Liked the second half of the movie WAY better than the first, which was a bit on the corny side. On the whole, though, :thumbsup:
I really found myself getting involved emotionally as Anakin descended.... it drew me in, even though I totally didn't expect it to.
Some forehead slaps/dislikes:
[*]Okay.. no need for the Tarzan call damnit. That's just ridiculous.
[*]No wind in space. When will filmakers get this?
[*]Slightly annoyed by the reason given for Padme's death
[*]Midichlorians -- Whince!
[*]Too much corny R2 at the beginning. More balanced and it wouldn't have annoyed me.
[*]Too many sweeping cityscapes -- stop showing off!
[*]Droids are even bigger idiots than they were in previous episodes. Time to upgrade to Backbone 2.0!
[*]More Vader reconstruction please!
[*]Duck for cover! Hands flying off everywhere!
[*]Did we REALLY need an oversized multicolored lizard-steed? Really? I mean Really?
[*]Bail Organa's ship toward the end: Jesus Christ my eyes! Bright light! Bright Light!
[*] I don't know why, but near the end when Vader comes off the platform all emotional about Padme, I was reminded of Dark Helmet in Spaceballs.
[*]The obligatory fat-guy-in-a-C3PO suit at our theater. Not Lucas's fault per se, but still... it's painful to watch.
Some likes:
[*]No gungan voices heard anywhere
[*]Opening space battle = wow
[*]Cityscapes and all effect shots are impressive....most impressive
[*]Yes, my friends, Yoda is just a badass.
[*]Chewy!!
[*]Vader's defeat at Mustafah...damn he looked bad....cool!
[*]Tarkin! Sweet!
[*]So THAT's why Palpatine looks like he does in the Ep IV-VI timeline!
[*]Okay....I admit it: Hands flying off everywhere!

[*]6-Wings (or whatever they're called) rock
[*]I dont' care what her hair looks like now, Natalie Portman is just fscking HAWT!
[*]Bail Organa's ship toward the end: Hey... that's familiar!