• We should now be fully online following an overnight outage. Apologies for any inconvenience, we do not expect there to be any further issues.

Do you think the Big 3 Automakers are going to fold?

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Skotty

Senior member
Dec 29, 2006
232
0
0
Most cars these days are boring. However, Ford has done an excellent job over the years keeping the Mustang exciting and reasonably fresh. And the current Dodge Charger is of interest as well, though I don't think you can get them with manual transmissions, which is what I would want. I exclude vehicles like the Corvette and Viper because they are in price brackets not reachable by most people. US companies have always been strong with trucks and muscle cars (has there ever been a foreign muscle car?), but in a market where those segments have grown weaker, they really need to improve on the image of their small and mid-range cars.

Many people talk about where the dollars go in foreign vs domestic, but something that rarely gets mentioned is national pride. I like being proud of my country's accomplishments, and in that respect, seeing our domestic auto industry overrun by foreign industry is not a good thing.
 

fisheerman

Senior member
Oct 25, 2006
733
0
0
I believe we are going to see a consolidation in the US of car manufactures just like all the other large industries(ie airlines, retail, etc) have gone thru. Im not sure who will be around or who will not.

i do now that the current state that the american car companies are in isn't going to last.
you will see them ditching pension plans for 401k, limited the union ability to hold companies hostage on wages and especially health care, etc.

if not they will not exist because there is no way for a unionized labor force such as the autos have to compete with non unionized labor companies....period.

i know pro union people don't like to hear that but it is a fact. I personnally think globalization is bad for america but it is happening and there is no way to stop it. Our companies must adapt or risk being put out of business.

I also don't buy the idea that you don't buy foriegn because the profits don't flow back to the US. In a true free market you always buy the best product for the cheapest price.

The economy will work dictate which companies go under and which ones will not..........

-fish
 

tcsenter

Lifer
Sep 7, 2001
18,937
568
126
I just don't know why it is so hard for them to see that their products aren't moving like they used to! Why not emulate what Toyota and Honda are doing?
Because they can't from a competitive pricing standpoint; domestic costs for retirees are too high and they still have significantly higher man-hour/vehicle labor costs.

GM certainly could build it, but not remotely at the same price point. What Toyota and Honda could sell for $25K, GM would have to sell for not less than $30K and likely upwards of $35K. Whose going to pay that much more for the same thing? As with any other consumer good, pricing rules.

Toyota and Honda use state-of-the-art factories that spare no automation or technology, while our unions still are zealously opposed to the loss of ANY manual positions due to technology. They "claim" not to be opposed to technology, but the union fights tooth and nail when the company wants to eliminate the positions that are made obsolete by technology.

So GM might spend $200 million for new automation at one plant and still have to retain or pay the workers whose positions are made obsolete by that automation. Where is the cost savings or advantage? It actually costs them many times more to adopt technology and automation because they can't get rid of the manual positions!

Forget building a better car at a competitive price, we can't build an equal car at a competitive price.
 

Mellman

Diamond Member
Jul 9, 2003
3,083
0
76
IF the big three could get their heads out of their arse when it comes to interior i'd gladly buy one. I'm a huge chevy fan, love to support american companies, but when they give me no options...i can't buy them. I wanted a fun to drive, 20-30k car, with a somewhat nice interior. the mazda 3 fits all those bills with an interior better than even 30-40k chevy's ...and the fact that I got a mazdaspeed 3, something nothing in the big 3 camp can compete with...well, i went mazda :(

I'll buy a vette someday, but their offerings for me as a 20 something male...are nil

-matt
 

Parasitic

Diamond Member
Aug 17, 2002
4,000
2
0
Originally posted by: Mellman
IF the big three could get their heads out of their arse when it comes to interior i'd gladly buy one. I'm a huge chevy fan, love to support american companies, but when they give me no options...i can't buy them. I wanted a fun to drive, 20-30k car, with a somewhat nice interior. the mazda 3 fits all those bills with an interior better than even 30-40k chevy's ...and the fact that I got a mazdaspeed 3, something nothing in the big 3 camp can compete with...well, i went mazda :(

I'll buy a vette someday, but their offerings for me as a 20 something male...are nil

-matt

Mazda has partial Ford investment and control.

And some of you guys make it sound like the Big 3 aren't moving any cars at all.
 

Ktulu

Diamond Member
Dec 16, 2000
4,354
0
0
Originally posted by: Mellman
IF the big three could get their heads out of their arse when it comes to interior i'd gladly buy one. I'm a huge chevy fan, love to support american companies, but when they give me no options...i can't buy them. I wanted a fun to drive, 20-30k car, with a somewhat nice interior. the mazda 3 fits all those bills with an interior better than even 30-40k chevy's ...and the fact that I got a mazdaspeed 3, something nothing in the big 3 camp can compete with...well, i went mazda :(

I'll buy a vette someday, but their offerings for me as a 20 something male...are nil

-matt

If you could get your head out of your arse, then you'd see what kind of interiors GM has been developing and has coming down the product pipeline.

example

Here's how I see GM and Ford:
reliability - check
exterior - check
interior - check
performance - check
price - check
value - buzz ( resale value is still in the sh!tter)

All and all not bad IMHO.
 

b0mbrman

Lifer
Jun 1, 2001
29,470
1
81
Originally posted by: ElFenix
what do you think alan mulally is trying to do?

it's hard when you have a giant millstone around your neck that honda and toyota do not have, however.


there is a very good chance that my next car is a ford.

Exactly. It's for this reason that I almost hope they fold

Current car is a Ford
 

ElFenix

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Mar 20, 2000
102,402
8,574
126
Originally posted by: DLeRium
Originally posted by: Vic
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Well, they fvcked themselves hard by relying almost soley on the profits from their fullsize SUVs and trucks. When fuel prices almost doubled after hurricane Katrina people stopped buying them or took a real hard look at whether or not they really needed a fullsize SUV vs just wanting one.

Yep, which is why Toyota is getting its ass handed to them because half of its model line-up are SUVs and trucks, and it's facing impending disaster because it's just invested billions developing a new full-size truck model.

Oh wait... no, it's not.

And gas prices doubled after Katrina (which made landfall on 8/29/05). Oops, that's not true either. While prices did spike briefly after Katrina, they had already gone in the summer of 03, of 04, and in 05 (beginning in March of that year). Here's a 3 year chart of gas prices in your area showing gas prices climbing well before Katrina Text.

Impending disaster? Camry and Corolla sales went up YET AGAIN in 2006. Lexus sales skyrocketed, especially the IS-series. I think Toyota is doing just fine. It's biggest competitor, Honda saw Accord and Civic sales drop. When you come to light trucks and SUVs, Chevy will still win. Toyota has already pushed its sedans to the limit and the only place to expand is to trucks and SUVs. You can't take down teh leaders in that field without investing a lot in it yourself.

you sure didn't see that sarchasm you just fell into, did you?
 

Colt45

Lifer
Apr 18, 2001
19,720
1
0
Originally posted by: Aimster
why do people still call it the big three?

Dodge/Chrysler are German now

Not for long. It's starting to look like they're going to offload chrysler.
 

mrSHEiK124

Lifer
Mar 6, 2004
11,488
2
0
Originally posted by: Ktulu
Originally posted by: Mellman
IF the big three could get their heads out of their arse when it comes to interior i'd gladly buy one. I'm a huge chevy fan, love to support american companies, but when they give me no options...i can't buy them. I wanted a fun to drive, 20-30k car, with a somewhat nice interior. the mazda 3 fits all those bills with an interior better than even 30-40k chevy's ...and the fact that I got a mazdaspeed 3, something nothing in the big 3 camp can compete with...well, i went mazda :(

I'll buy a vette someday, but their offerings for me as a 20 something male...are nil

-matt

If you could get your head out of your arse, then you'd see what kind of interiors GM has been developing and has coming down the product pipeline.

example

Here's how I see GM and Ford:
reliability - check
exterior - check
interior - check
performance - check
price - check
value - buzz ( resale value is still in the sh!tter)

All and all not bad IMHO.

Most of those steering wheels look nice. The two unbranded ones (1st column, 1st row, and 2nd column, 2nd row) look nasty, and surprisingly, IMO the best looking one, is the Buick wheel. All the gauges in the top row look silly. That dash console looks nice though, complicated, but nice.
 

sandorski

No Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
70,785
6,345
126
GM might survive intact, but will continue to shrink

Ford might just disappear, though some other Auto Corp might buy it and continue to use the name for Marketing purposes

Chrysler, I dunno, it might just disappear or be used(like Ford) for Marketing purposes by someone else. Predict: bought by Chinese Corp

The Big 3 is no more, but will likely continue to be used until at least 1 of them is completely gone.
 

mercanucaribe

Banned
Oct 20, 2004
9,763
1
0
I have a Jeep that I bought used, and I'd buy a new Chrysler or GM product, but not Ford... not knowing what Henry Ford did during WWII.
 

Ktulu

Diamond Member
Dec 16, 2000
4,354
0
0
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Ktulu
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Ktulu


value - buzz ( resale value is still in the sh!tter)

So buy used. Duh :roll:

5 year 100,000 mile warranty, sounds like a win.

So how is that not thrown into the value equation? :confusion;

Because my original post was obviously concerning new vehicles, but if you want to go for used then that really doesn't matter now does it?
 

b0mbrman

Lifer
Jun 1, 2001
29,470
1
81
Originally posted by: Ktulu
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Ktulu
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Ktulu


value - buzz ( resale value is still in the sh!tter)

So buy used. Duh :roll:

5 year 100,000 mile warranty, sounds like a win.

So how is that not thrown into the value equation? :confusion;

Because my original post was obviously concerning new vehicles, but if you want to go for used then that really doesn't matter now does it?

I believe you're mistaken....unless you're denying that a 5-year, 100,000 mile warranty adds value.

I'd say it does
 

BUTCH1

Lifer
Jul 15, 2000
20,433
1,769
126
I drive an 05 Malibu ltz, it's a good daily driver and gets 23cityMPG with a 200HP V6.
domestics have been improving but they have make good products for a long time
before the public forgets the Tempo, celebrity, craptacular cars of past. Remember
Hundia's Accell? classic $hitbox. took them 10 yrs. to recover from that one, now
they are a respected manufacturer. Big 3 are in this stage now...
 

bozack

Diamond Member
Jan 14, 2000
7,913
12
81
Meh, I have only owned domestics, two fords and one Chevy, my parents growing up owned Lincoln and Cadillac, my wife has owned a few foreign, My next car will not be domestic...the build quality just isn't that good...reliability of my current ford is ok, but nothing spectacular.
 

chusteczka

Diamond Member
Apr 12, 2006
3,399
3
71
I have been unable to find a better car for my commuting needs than a new Chevy Cobalt with manual transmission, windows, and locks for $13,500 after taxes.