Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: swtethan
now to me ... and this is *my* PoV ... the PCIe 8800 and Core2Duo are both "very nice" ... but don't offer practical significant performance improvement in games over midrange single-core x1950 AGP rigs on relatively small displays.
There is no argument here. Right now a plain 6600 256mb is good enough for my needs on a 19inch monitor, but both of you would find it inadequate. Upgrading is entirely dependent on each person's budget and preferences for resolutions, game quality settings etc. I am sure there are people on these boards who complain their 8800GTX runs *slow* and someone else is playing the same game with 7900GT and feels that the power is more than adequate.
now i really believe - next year - when "games demand it" ... we are going to make a JUMP to mainstream multi-core and your GTS and Core2Duo on your BIG displays aren't gonna cut it *either*
Doubtful. It takes software on average 2 years to take full advantage of components. X2 came out 2+ years ago and still very few games on the whole benefit from dual core. I doubt my 3.4ghz Core2Duo will struggle when today 2.13ghz is enough to feed an 8800GTX.
so you will upgrade - twice - when i upgrade once
that IS how i look at it
if i guess *wrong* ... then i lose ... but you ARE spending double
for what i also consider an *interim* upgrade
I had similar old setup similar to yours which comprised of P4 2.6C@3.2ghz, 1gb ram, Abit IS7, sold it last summer for $275 US, added $500 and got 2gb DDR2, core2duo and new mobo and 6600 in Oct, 2006. In 2007, I'll sell the same components to a friend who'll have no idea about overclocking for $500+ (making the upgrade cost very small) because Core2Duo 3.4 will cost $250-300 alone.
With overclocking at your side, you can upgrade 2, 5, 10x if you want. As long as there are consumers that dont' know how to overclock and you can sell the technology to them by being a good salesperson: SATA2 is 300mb/sec vs. your ATA 133mb/sec (they get excited by hearing numbers

but have no idea what they mean). This way you can actually lose very little $ or even make money and always have a very fast rig. Selling PCIe, DDR2, 256MB to an average Joe is a lot easier than selling AGP, DDR1 and P4 single core even if the latter setup is faster (because the average person wont argue that DDR2>DDR1, PCIe>AGP and Core2Duo > P4 from 2003). Most people I've met will think a 7300LE turbocache 512mb is a lot faster than X1950XT 256mb unless one were to show them the price difference (which they won't research anyways). Therefore, when one buys components or upgrades, it is important to consider resale and from that perspective AGP doesn't stand a chance.