Why do people like Costco so much?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Muse

Lifer
Jul 11, 2001
41,067
10,311
136
I live in a single adult household and I've been a Costco member since the 1990's and haven't considered not being a member. The dues now are I think around $60/year, and I figure I make that up in savings easily just shopping there. There's lots to like:

1. They don't stock much in the way of competing brands. You go into a supermarket and they have maybe 4 kinds of something. At Costco they don't do that, they have buyers who try to pick a brand that people will prefer. Otherwise it's a waste of their shelf space and that brings down their profits.

2. They do a lot of deals to get their own brand on items, usually Kirkland. Those tend to be decent to high quality and at a discount to regular brands.

3. Although I'm single, I like quantity over convenience for many things, and there's savings in that. I'll buy a 15lb bag of rice instead of a 12oz box at some supermarket, saves me money. I'll buy a 13lb box of navel oranges that'll last me at least until my next trip. I'll buy a 10lb bag of organic sweet potatoes that last months unrefrigerated. I buy a lot of nuts there and freeze them. I never used to eat tomatoes off season (I grow my own) but this winter bought 2lb containers of organic cherry tomatoes there every two weeks (once I was vaccinated I started going every other week again). They keep OK for a couple of weeks. I buy bags of 6 organic Romaine lettuce for under $4, been eating a fresh salad every day for months. The selection of cheese is in my eyes terrific and the prices exceptional. I buy a 3lb bag of organic frozen blueberries at a great price and put them in my smoothies. I think their dozen bagels, baked right there, for $6.99 are a great deal and I always get that.

4. I have 2 TVs I bought at Costco, discounted and they have an automatic additional IIRC 2 years warranty.

5. For most items they have a no questions asked return policy that's robust. IIRC I don't even have to have the receipt, the record of my purchase is in their data.

6. The drive is 5 miles from my house. Farther than my favorite indy supermarket (a 1/4 mile bicycle ride), but perfect for an every other week jaunt over there.

7. Nowadays they have real good usually pretty fresh produce. I tend to buy organic produce and they have a fair amount of that. You're never sure what they're going to be stocking but I usually have a pretty good idea. If I require something they don't have I'll drop into Trader Joe's or my fave indy market.

8. Cheapest gas around. And the Visa Costco credit card has 3% back on gas elsewhere, 3% back on restaurants, 3% back on approved travel expenses (e.g. flights). Good place to get tires. They don't carry ones for my old car though nowadays.

9. I've gotten some online deals but principally shop Costco B&M.

10. They issue me a rebate coupon once a year (comes in the mail) that I bring to my next B&M trip that pays most of my yearly membership fee.

11. They have a coupon book they send you with deals. Most of that stuff doesn't interest me, but I look it through and pick out items I bookmark to pick up because I'd get them anyway, so I get them at a discount. I sometimes stock up on things like that. Used to be you had to present the coupon at checkout but they stopped doing that... it gets marked down automatically now if it's on sale.

12. The staff there tend to be pretty helpful. I like that it's not a standard business model. It really is the opposite of a 7-11 or convenience store, and I never go into those places.

13. The clientele is on average pretty OK compared to elsewhere, I think. For instance, the local Safeway super markets drive me nuts. Seriously, the people in there gross me out. At Costco I may get irritated at times but never get intense reactions.

14. Yeah, the free food samples all over the food areas are fun. They stopped doing it during the pandemic, but I got one a week ago, so they're evidently starting to do that again. I usually feel like I just ate 1/2 a meal by the time I leave!
 
Last edited:

balloonshark

Diamond Member
Jun 5, 2008
7,246
3,683
136
Never been to a Costco but every other topic on slickdeals someone chimes in and say this item is cheaper at Costco and it's better quality.

Maybe keep your eyes on slickdeals since they seem to post some Costco deals including when they have sales. They also have coupons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Muse

ponyo

Lifer
Feb 14, 2002
19,688
2,811
126
If I was single, it would be very hard to justify Costco membership. Portions are just too big for single person. I hate cooking just for myself. I wouldn't cook much if I was single. I would grocery shop at Lidl, Aldi, Trader Joe's, and Publix instead and just utilize Amazon and Walmart for other stuff.

Beat me either. I went to Costco a few times with a friend (she has the membership and I has one from Sam's). I did spot check a few times such as spices, pants, undies, socks. Almost all of them were about the same price as Sam's.

I have to say the employees at Costco were more friendly and helpful and the place seem to be cleaner.
Sam's is like the ghetto version of Costco. It might look similar but looks are deceiving. Sam's inventory turnover is just too slow compared to Costco so their food and produce are not fresh because of that. At least where I live. Costco and Trader Joe's turnover their inventory amazingly quick so their goods are pretty much always fresh. I keep Sam's membership mainly for gas since it's closer to where I live.
 

Muse

Lifer
Jul 11, 2001
41,067
10,311
136
If I was single, it would be very hard to justify Costco membership. Portions are just too big for single person. I hate cooking just for myself. I wouldn't cook much if I was single. I would grocery shop at Lidl, Aldi, Trader Joe's, and Publix instead and just utilize Amazon and Walmart for other stuff.
I'm single and love Costco. I'll buy a package of bacon and freeze it. I'll buy a roast, cut it up and freeze it. I buy those 3lb bunches of bananas (organic and much cheaper you can get elsewhere), 2 or 3 bunches at a time and store in the fridge, put a few in the oven (pilot keeps them at 85F) where they ripen in a day or two: I have bananas, as many as I want, when I want, any time I want until my next trip. I bring a shopping list I print out before I go, have a table dedicated to Costco shopping!
Sam's is like the ghetto version of Costco. It might look similar but looks are deceiving. Sam's inventory turnover is just too slow compared to Costco so their food and produce are not fresh because of that. At least where I live. Costco and Trader Joe's turnover their inventory amazingly quick so their goods are pretty much always fresh. I keep Sam's membership mainly for gas since it's closer to where I live.
I find that Costco's produce tends to be a lot fresher than my local Trader Joe's. I have to inspect stuff carefully at TJ's.
 

Kaido

Elite Member & Kitchen Overlord
Feb 14, 2004
51,952
7,409
136
Kirkland brand food owns the key to my heart
 
  • Like
Reactions: Muse

Red Squirrel

No Lifer
May 24, 2003
70,930
13,927
126
www.anyf.ca
I went to Costco back when I went to Sudbury and it was pretty crazy to see for the first time, just so huge in there. It's like Walmart on steroids but with better quality stuff. That said if we had one here I don't know if it would be worthwhile for me to get a membership. I can't go through food fast enough to justify buying bulk, and for non perishables, there is still only so much I need in a given year.
 

ondma

Diamond Member
Mar 18, 2018
3,316
1,708
136
(1) While Costco is still the best national WH club its not as good selection or price wise as it used to be.

(2) Having said that I usually still find most of what I want when I shop there, but now that I'm single I don't buy in bulk as often.
I have mixed feelings about it. We like to purchase meat there, as it is high quality and the prices are usually reasonable. Fruit and vegetable prices can be a bargain as well.
I will look into buying tires there the next time I need them, either before this winter or next. One does have to be careful though to not buy huge quantities of things that you will never use. We have a costco membership now, and used to have Sam's club as well when all our kids were home. I find Costco to be a much cleaner, better organized, more pleasant shopping experience than Sam's Club was.
 

MrSquished

Lifer
Jan 14, 2013
26,067
24,397
136
If I was single, it would be very hard to justify Costco membership. Portions are just too big for single person. I hate cooking just for myself. I wouldn't cook much if I was single. I would grocery shop at Lidl, Aldi, Trader Joe's, and Publix instead and just utilize Amazon and Walmart for other stuff.


Sam's is like the ghetto version of Costco. It might look similar but looks are deceiving. Sam's inventory turnover is just too slow compared to Costco so their food and produce are not fresh because of that. At least where I live. Costco and Trader Joe's turnover their inventory amazingly quick so their goods are pretty much always fresh. I keep Sam's membership mainly for gas since it's closer to where I live.

I'm not a big fan of cooking for myself a lot when single but some of us have to instead of buying takeout all the time, it's just pricey, but if you don't mind freezing raw ingredients, usually proteins, and finding the good shelf stable stuff, Costco can work out well. Some things I definitely won't buy at Costco due to portion sizes, especially things that are more perishable, like a huge thing of salad mix, but the freezer is your friend for many products like chicken and beef and pork and shrimp. The 2 dozen organic eggs are a great deal, since I cook them for my dog. The big bag of raw organic sugar. The raw honey. The granola. The Momosan noodles. Dog greenies. Better than Bouillon. Kerry Gold Butter that you can freeze. The Kirkland organic chicken stock. Bacon. Dried fruits. Rice. Organic pasta. Pistachios. The olive oil. There is a good chance you will find enough to make worthwhile if you cook for yourself 50% of the time or more, as long as you can find products that can keep that you like. I have enough go to stuff that it's worth it.

But if you get takeout most of the time, or just don't love Costco's selections, then yeah, it's really not worth it at all.
 

nakedfrog

No Lifer
Apr 3, 2001
63,186
19,519
136
So I joined 8 minutes ago. Ordered my bidet and to the younger dudes out there. You know you have been with a woman a long time and have a successful relationship when you can buy her a toilet seat for her birthday and she will love it.
That right there is success. I’ll update the thread in August if I remember.
Second thing I shopped for were tires and DAMN they are expensive for tires. $860 for four tires mounted on my car vs townfair who I hate because of their perpetual up selling of everything is $550-ish sort of guessing but there is always an up sell so I added $30 additional to the cost. Same brand, different model, similar wear guarantee.
I f-img hate tire shopping the experience sucks due to:
Hidden costs
Cost of install typically isn’t shown
Buying from online vendor is useless because finding someone to put them on will be a pain in the ass. No I am not going the explosive mounting route.
Models vary location to location to make price comparisons difficult
I've never had much trouble finding someone to mount tires I've ordered online, YMMV. So long as they're still visibly brand new, anyway. I've done it quite a few times. That was in the midwest, haven't done it in the PNW yet. Generally ran me about $20/tire.
But I've also found when I am planning to buy/install tires at the same place, most local joints will have about the same price on similar tires--one might offer "free" install, but charge more for the tires, such that it works out to nearly the same price as another place in town in the end.
I almost always end up holding out for a rebate anyway, there's frequently rebates going around. My last Firestone tire rebate was pretty painless (and tires are the only thing I ever recommend getting done at Firestone).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fanatical Meat

nakedfrog

No Lifer
Apr 3, 2001
63,186
19,519
136
giphy.gif
 
  • Love
Reactions: Kaido

BurnItDwn

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
26,355
1,867
126
I believe costco offers free tire rotations for life of the tires if you buy your tires from them ... that accounts for part of the up front price ....
 
Feb 4, 2009
35,862
17,406
136
I believe costco offers free tire rotations for life of the tires if you buy your tires from them ... that accounts for part of the up front price ....

Pretty much everywhere near me does that but yeah that has value doing it yourself is a pain in the ass especially with the jack included with the car.
 

nakedfrog

No Lifer
Apr 3, 2001
63,186
19,519
136
Yeah, I only had to use my floor jack a few times before it felt like a worthwhile purchase. Still don't rotate my own tires, maybe after I have a compressor and air tools. Planning to get one so I can put up some tongue and groove ceiling in the new place.
 
Feb 4, 2009
35,862
17,406
136
After a few trips exploring all the aisles you'll know if it's worth it for your lifestyle.

Yeah I’ll check it out. Not sure if it will be my thing since I am not a bulk shopper and pizza or food takeout is just too far to bother with.
However I got the bidet, I do need an above the stove microwave their website shows some interesting ones, sort of more money than I want to spend on something that 99% of the time is used to heat frozen veggies but they are brand names and appear to be midrange feature wise which I assume translates to longer lasting, plus they look better than the $200 brand name Lowes or Homedepot microwaves.
 

Red Squirrel

No Lifer
May 24, 2003
70,930
13,927
126
www.anyf.ca
That reminds me I probably should do a tire rotation on my truck. I used to do it kind of naturally with the cars given I'd swap tires twice a year for winter/summer but now I have all terrains and since it's 4x4 I don't bother with winters. I got the trademark Ford rust going on so not sure how easy they will be to take off though lol.
 

Kaido

Elite Member & Kitchen Overlord
Feb 14, 2004
51,952
7,409
136
Hmm. A good trusted opinion.
Still kind of a far drive for food but I’ll check it out

Is Costco worth it? It really depends on your situation. A few notes:

1. Free samples are back & are a fun perk
2. Kirkland brand is 90% awesome. There are some misses, but because a team of people is picking out a supplier for their store-brand stuff, it's generally really really good.
3. The snackbar after checkout is pretty decent. Try the vanilla soft serve with the berries, it's really good!
4. They have an excellent return policy
5. Get the Executive Membership for $120. If you don't spend enough to get the rewards within a year, they'll refund the difference between a regular membership.
6. The $5 rotisserie chicken is fantastic. The story behind it is amazing.

However, if you're not doing bulk shopping, then it may not be worth it. I cook for my family & for my extended family (ex. my parents, who are older), plus I've started to get into food storage (sort of like Prepper Lite lol) ever since the pandemic, with things like vac-sealing food & using a deep freezer to store raw frozen food, par-cooked/prepped foods (ex. sous-vide then frozen to thaw & sear/grill later, frozen cookie dough balls, etc.), and fully-cooked foods, so I like to buy in bulk & then vac-seal stuff up so I don't have to go shopping so much & can save money. If you just kind of shop for a couple people as the week goes on for the week ahead, then it may not be worth it to you. Two ways to try it out:

1. Find a friend who has a membership to go with
2. Get a membership. They'll refund it if you don't like it.

One thing to note is that they only take VISA in the stores. They dropped support for Mastercard, Discover, and American Express. They do take Mobile Pay tho, so you can use Apple Pay & whatnot:


Little bit of a hassle if you want to rack up points on your Mastercard or whatever. Also, depending on how much you're willing to go down the Costco rabbit hole of opportunities, there are a lot of other stuff that make it worthwhile:


For example, they're a great place to buy tires from:


If you travel, they have deals on rental cars, theme parks, hotels, and cruises:


Plus they have a pretty good eyeglass store. So...kind of depends on if all of this stuff makes sense for your situation. I like to get meat there (beef, chicken, fish, etc.) plus bulk baking supplies. They always have cool snacks to try (in bulk, lol). It's a cool store, but if none of this stuff interests you, then it may not be worth the annual cost or the drive to commute to.
 
Feb 4, 2009
35,862
17,406
136
Is Costco worth it? It really depends on your situation. A few notes:

1. Free samples are back & are a fun perk
2. Kirkland brand is 90% awesome. There are some misses, but because a team of people is picking out a supplier for their store-brand stuff, it's generally really really good.
3. The snackbar after checkout is pretty decent. Try the vanilla soft serve with the berries, it's really good!
4. They have an excellent return policy
5. Get the Executive Membership for $120. If you don't spend enough to get the rewards within a year, they'll refund the difference between a regular membership.
6. The $5 rotisserie chicken is fantastic. The story behind it is amazing.

However, if you're not doing bulk shopping, then it may not be worth it. I cook for my family & for my extended family (ex. my parents, who are older), plus I've started to get into food storage (sort of like Prepper Lite lol) ever since the pandemic, with things like vac-sealing food & using a deep freezer to store raw frozen food, par-cooked/prepped foods (ex. sous-vide then frozen to thaw & sear/grill later, frozen cookie dough balls, etc.), and fully-cooked foods, so I like to buy in bulk & then vac-seal stuff up so I don't have to go shopping so much & can save money. If you just kind of shop for a couple people as the week goes on for the week ahead, then it may not be worth it to you. Two ways to try it out:

1. Find a friend who has a membership to go with
2. Get a membership. They'll refund it if you don't like it.

One thing to note is that they only take VISA in the stores. They dropped support for Mastercard, Discover, and American Express. They do take Mobile Pay tho, so you can use Apple Pay & whatnot:


Little bit of a hassle if you want to rack up points on your Mastercard or whatever. Also, depending on how much you're willing to go down the Costco rabbit hole of opportunities, there are a lot of other stuff that make it worthwhile:


For example, they're a great place to buy tires from:


If you travel, they have deals on rental cars, theme parks, hotels, and cruises:


Plus they have a pretty good eyeglass store. So...kind of depends on if all of this stuff makes sense for your situation. I like to get meat there (beef, chicken, fish, etc.) plus bulk baking supplies. They always have cool snacks to try (in bulk, lol). It's a cool store, but if none of this stuff interests you, then it may not be worth the annual cost or the drive to commute to.

Yeah bunch on the list doesn’t apply or ranks as Meh to me.
However....
A snack bar at checkout sounds like it’s worth the price of admission.

More seriously I picked up the 6800U bidet you recommended a few months ago. I absolutely know my wife will appreciate it and while it is currently not a problem I would like to get my Parents into thinking they are not weird. They are getting old and cleaning back there could become a problem, hasn’t yet but it would be great if I could get them accustomed to the idea now.
The bidet purchase alone paid for the membership. I’ll try shopping there and see what it’s all about but that won’t happen until August.
Next project is to figure out how to replace a basement window, project after that is to run a wire for the bidet.
 
Last edited:

Muse

Lifer
Jul 11, 2001
41,067
10,311
136
About an hour round trip
I'm around 25 minutes round trip. But I usually go past and double back to get some extra miles on my car because my Costco runs are usually the only car usages I'm getting, so wanna give the car a workout every two weeks. So, probably 35 minutes total driving every other Thursday, after I was fully vaccinated.