Originally posted by: Steeplerot
Originally posted by: GTKeeper
Steeplerot,
If you care to address these points, please do, I wonder what your opinion is on the matter.
Point #1
I fully believe that all immigrants can become americans and that they are 'good enough'. It has nothing to do with them being illegal or not. It is not a Racism issue to me.
I do not disagree with this, but I do not see labeling them illegals when it was our poorly layed out unrealistic laws that were created by racism that made the problem i n the first place, it is a crap position to be in as a mexican but it was inevitable becasue of our laws. They were just doing the best for their familys and have not caused us much trouble imo, regardless of what people try to say a lot have risks there freedom to come here in the first place and maintain false SS numbers just to be productive, AND pay taxes they know they will never get returns for.
Originally posted by: GTKeeper
Point #2
If the government would regulate and check if all these illegal immigrants are paying taxes and ss just like every other American, they can stay IMHO because they are productive members of society and they have a right to be here as able bodies citizens.
I agree, if they have clean records and are productive it would be foolish to drive them out, a fine of some sort would be a good idea, but I could more see the employers over the past few years deserving of the fine more then the worker, I am not sure of this yet.
Originally posted by: GTKeeper
Point #3
People like you undermine all the immigrants that have come here legally. And please don't tell me that we have it 'easier' than anyone else. It took my family (and only with the aid of a U.S company) 4 months to get a H1 Visa. And what this meant was standing in line for weeks at a time to talk to a U.S immigration officer in the U.S Embassy. Yes, you stand in line for 12 hours, you get a ticket and come back to stand for 12 hours more the next day based on your place in line the day before.
After that the application for a Green Card was even more stressful, because if you don't get that you have to go back home. We went through that as well.
With the rate of illegals coming into the U.S I seriously doubt they all have the proper paperwork to work here to begin with. A lot of it is under the table.
A lot is under the table, but then a lot also have green cards and falsified IDs they have been forced to get, it is not a fair situation but the law itself is a unfair and as I said racist OLD policy, there is a great wrong done in the past, and I am not sure if a I am sorry is enough to correct those that did go through proper process over the years, but legal immigrants have had a easier time in a lot of ways then someone always fearing deportation and having to use false ID's they have also been through hell in a way, to do nothing less then be productive members of society.
It is not fair to just about anyone and IS a big problem, but the chest thumping and discrimination over people here to work looking for the same chance the rest of the immigrants here had is hypocritical on many levels, I agree that none of this is fair, but if you get down to the law that made this, it is obvious why, it is straight from the KKK, trouble down the road is inevitable when people like that drive lawmaking, now we are in a real mess.