I bet, like most thinking posters, he's not getting how you can so baldy lack the basic foresight to see what it would entail to actually train the unemployed in entirely unrelated fields they have no background or education in, that it would necessarily require a huge tax-funded outlay for all the gov't-sponsored hiring of people to train and manage the unemployed in these menial jobs you suggest
The few we'd have to hire we could hire from the unemployed list, thereby reducing the unemployed number. As for training,
what training????? Bending down to pick up garbage? Holding a scraper and scraping paint? Holding a paintbrush and painting? If people cannot master these tasks their first day on the job, the manager can simply have them removed from the unemployment list, as they're too lazy, too stupid, or both.
, that these menial jobs would all have to magically be located within a reasonable distance of all the people who collect unemployment,
They'll be located wherever we need the work done. If that means these people need to live in a tent city, then I guess that's too F'ing bad isn't it? They don't want to do that, they can always go off unemployment. Most jobs though, the unemployed could easily report to their collection point at 6:00 AM local to be bussed to the jobsite - or alternately, arrive there themselves if the location is known ahead of time.
as well as the overwhelming reality that these completely unrealistic menial jobs would inevitably delay the unemployed from getting back into the job market by taking time away from them to actually look for work.
They'd only be working say 30 hours a week. Plenty of time to look for work. For those that have a job interview, they only need to bring a letter from the interviewer for proof of missing the day they needed to report in. Not hard at all, so easy someone living off the system can do it.
And then to top it all off, this training
You keep mentioning this training. What training do you need to do simple manual labor???? If these people are that F'ing dumb, then we need to be rethinking what we should be doing with these people. Forced sterilization may be a good idea to start with if they are so mentally challenged they can't handle a.) bending down b.) grabbing piece of trash c.) standing up d.) putting piece of trash in bag they're holding.
would almost assuredly crowd out a vast majority of the unemployed who would have used said dollars for trade schools or higher education training; unlike the deadend menial jobs education they were just trained for in your completely made-up scenario.
They'd only be doing this 30 hours a week, not 60. They can get their training done on all the rest of their off time. That is, the ones that actually do really go get training, which, from the many people I know collecting unemployment, is a small small %. Then there's your point that no one made of training these people to do menial jobs. No! We're not training them to do menial jobs: We're letting them do menial jobs while they collect public funds. That they learn to bend down and pickup garbage is their problem, not ours.
Oh, not to mention it would discriminate against the significant amount of people that couldn't physically perform said menial jobs.
The old and injured - proof of injury from Dr. prior to starting unemployment job duty required - can go and work in a hospital donating their time. Homeless shelter. Day care. Whatever. Those that are left get a pass, if they're that F'd up then they'd already be on disability anyways.
You're right, we should be trying harder to actually get something for all our unemployment bucks rather than just p1ss it away on getting nothing in return. At least you finally got something right.
Chuck