Cats or Dogs

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,455
19,924
146
Contrary to popular myth, cats can be very attentive and can be trained.

Every cat I have had since childhood has been a lap cat. They have been trained to never get on counters, trash cans or table tops. And trained to scratch no where else but a scratching post. Placement of the post(s) is key. My cats have always come when I call them and are very loving. They never bite or scratch unless provoked.

The key to keeping them from biting and scratching you is to NEVER use your hands to play with them, or punish them. Make your hands an ABSOLUTE no bite and no scratch zone. Use toys to play with them but NEVER your body. When they are kittens it takes a lot of work to teach them that your hand is not a toy, but it is worth it later when they grow up. My cats learned to lick my hands instead of biting them when they don't like how I'm petting or holding them. And I in turn respect their wishes and do not keep provoking them until they bite.

For those with virtually feral cats that are uncontrollable, a long reaching water squirt bottle is your key to keeping them from going places and doing things you don't want them to. And it's perfect for the lazy because you don't have to get up to chase them down.

Cats do not automatically like and trust you. You must befriend them and earn their trust and respect. Once you do, you'll find they are not the animals you thought they were.

Cats are willful and persistent. The only way to earn their respect is to be just as willful and persistent. The only way to earn their trust is to be fair and consistent. If you are unpredictable in how you treat them they will not trust you. If you like freaking your cat out and treating them like a toy, rather than a thinking, feeling being, they will not trust you.

Finally, take as much time to learn to read their tail as you expect them to learn the few key words like "food" and "come." They will respect you when you learn to read their tail. It's how they communicate. And be as responsive to their requests as you expect them to be to yours.

Cats, unlike dogs, require mutual respect and trust. With a cat, you are not a master or leader of the pack, you are a mutual friend and must earn that.

And from what landlord friends tell me, dogs are much more destructive to property than cats.
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,455
19,924
146
Originally posted by: God Mode
dogs will sit by your side during all the good and the bad.

So will a cat who trusts and respects you.

When I am very sick (like I was with meningitis) my cat rarely left my side.
 

Modelworks

Lifer
Feb 22, 2007
16,240
7
76
Originally posted by: evident
i've never had either. my friends had cats and dogs. there were some prick dogs and bitchy cats, but overall i would enjoy either. any chance of buying a puppy and kitten and have them grow up together?

Yes.
There are plenty of cases where dogs and cats get along fine.
We even had a dog that allowed newborn kittens to crawl all over it, pulling on its fur, etc. All he did was lick the kittens.
 

JMapleton

Diamond Member
Nov 19, 2008
4,179
2
81
Dogs are much more fun, cats don't seem very responsive they seem to have low attention spans.

Dogs you can play fetch with them for hours until you're both our of energy and puffing for a breath.
 

Red Squirrel

No Lifer
May 24, 2003
70,785
13,873
126
www.anyf.ca
A cat for me. I love dogs when it's someone else's but I would pick a cat over a dog as a pet. They are easier to care for and are super hilarious. Then again dogs can be funny as well.
 

Leafy

Member
Mar 8, 2008
155
0
0
Originally posted by: Martin
Dog owners are not bothered by the smell, drool and general mess since they are very insecure and the attention and affection of even a lowly creature like a dog fills the giant hole in their souls.

Cat owners OTOH aren't such desperate wretches, so cats are perfectly fine pets for them.

Mothers are not bothered by the smell, drool and general mess since they are very insecure and the attention and affection of even a lowly creature like a baby fills the giant hole in their souls.

Your argument can be turned against any creature requiring care. Fail.
 

mortong

Member
Apr 14, 2006
117
0
76
I like dogs, but why worry about proving that I'm right? It's just what I prefer. I really don't think less of anyone for preferring cats. :p
 

Zebo

Elite Member
Jul 29, 2001
39,398
19
81
Cats are worth shit. We have one but it cant get pheasant out of 6' tall corn fields where no man can tread. Can't flush coveys of Quail. Can't swim in icy cold water and get ducks. Can't tell me when someone is driving up to house a 1/4 mile away. Can't take down a man (but neither can my labs lol but some can like block heads) but if you're looking for a mouse a cats the best thats why he's allowed to live.

I do like my cat though. He brings in a mouse a bird or a snake about every day. Keeps property pest free.
 

Zebo

Elite Member
Jul 29, 2001
39,398
19
81
Cats, unlike dogs, require mutual respect and trust. With a cat, you are not a master or leader of the pack, you are a mutual friend and must earn that.

I;m still working on that with people so I don't need an entirely new species to compound the difficulty.
 

coldmeat

Diamond Member
Jul 10, 2007
9,234
142
106
If your dog is ruining your house, it obviously isn't housebroken or you are just a bad owner.

And as far as slobbering goes, I've only seen a few dogs that slobber and they were either mastiffs or special cases.