Would everyone claiming it does not deserve to be the best movie of the year please nominate something they think is deserving?
I thought Avatar was very good, in fact I thought the visuals were one of the weaker parts of the film.
Better films than Avatar of 2009 (imho, as I don't really give a shit about CGI unless the story / acting is really good, or if I'm just in the mood for a throwaway action film)
Tyson (documentary). Fascinating stuff.
Bad Lieutenant : New Orleans. Good to see Cage back in something that suits him well.
The Road. Depressing but very well done, and it doesn't try to spell everything out in 72pt bold, there's subtlety and art here.
Crazy Heart. Legendarily great, gutsy, nuanced work by Jeff Bridges, and a strong supporting cast doing great work.
The Messenger. Outstanding performance by Woody Harrelson, and one of the best directorial debuts of the decade.
The Hurt Locker. Gritty and unpolitical examination of some young men doing very hard work in bleak conditions. Great use of the camera here to give unique perspectives on the action. Doesn't pull punches.
Up in the Air. Solid all around, and very apropos to the times.
Goodbye Solo. A totally profound character study. By the end of this film you could literally know these characters like they were family for years.
That's just for starters. 2009 wasn't even a particularly great year for films.
Popular =! Quality.
McDonalds sells more food daily than any restaurant in history. Is McD's the best food in the world?