Hawaii Superferry

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Jun 27, 2005
19,216
1
61
Originally posted by: Chaotic42
Originally posted by: DasFox
1. What comes to mind when you think about Hawaii?
Tan women and beautiful natural scenery

2. If you took a vacation to Hawaii, what are you thinking about?
Tan women and beautiful natural scenery

3. Why do you think most people live in Hawaii?
Tan women and beautiful natural scenery
4. If Hawaii becomes like anywhere else what will be the point of visiting?
Tan women and beautiful natural scenery

:laugh: :thumbsup:
 

yowolabi

Diamond Member
Jun 29, 2001
4,183
2
81
Originally posted by: jdoggg12
I can see their logic. How many of you know much about hawaii? I have friends and family there. Whoever said they're trying to get more tourists there is dead wrong. The only people trying to get MORE tourists there are the mainland business owners. 95% of all the locals despies the tourists. The way of life there is so much different than the mainland, its really amazing.

If this thing becomes the norm, it will greatly appeal to the island hopping tourists and make the more remote islands more easily accessible. They DONT want that. Hawaii is kinda like a national park- the whole state really... its allure is in nature, the more humans that come the worse off the land will be.

I'm sure they would like to stop any sort of change, but at best they can slightly slow things down. Couching their objections in false environmental concerns just makes them look like liars, and discredits real environmental issues.
 

buck

Lifer
Dec 11, 2000
12,273
4
81
Originally posted by: Whoozyerdaddy
Originally posted by: buck
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: DasFox
Topic Title: Hawaii Superferry
Topic Summary: What A Mess And Uproar It's Making

It's not making a mess.

It's all about the money.

The airlines don't want to lose any of their monopoly.

It will be interesting to see what wins out.

This boat is speeding through where whales migrate, i think that is their biggest beef. These arent just a couple few whales, the place is loaded with them.

Most of the whales stay to the west side of the chain. I moved here last winter. I live a block off the ocean and walk down to it at least twice a day. I never saw a single spout. Go to the west/south side and there are whales everywhere. Everywhere you look you see spouts and breaches.

The ferry runs along the eastern side of the chain. Whales are a convenient excuse.

Like I said, the whole protest movement is hypocritical. The ferry is more for locals than tourists. If they are trying to block progress or more traffic or (insert excuse here) then they should be out there blocking the Young Brothers barges hauling in freight and things from people who are moving here. That is the real source of harm to what they claim to want to protect.

And the airlines have nothing to do with it Dave... Do you think they care about 200 passengers when compared to the 50,000 or so they fly in and out of the island every day? (And that's just Maui) Come on.

For the couple of weeks I was there last time, I spent every day surfing as much as possible and saw whales everyday from just offshore of ma'alea, south of Lahaina, honolua bay, in front of ho'okipa, and even off of Hana. This was in mid Dec.
I am not saying that this is their only excuse, but the fact is that these boats run through the whales migration area. I am not trying to argue with you, especially since you live there, but why do you think most of the locals are against this ferry?

The native hawaiins I know and surfed with all seemed pretty vocal about protecting their waters....
 

DasFox

Diamond Member
Sep 4, 2003
4,668
46
91
Well I personally don't know what the real issues are against the SuperFerry, I personally thought it was more about protecting a way of life, and stopping the big corporates from moving in and developing up more BIG things, hence the SUPER/BIG ferry which has people scared about this BIG thing now invading our slow little islands....

I'm all for having some progress, if it means improving the quality of life to REALLY help people, BUT in all HONESTY, having Costco, Walmart, Kmart, HomeDepot, and all the bigs stores has really done nothing to improve my life. Putting traffic signals in, making the roads wider has also done nothing to improve my life, and when I came to Hawaii over 15 years ago life here was just fine, and I didn't need any more of these supposed improvements in life.

This is what it's really all about, is it really doing anything to make the Hawaiian peoples life better, and we just have to have it to get on with life, and the answer is NO.

Over 50% of the BS built up out here over the past 10 years, the majority will also tell you it does nothing for them.

THINK about it, most everyone wanting to live an island life, just wants a simple island life, and if they don't they have 49 other states to choose from, so why make this place like everyone other rat race? Now that's nutts, and being a hypocrite, because what it's really about is people wanting to come into the islands and seize opportunities for THEIR ---> POCKETS! :(

And guess what, once the mess is made, and the place has gone to a hell hole, and they've made their money, you think they are sticking around in the place that once was paradise? HELL NO, they'll pack up move on, leave the poor island people with all the crap they've created, and look for another place to exploit.

TRUTH IS, IT'S ALL ABOUT PROTECTING A WAY OF LIFE, REMEMBER THAT! ;)

ALOHA
 

dud

Diamond Member
Feb 18, 2001
7,635
73
91
Only in Hawaii.

A VERY similar boat sails from Rochester, NY to Toronto without incident when weather allows. Whats better for the environment ... a large boat moving peeps from Island-to-island or a number of planes spewing crap into the atmosphere to move those same peeps.

BTW ... the planes can't transport those cars.
 

DasFox

Diamond Member
Sep 4, 2003
4,668
46
91
Remember Hawaii is America, it's your place of tourism, those that will never live here, but seek to find that island get away from the rat race of your daily life need to know that Hawaii needs to be protected not only for locals, but tourists, and remember all of Hawaii is directly or indirectly effected by tourism. Kill this industry, and you kill Hawaii!

Don't think it can't happen it can, I've seen island destruction, and the death of tourism on islands of the pacific on a small scale.

Actually this year Maui saw a decline in tourism, FACT!

Tourists who take island vacations want island vacations not cement jungle rat races.

Next time when you are dreaming of the Hawaii island get away, do you want any of the following on your vacation?

1. Road rage?
2. Traffic congestion?
3. Typical city life madness, everyone always to busy in to much a hurry to give anyone any time?
4. Cement everywhere you look, all land cemented over with shops and stores?
5. Do you want to come to Hawaii, to find out you are just in an island California rat race?

ALOHA
 

So

Lifer
Jul 2, 2001
25,923
17
81
Originally posted by: DasFox
Remember Hawaii is America, it's your place of tourism, those that will never live here, but seek to find that island get away from the rat race of your daily life need to know that Hawaii needs to be protected not only for locals, but tourists, and remember all of Hawaii is directly or indirectly effected by tourism. Kill this industry, and you kill Hawaii!

Don't think it can't happen it can, I've seen island destruction, and the death of tourism on islands of the pacific on a small scale.

Actually this year Maui saw a decline in tourism, FACT!

Tourists who take island vacations want island vacations not cement jungle rat races.

Next time when you are dreaming of the Hawaii island get away, do you want any of the following on your vacation?

1. Road rage?
2. Traffic congestion?
3. Typical city life madness, everyone always to busy in to much a hurry to give anyone any time?
4. Cement everywhere you look, all land cemented over with shops and stores?
5. Do you want to come to Hawaii, to find out you are just in an island California rat race?

ALOHA

You seem to be big on tourism, but against tourists coming...you can't have it both ways buddy.
 

K1052

Elite Member
Aug 21, 2003
52,615
46,281
136
The ferry is less than 350 feet long, has no props, and doesn't use ballast tanks. Not exactly the RMS Titanic. :roll:

If you have a port of any size at all I can guarantee it sees ships a lot larger than this on a regular basis.
 

Rubycon

Madame President
Aug 10, 2005
17,768
485
126
Originally posted by: DasFox

1. Road rage?
2. Traffic congestion?
3. Typical city life madness, everyone always to busy in to much a hurry to give anyone any time?
4. Cement everywhere you look, all land cemented over with shops and stores?
5. Do you want to come to Hawaii, to find out you are just in an island California rat race?

ALOHA

You've described many of the islands in the Caribbean. When there's more than 6 ships in St Maarten, it's considered a port of crawl. St Thomas is far worse and the attitude of the locals towards the visitors shows this. :(

Lots of rice (the cars with airplane wings and muddy bass sound) abound as well.

 

dmcowen674

No Lifer
Oct 13, 1999
54,889
47
91
www.alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: Whoozyerdaddy
Originally posted by: buck
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: DasFox
Topic Title: Hawaii Superferry
Topic Summary: What A Mess And Uproar It's Making

It's not making a mess.

It's all about the money.

The airlines don't want to lose any of their monopoly.

It will be interesting to see what wins out.

This boat is speeding through where whales migrate, i think that is their biggest beef. These arent just a couple few whales, the place is loaded with them.

Most of the whales stay to the west side of the chain. I moved here last winter. I live a block off the ocean and walk down to it at least twice a day. I never saw a single spout. Go to the west/south side and there are whales everywhere. Everywhere you look you see spouts and breaches.

The ferry runs along the eastern side of the chain. Whales are a convenient excuse.

Like I said, the whole protest movement is hypocritical. The ferry is more for locals than tourists. If they are trying to block progress or more traffic or (insert excuse here) then they should be out there blocking the Young Brothers barges hauling in freight and things from people who are moving here. That is the real source of harm to what they claim to want to protect.

And the airlines have nothing to do with it Dave...

Do you think they care about 200 passengers when compared to the 50,000 or so they fly in and out of the island every day? (And that's just Maui) Come on.

You didn't give a reason. Come on, what is it?
 

Rubycon

Madame President
Aug 10, 2005
17,768
485
126
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: Whoozyerdaddy
Originally posted by: buck
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: DasFox
Topic Title: Hawaii Superferry
Topic Summary: What A Mess And Uproar It's Making

It's not making a mess.

It's all about the money.

The airlines don't want to lose any of their monopoly.

It will be interesting to see what wins out.

This boat is speeding through where whales migrate, i think that is their biggest beef. These arent just a couple few whales, the place is loaded with them.

Most of the whales stay to the west side of the chain. I moved here last winter. I live a block off the ocean and walk down to it at least twice a day. I never saw a single spout. Go to the west/south side and there are whales everywhere. Everywhere you look you see spouts and breaches.

The ferry runs along the eastern side of the chain. Whales are a convenient excuse.

Like I said, the whole protest movement is hypocritical. The ferry is more for locals than tourists. If they are trying to block progress or more traffic or (insert excuse here) then they should be out there blocking the Young Brothers barges hauling in freight and things from people who are moving here. That is the real source of harm to what they claim to want to protect.

And the airlines have nothing to do with it Dave...

Do you think they care about 200 passengers when compared to the 50,000 or so they fly in and out of the island every day? (And that's just Maui) Come on.

You didn't give a reason. Come on, what is it?

What are the odds of a plane crashing into the sea - on top of a whale? ;)
 

foghorn67

Lifer
Jan 3, 2006
11,883
63
91
Originally posted by: DasFox
Remember Hawaii is America, it's your place of tourism, those that will never live here, but seek to find that island get away from the rat race of your daily life need to know that Hawaii needs to be protected not only for locals, but tourists, and remember all of Hawaii is directly or indirectly effected by tourism. Kill this industry, and you kill Hawaii!

Don't think it can't happen it can, I've seen island destruction, and the death of tourism on islands of the pacific on a small scale.

Actually this year Maui saw a decline in tourism, FACT!

Tourists who take island vacations want island vacations not cement jungle rat races.

Next time when you are dreaming of the Hawaii island get away, do you want any of the following on your vacation?

1. Road rage?
2. Traffic congestion?
3. Typical city life madness, everyone always to busy in to much a hurry to give anyone any time?
4. Cement everywhere you look, all land cemented over with shops and stores?
5. Do you want to come to Hawaii, to find out you are just in an island California rat race?

ALOHA

that is really up to HI itself to dictate.
The ferries don't build freeways. Nor do they build new buildings, stores, shops, hotels, etc.
You are aiming at the wrong target.
And yeah, like said above, you can't have it both ways.
 

DasFox

Diamond Member
Sep 4, 2003
4,668
46
91
Originally posted by: So
Originally posted by: DasFox
Remember Hawaii is America, it's your place of tourism, those that will never live here, but seek to find that island get away from the rat race of your daily life need to know that Hawaii needs to be protected not only for locals, but tourists, and remember all of Hawaii is directly or indirectly effected by tourism. Kill this industry, and you kill Hawaii!

Don't think it can't happen it can, I've seen island destruction, and the death of tourism on islands of the pacific on a small scale.

Actually this year Maui saw a decline in tourism, FACT!

Tourists who take island vacations want island vacations not cement jungle rat races.

Next time when you are dreaming of the Hawaii island get away, do you want any of the following on your vacation?

1. Road rage?
2. Traffic congestion?
3. Typical city life madness, everyone always to busy in to much a hurry to give anyone any time?
4. Cement everywhere you look, all land cemented over with shops and stores?
5. Do you want to come to Hawaii, to find out you are just in an island California rat race?

ALOHA

You seem to be big on tourism, but against tourists coming...you can't have it both ways buddy.

I never said anything against tourists coming to Hawaii ever, please don't make false statements. I said I'm for tourism, and protecting it.

Keep the facts straight please! ;)

You can't build Hawaii into the next California, and then expect tourists to flock here thinking it's something special when it's not.
 

K1052

Elite Member
Aug 21, 2003
52,615
46,281
136
Originally posted by: Rubycon
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: Whoozyerdaddy
Originally posted by: buck
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: DasFox
Topic Title: Hawaii Superferry
Topic Summary: What A Mess And Uproar It's Making

It's not making a mess.

It's all about the money.

The airlines don't want to lose any of their monopoly.

It will be interesting to see what wins out.

This boat is speeding through where whales migrate, i think that is their biggest beef. These arent just a couple few whales, the place is loaded with them.

Most of the whales stay to the west side of the chain. I moved here last winter. I live a block off the ocean and walk down to it at least twice a day. I never saw a single spout. Go to the west/south side and there are whales everywhere. Everywhere you look you see spouts and breaches.

The ferry runs along the eastern side of the chain. Whales are a convenient excuse.

Like I said, the whole protest movement is hypocritical. The ferry is more for locals than tourists. If they are trying to block progress or more traffic or (insert excuse here) then they should be out there blocking the Young Brothers barges hauling in freight and things from people who are moving here. That is the real source of harm to what they claim to want to protect.

And the airlines have nothing to do with it Dave...

Do you think they care about 200 passengers when compared to the 50,000 or so they fly in and out of the island every day? (And that's just Maui) Come on.

You didn't give a reason. Come on, what is it?

What are the odds of a plane crashing into the sea - on top of a whale? ;)

Probably less than the odds of your inter-island flight suddenly getting a sunroof...
 

DasFox

Diamond Member
Sep 4, 2003
4,668
46
91
Originally posted by: foghorn67
Originally posted by: DasFox
Remember Hawaii is America, it's your place of tourism, those that will never live here, but seek to find that island get away from the rat race of your daily life need to know that Hawaii needs to be protected not only for locals, but tourists, and remember all of Hawaii is directly or indirectly effected by tourism. Kill this industry, and you kill Hawaii!

Don't think it can't happen it can, I've seen island destruction, and the death of tourism on islands of the pacific on a small scale.

Actually this year Maui saw a decline in tourism, FACT!

Tourists who take island vacations want island vacations not cement jungle rat races.

Next time when you are dreaming of the Hawaii island get away, do you want any of the following on your vacation?

1. Road rage?
2. Traffic congestion?
3. Typical city life madness, everyone always to busy in to much a hurry to give anyone any time?
4. Cement everywhere you look, all land cemented over with shops and stores?
5. Do you want to come to Hawaii, to find out you are just in an island California rat race?

ALOHA

that is really up to HI itself to dictate.
The ferries don't build freeways. Nor do they build new buildings, stores, shops, hotels, etc.
You are aiming at the wrong target.
And yeah, like said above, you can't have it both ways.

No it's not the wrong target, let one come, then they all want to come.

What I'm talking about here is big business, when they see one having at, they want in on the action too, etc. etc.

Let one build, and develop, then another wants at it, and so on...
 

So

Lifer
Jul 2, 2001
25,923
17
81
Originally posted by: DasFox
Originally posted by: So
Originally posted by: DasFox
Remember Hawaii is America, it's your place of tourism, those that will never live here, but seek to find that island get away from the rat race of your daily life need to know that Hawaii needs to be protected not only for locals, but tourists, and remember all of Hawaii is directly or indirectly effected by tourism. Kill this industry, and you kill Hawaii!

Don't think it can't happen it can, I've seen island destruction, and the death of tourism on islands of the pacific on a small scale.

Actually this year Maui saw a decline in tourism, FACT!

Tourists who take island vacations want island vacations not cement jungle rat races.

Next time when you are dreaming of the Hawaii island get away, do you want any of the following on your vacation?

1. Road rage?
2. Traffic congestion?
3. Typical city life madness, everyone always to busy in to much a hurry to give anyone any time?
4. Cement everywhere you look, all land cemented over with shops and stores?
5. Do you want to come to Hawaii, to find out you are just in an island California rat race?

ALOHA

You seem to be big on tourism, but against tourists coming...you can't have it both ways buddy.

I never said anything against tourists coming to Hawaii ever, please don't make false statements. I said I'm for tourism, and protecting it.

Keep the facts straight please! ;)

You can't build Hawaii into the next California, and then expect tourists to flock here thinking it's something special when it's not.

You're for tourism, but against a ferry that will bring tourists. How does that make sesne?
 

DasFox

Diamond Member
Sep 4, 2003
4,668
46
91
Tourists don't arrive in Hawaii on a ferry boat, remember that, and tourists can't take rental cars on the ferry either, this is more about supposedly providing more convenience to the locals, and not many of them see it that way, or something they need.

The SuperFerry isn't about tourism.
 

randay

Lifer
May 30, 2006
11,018
216
106
Originally posted by: DasFox
Originally posted by: So
Originally posted by: DasFox
Remember Hawaii is America, it's your place of tourism, those that will never live here, but seek to find that island get away from the rat race of your daily life need to know that Hawaii needs to be protected not only for locals, but tourists, and remember all of Hawaii is directly or indirectly effected by tourism. Kill this industry, and you kill Hawaii!

Don't think it can't happen it can, I've seen island destruction, and the death of tourism on islands of the pacific on a small scale.

Actually this year Maui saw a decline in tourism, FACT!

Tourists who take island vacations want island vacations not cement jungle rat races.

Next time when you are dreaming of the Hawaii island get away, do you want any of the following on your vacation?

1. Road rage?
2. Traffic congestion?
3. Typical city life madness, everyone always to busy in to much a hurry to give anyone any time?
4. Cement everywhere you look, all land cemented over with shops and stores?
5. Do you want to come to Hawaii, to find out you are just in an island California rat race?

ALOHA

You seem to be big on tourism, but against tourists coming...you can't have it both ways buddy.

I never said anything against tourists coming to Hawaii ever, please don't make false statements. I said I'm for tourism, and protecting it.

Keep the facts straight please! ;)

You can't build Hawaii into the next California, and then expect tourists to flock here thinking it's something special when it's not.


are you hawaiian? where you born in hawaii? Im just wondering what gives you the right to be so upset about these kinds of things. exactly how does an interisland ferry turn kauai or maui into california? to be honest, your whole hawaii-is-being-ruined shpiel irritates the heck outta me.
 

DasFox

Diamond Member
Sep 4, 2003
4,668
46
91
First off randay chill, LOL. :)

NOTICE My winked eye avatar in my last reply. I'm not upset about anything, you are, so relax.

You ask how does this ferry turn us into California, well I never said it did, I said, you can't build Hawaii into the next California, meaning adding the superferry into the Hawaiian way of life is just a natural progression into modernism, it's not the only problem, it's just one of the many being added into the developmental chain...
 

Rubycon

Madame President
Aug 10, 2005
17,768
485
126
That vessel would make a suitable tender for the upcoming F3 ships. Thank goodness I'm not involved in that. (at least not yet)
 

JEDI

Lifer
Sep 25, 2001
29,391
2,738
126
Originally posted by: DasFox
You thought the Hawaii life style was suppose to be small and laid back, so do most people. Now here comes the "Hawaii Superferry", and welcome to what you thought was suppose to be small town Hawaii, look out the Superferry is coming, and it's making a big uproar in Hawaii.


News Topics:

Hawaii Superferry officials suspend service indefinitely after days of protests, setbacks
Protests send Superferry back to port
Photos of the Superferry - WOW this thing is BIG!
Surfers block Hawaii Superferry
Hawaii Superferry Questions need to be answered
Petition Against the Superferry

so why dont they want the superferry?!
 

DasFox

Diamond Member
Sep 4, 2003
4,668
46
91
Originally posted by: JEDI
Originally posted by: DasFox
You thought the Hawaii life style was suppose to be small and laid back, so do most people. Now here comes the "Hawaii Superferry", and welcome to what you thought was suppose to be small town Hawaii, look out the Superferry is coming, and it's making a big uproar in Hawaii.


News Topics:

Hawaii Superferry officials suspend service indefinitely after days of protests, setbacks
Protests send Superferry back to port
Photos of the Superferry - WOW this thing is BIG!
Surfers block Hawaii Superferry
Hawaii Superferry Questions need to be answered
Petition Against the Superferry

so why dont they want the superferry?!

Sorry I thought I made it clear in other replies.

To much growth development, to many BIG things choking on the SMALL island way of life.

To much modernism, moving the islands to fast.

I can't speak for all islands, but I do know Kauai is moving fast, and they're not happy, but on Maui, Maui has shown the greatest amount of growth and development of any Hawaiian island in the last 5 years, in fact the growth has been so overwhelming, certain parts have been the biggest booms in the United States for growth, and 5 years ago my town was the fastest booming town in American and it made nation wide news.

The problem is to much is happening way to fast, and to much development going on, but if this were a big city, or urban lifestyle it would seem normal to you, but when you look at the size of the islands and towns and consider they have been some of the biggest growing in America, well this is really ridiculous, and that is really what this all about, a way of life being pushed to the side, while the industrialized America moves to town.
 

randay

Lifer
May 30, 2006
11,018
216
106
Originally posted by: DasFox
First off randay chill, LOL. :)

NOTICE My winked eye avatar in my last reply. I'm not upset about anything, you are, so relax.

You ask how does this ferry turn us into California, well I never said it did, I said, you can't build Hawaii into the next California, meaning adding the superferry into the Hawaiian way of life is just a natural progression into modernism, it's not the only problem, it's just one of the many being added into the developmental chain...

good job at totally not answering any questions. so what do you want hawaii to be like? grass huts, hunting for pigs with spears, and showering in mountain streams? come on, tell me your life would be better without electricity, cars, or anything else native hawaiians couldnt get off the land. you wouldnt even have a life in hawaii if not for that "modernization" thing you are so against. so what is it really? you just hate people? you dont want people to enjoy hawaii? you want it all to yourself? I really do not understand.