches...

Just like with everything in life, good industrial design, UI and materials go for premium money.

Indeed but Porsches still give you advantages. While a mac creates disadvantages, in most cases.

And of course porsches dont have the same insides as hondas. Unlike macs which have same insides as dells, hps, etc.

Boo-yah!
 

DaveSimmons

Elite Member
Aug 12, 2001
40,730
670
126
> How can you not buy a macbook?

Because you can get a decent non-Apple laptop AND a PS3 Slim AND an Xbox 360 Elite for the same price?

Of course Mac owners don't know anything about gaming so that won't matter to them ;)
 

ProfJohn

Lifer
Jul 28, 2006
18,161
7
0
I love my MacBook

Great lap top for when I travel, otherwise it sits on the desk and collects dust.
 

Crono

Lifer
Aug 8, 2001
23,720
1,502
136
Originally posted by: ProfJohn
I love my MacBook

Great lap top for when I travel, otherwise it sits on the desk and collects dust.

I would gladly take that dust collector off your hands for free :p
 

iGas

Diamond Member
Feb 7, 2009
6,240
1
0
Originally posted by: DaveSimmons
> How can you not buy a macbook?

Because you can get a decent non-Apple laptop AND a PS3 Slim AND an Xbox 360 Elite for the same price?

Of course Mac owners don't know anything about gaming so that won't matter to them ;)
Or, a PS3 ++ 42"-46" LCD and still have money left over to buy games.
 

halik

Lifer
Oct 10, 2000
25,696
1
81
Originally posted by: KeypoX
Originally posted by: halik
Originally posted by: speg
Originally posted by: Jumpem
They are ridiculously overpriced, and run an inferior OS.

OS X is inferior? But I've got the box right here, says it's the worlds most advanced!

I'd like to hear the explanation how OSX is inferior... It's far the most productive flavor of Unix I've tried. And that includes the SGI Fuel that's sitting right next to my hackintosh.

Its window management sucks. But is very pretty.

It is inferior because the way you can window manage is horrible. Also in linux you can use scale (Scale = > version of expose). Thats just one example... many more that have to deal with customization and other aspects.

I like to play with osx, but its the worse of the 3. Both in security (fact based on security reports) and usability (more opinion based, but the facts back it up, IE: Window management).

Security-wise yes, but not in the UI aspect. Apple spends a lot of money on UI research and most of their things eventually trickle down to other OSs (dragging files over folders opens the folders, dragging files into terminal writes out the file path, expose etc.). The only thing that was missing up to 10.3 was spaces/virtual desktop.
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
Reasons one might not buy a Macbook:
1. Doesn't come with Windows. How much is a retail non-upgrade version of Windows? $200?
2. Macbooks are expensive, and many people don't need the build quality of a Macbook.

My $400 Compaq laptop has served me well and has done everything I need it to do for 2 years. I did let my company buy me a Macbook as my work computer though. I'm not going to complain if someone else wants to spend $1500 on a laptop.
 

Bateluer

Lifer
Jun 23, 2001
27,730
8
0
Apple definitely has some sleek designs, but its not worth the price premium. Looking at a Macbook Pro 15in right now. The cost to upgrade from 4GB of RAM to 8GB(2x4GB) of RAM is 1000 dollars. A single stick of 4GB SO-DDR3 at Newegg right now is under 300. To upgrade from a 320GB 5400rpm hard drive to a 500GB 7200rpm hard drive is 150 dollars, compared to 90 dollars at Newegg. Adding a 24in LCD is 900 dollars, compared to 180 for a cheaper Acer with the same specs or 300 for a nicely spec'd Dell Ultrasharp. All the software they charge 200 to 400 dollars for can be found at Sourceforge for no cost or on the retail shelves for under 100.

A 15in Macbook Pro with the 2.66Ghz C2D, 8GB of RAM, 500GB 7200RPM hard drive, 24in Apple Cinema display, with no extra software or additional warranty comes in at 4,048. A Sager NP8662 system configured at PC Torque with a 3.06Ghz C2D(T9900), 8GB of DDR3, a GF 260M GTX with 1GB of VRAM, 500GB 7200 RPM hard drive, Zero Dead Pixel policy, BluRay Burner, Vista Ultimate 64, Office 2007 Professional, 3yr Labor/1yr parts, and 1yr accidental damage protection plan all comes out to around 3,808. 3,693 if you pay cash. Through in a high end 24in display and you're still under the price of the Macbook with a substantially more powerful system. The 4 thousand dollar Macbook comes equipped with an nvidia 9400M IGP, for crying out load.
 

halik

Lifer
Oct 10, 2000
25,696
1
81
One more thing I gotta add is that Apple stuff doesn't depreciate anywhere near as fast as plain vanilla PCs. I bought a dual 1Ghz G5 powermac back in 2006 for $800 and sold it for $750 earlier this year.

 

Leros

Lifer
Jul 11, 2004
21,867
7
81
I love the Macbook hardware. I love the fact that OSX is Unix based. I do not want to use OSX.

Take the latest Windows, make it Unix-based, put it on Macbook hardware and I might consider buying it.
 

Jimmah

Golden Member
Mar 18, 2005
1,243
2
0
If I didn't get all my laptops for free I would hop all over getting a Macbook. Well, if I could afford one. Well designed, simple and efficient.
 

mafia

Golden Member
Jul 10, 2008
1,671
3
76
Originally posted by: halik
Originally posted by: KeypoX
Originally posted by: uclaLabrat
Yeah, I think it's fairly well explained. Macs are nice, sure, if you don't mind paying 60-100% more than you need to for the same amount of computing power. Then again, if you buy your PC's based on the fact that they're "thin and shiny/sleek" then you have other problems....but if it works for you, then by all means, go ahead.

lol... "I ll buy anything shinny and made by apple "

Eh honda civic will get you from A to B too, but people still buy Porsches...

Just like with everything in life, good industrial design, UI and materials go for premium money.

Please don't compare Macs to Porsches! And PCs to Civics. Come on? I think its the other way around. Buying a Mac is like buying a Honda Civic for the price of a Carrera GT. On the other hand, buying a PC is like buying a Honda Civic, but getting a Porsche in return. Way more powerful, play lots more games, and at the forefront of CPU and Graphic Card tech.
 

zerogear

Diamond Member
Jun 4, 2000
5,611
9
81
Originally posted by: xSauronx
id take a thinkpad over a macbook any day of the week. you couldnt pay me to use an apple product, and if you gave me a mac, id have linux on it before the afternoon was over.
Originally posted by: dud
I owned a Macbook ... and sold the Macbook.

I found more usefulness in my current Asus netbook.

You've fallen for the marketing. Run away ...



QFT.
 

mafia

Golden Member
Jul 10, 2008
1,671
3
76
Originally posted by: Martin
I'm been looking for a laptop, so I went to Best Buy tonight. They had a shitload of regular laptops and all of them paled in comparison to the macbooks. Since all laptops have more or less the same innards, the fit, finish and packaging is what really set them apart. The windows laptops ranged from OK to gaudy, ugly and tacky and not a single one of them was as thin as the macbook. I'm typing this on a 5 year old T42 - its in a nice slim 1" package, why the hell is Apple seemingly the only one making thin laptops?


If you really want a good sleek looking labtop thats not overpriced and doesn't have a monopolised market, then try Sony Vaio. Much better power to money ratio than a stupid Macbook :p
 

halik

Lifer
Oct 10, 2000
25,696
1
81
Originally posted by: mafia
Originally posted by: halik
Originally posted by: KeypoX
Originally posted by: uclaLabrat
Yeah, I think it's fairly well explained. Macs are nice, sure, if you don't mind paying 60-100% more than you need to for the same amount of computing power. Then again, if you buy your PC's based on the fact that they're "thin and shiny/sleek" then you have other problems....but if it works for you, then by all means, go ahead.

lol... "I ll buy anything shinny and made by apple "

Eh honda civic will get you from A to B too, but people still buy Porsches...

Just like with everything in life, good industrial design, UI and materials go for premium money.

Please don't compare Macs to Porsches! And PCs to Civics. Come on? I think its the other way around. Buying a Mac is like buying a Honda Civic for the price of a Carrera GT. On the other hand, buying a PC is like buying a Honda Civic, but getting a Porsche in return. Way more powerful, play lots more games, and at the forefront of CPU and Graphic Card tech.

Uhhh that argument doesn't work - macs are obviously considered premium goods compared to say dell laptops given the cost alone. Same thing goes for the construction (aluminum frame, skin vs plastic).

People pay more for premium stuff, it's as simple as that. Ford sells the same car as both lincoln and ford, lexus does the same thing with the ES.
 

mafia

Golden Member
Jul 10, 2008
1,671
3
76
Originally posted by: halik
Originally posted by: mafia
Originally posted by: halik
Originally posted by: KeypoX
Originally posted by: uclaLabrat
Yeah, I think it's fairly well explained. Macs are nice, sure, if you don't mind paying 60-100% more than you need to for the same amount of computing power. Then again, if you buy your PC's based on the fact that they're "thin and shiny/sleek" then you have other problems....but if it works for you, then by all means, go ahead.

lol... "I ll buy anything shinny and made by apple "

Eh honda civic will get you from A to B too, but people still buy Porsches...

Just like with everything in life, good industrial design, UI and materials go for premium money.

Please don't compare Macs to Porsches! And PCs to Civics. Come on? I think its the other way around. Buying a Mac is like buying a Honda Civic for the price of a Carrera GT. On the other hand, buying a PC is like buying a Honda Civic, but getting a Porsche in return. Way more powerful, play lots more games, and at the forefront of CPU and Graphic Card tech.

Uhhh that argument doesn't work - macs are obviously considered premium goods compared to say dell laptops given the cost alone. Same thing goes for the construction (aluminum frame, skin vs plastic).

People pay more for premium stuff, it's as simple as that. Ford sells the same car as both lincoln and ford, lexus does the same thing with the ES.


But Porsches are fast. How often do you see a Mac playing Crysis? Premium has to be at the forefront of technology. People don't just buy a Mercedes S class because its made out of better materials. They buy it because it has a more powerful engine (CPU), newer technologies, etc..


 

lxskllr

No Lifer
Nov 30, 2004
60,206
10,663
126
Originally posted by: xSauronx
Originally posted by: speg
Originally posted by: xSauronx
id take a thinkpad over a macbook any day of the week. you couldnt pay me to use an apple product, and if you gave me a mac, id have linux on it before the afternoon was over.

Why so much hate? :(

the lack of freedom and the way apple deals with customers and such bothers me. OS X is meh, as far as im concerned (my brothers imac has given me no shortage of headache) and their products are pretty much overpriced. i just have absolutely zero desire to own anything made by apple.

i dont like microsoft, but i definitely have windows on a couple of things. i wouldnt even run OS X in a vm.

That's exactly how I feel, except I do like Microsoft. I'd take Linux every day of the week in preference to OSX.
 

halik

Lifer
Oct 10, 2000
25,696
1
81
Originally posted by: mafia
Originally posted by: halik
Originally posted by: mafia
Originally posted by: halik
Originally posted by: KeypoX
Originally posted by: uclaLabrat
Yeah, I think it's fairly well explained. Macs are nice, sure, if you don't mind paying 60-100% more than you need to for the same amount of computing power. Then again, if you buy your PC's based on the fact that they're "thin and shiny/sleek" then you have other problems....but if it works for you, then by all means, go ahead.

lol... "I ll buy anything shinny and made by apple "

Eh honda civic will get you from A to B too, but people still buy Porsches...

Just like with everything in life, good industrial design, UI and materials go for premium money.

Please don't compare Macs to Porsches! And PCs to Civics. Come on? I think its the other way around. Buying a Mac is like buying a Honda Civic for the price of a Carrera GT. On the other hand, buying a PC is like buying a Honda Civic, but getting a Porsche in return. Way more powerful, play lots more games, and at the forefront of CPU and Graphic Card tech.

Uhhh that argument doesn't work - macs are obviously considered premium goods compared to say dell laptops given the cost alone. Same thing goes for the construction (aluminum frame, skin vs plastic).

People pay more for premium stuff, it's as simple as that. Ford sells the same car as both lincoln and ford, lexus does the same thing with the ES.


But Porsches are fast. How often do you see a Mac playing Crysis?

WTF is crysis?