iphone 3GS - 9.5/10. it does almost everything i want in a phone, and does them WELL. more audio and video codecs should be supported, the "lack" of true multitasking, and battery life could be better, but compared to my old 3G capable phones, it blows them away completely.
gay-t&t - 8/10 actually. since ive had my 3GS, ive had absolutely no dropped calls, and 4-5 bars everywhere i go. however, while its no sprint SERO, -1 is for being a bit expensive (thank god for 20% off) in general, and -1 for not having MMS and tethering at launch. how the hell can almost every other phone on at&t have MMS, and most other smartphones with both MMS and tethering? its unacceptable, quite honestly. at least its coming soon with 3.1 apparently (next week!).