• We should now be fully online following an overnight outage. Apologies for any inconvenience, we do not expect there to be any further issues.

Video not for the weak stomachs

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Aharami

Lifer
Aug 31, 2001
21,205
165
106
Originally posted by: Taejin
REPOST!

Well, not really a repost, but PETA jacked those clips from another video (I think). The original thread can be found by searching fur.



And there's nothing wrong with killing an animal for fur.

The reason why keep them alive is so they can get *all* the fur including on the head.

I think they should behead the animal or something..before skinning it alive like that..

But from an objective standpoint it kind of makes sense. (I think this takes place in China) - which means poor people, which means each scrap of fur is worth money, as long as it's part of the entire pelt. Also, if you do slit it's throat or cut it's head off, you'll get blood getting all over the coat. This may(?) have some adverse effect on the coat itself. And finally, you notice they do not do anything to really torture the animal, other than skinning it alive. They club/stun it, since they are really interested in the fur, and don't want to damage it./calm objectivity

Yeah, but the video is pretty awful, and I think they should not be able to kill animals for fur in that manner. The animals need to be put to death first.

so what does it matter that they didnt do anything ELSE to torture it? skinning it alive is torture enough!!!!
 

Tazanator

Senior member
Oct 11, 2004
318
0
0
I think it's fake/staged - most taxidemist you drop off the animal and leave. this is a hunting party. Not sure why they are so cruel probably a "sport" hunter and not a food hunter (difference is why they hunt, the food hunter wants it for eating and will take a lot of pains to get the best meat (ammo shot placement recovery of animal after shot/won't chase wounded) sport hunters just want the kill/trouphy)
 

jjzelinski

Diamond Member
Aug 23, 2004
3,750
0
0
Originally posted by: Aharami
Originally posted by: Taejin
REPOST!

Well, not really a repost, but PETA jacked those clips from another video (I think). The original thread can be found by searching fur.



And there's nothing wrong with killing an animal for fur.

The reason why keep them alive is so they can get *all* the fur including on the head.

I think they should behead the animal or something..before skinning it alive like that..

But from an objective standpoint it kind of makes sense. (I think this takes place in China) - which means poor people, which means each scrap of fur is worth money, as long as it's part of the entire pelt. Also, if you do slit it's throat or cut it's head off, you'll get blood getting all over the coat. This may(?) have some adverse effect on the coat itself. And finally, you notice they do not do anything to really torture the animal, other than skinning it alive. They club/stun it, since they are really interested in the fur, and don't want to damage it./calm objectivity

Yeah, but the video is pretty awful, and I think they should not be able to kill animals for fur in that manner. The animals need to be put to death first.

so what does it matter that they didnt do anything ELSE to torture it? skinning it alive is torture enough!!!!


That's so mindlessly cruel its funny, "And finally, you notice they do not do anything to really torture the animal, other than skinning it alive." LOL good god that's deranged!

So if animals are just property and are inferior creatures to human's are you of the habit of skinning your dogs when you have no use for them? Such as old age, boredom, etc... Sure you might not need the pelt, but what would it hurt?
 

Aharami

Lifer
Aug 31, 2001
21,205
165
106
1st time i turned it off as soon as he slammed that racoon on the ground. i tried watching it again to see whats so bad....i had to turn it off couple seconds after he started skinning that animal. i just couldnt watch it....i just couldnt. :(

i have a headache now
 

UNCjigga

Lifer
Dec 12, 2000
25,585
10,281
136
I liked their campaign of naked women better...PETA ads generally suck. They really know how to make people feel good about their organization :roll:
 

purbeast0

No Lifer
Sep 13, 2001
53,643
6,527
126
Originally posted by: rh71
Originally posted by: purbeast0
i love animals and all, but i also took a class in college that showed us a video of how cows come from the farm to our plate. it was very graphic and showed it all. but atleast it was VERY humane and the cows don't feel any pain as they are killed, and you don't feel quite AS bad for them.
how are cows humanely slaughtered ? I've never really found out...

well they are loaded off the truck and forced into a single file line. from there, they walk foward where there feet eventually fall out from below them, however they don't fall and their bellies are on a conveyer belt. so its kind of like they are lying on their bellies with their legs hanging over the side of the belt, but there are walls keeping them from falling off the belt. from there they go for a few feet where the belt stops and their head is "propped" on something, and a type of gun sends an electrical pulse into their brain, knocking them unconscious. they don't even feel a thing at all from it. then they move a little more on the conveyere belt and a person actually slits their throat. at this point they aren't completely dead yet, but they are still very much unconscious.

then a person adds a chain around one of their legs, and the conveyer belt (remember its moving the whole time, aside from when they get the electric pulse) drops from below them and they are dangling upside down. these chains they are attached too are also moving, at the same speed as the conveyer belt. at this point about 5-7 electrical charges are shot through the chain attached to their leg. this is where they pretty much die. they die from losing blood. the upside down lets gravity help with the blood loss, and the electric shocks at this point help the blood flow out of their body. (its kind of amusing to watch them dangling upside down and get a shock through their body because they start flailing all over the place, but not amusing in a funny or bad way).

so now they are officially dead. the skinning part is kind of cool though. a person will cut the skin off of the leg, kind of skinning the leg (that is dangling) and attach the skin to a "roller" type device. think of it like when you attach a thread to a spool, and roll the spool to have the thread keep getting added to the spool. the "roller" type device will then go down the entire body, all while rolling and rolling and rippin the skin off of the cow until it reaches the head and rips the skin off the head.

think of it as kind of "turning the skin inside out". it really is like when you try to roll something back onto a spool, although its a little more graphic. at this point, the guys then cut the head off the cow and they start to process the meat.

it is a very graphic process, but honestly, watching it was a great learning experience for me. i really hate seeing animals get hurt, even the slightest, but watching this seemed more of a learning experience than anything and it didn't really bother me much.
 

TheLonelyPhoenix

Diamond Member
Feb 15, 2004
5,594
1
0
PETA videos show the absolute worst of the worst of what happens to animals, these occurances certainly aren't average. Yet they pitch their message like every non-domesticated animal in the US has been brutally tortured for fun. The worst is when they put cheesy country songs behind the movie.

While I can certainly respect that animals should have certain rights (including ones that are going to be killed and eaten) and that some practices in the meat industry have gotten out of hand, by taking such an extreme attitude PETA have made themselves look ridiculous and destroyed their own credibility.
 

Yax

Platinum Member
Feb 11, 2003
2,866
0
0
The video was purposely done to further Peta's cause. Its easier to skin an animal after its dead. Its easier to shoot an animal in the head to kill it. Its also easier to shock the animal then stab it in the neck to kill it before skinning it.

Lame attempt to capture the attention of ignorant audiences.
 

Softballslug

Senior member
Feb 22, 2000
397
0
0
I think this is staged. Reason is... If PETA was so concerned about this happening why don't they tell us where, when and by whom??? Sounds easy enough doesn't it? They just want a reaction to meet their cause of the moment.
 

BlackAdam

Senior member
Jul 16, 2004
729
0
0
I hate PETA with a passion, but I have to agree with them on the fur issue. I'm not an activist against fur, but I frown on it. This video made me sick to my stomach.
 

Fingers

Platinum Member
Sep 4, 2000
2,188
0
0
Originally posted by: rh71
Originally posted by: purbeast0
i love animals and all, but i also took a class in college that showed us a video of how cows come from the farm to our plate. it was very graphic and showed it all. but atleast it was VERY humane and the cows don't feel any pain as they are killed, and you don't feel quite AS bad for them.
how are cows humanely slaughtered ? I've never really found out...

Air hammer to the head then hung upside down and bled out.

Edit: This is assumption for cows but it's how they do it for pigs, at least for smithfield hams. Don't know why some places use electrical shock method, it costs too much in electricity. Air compressor and air hammer is much cheaper and safer for the operator.
 

Fingers

Platinum Member
Sep 4, 2000
2,188
0
0
Originally posted by: Yax
The video was purposely done to further Peta's cause. Its easier to skin an animal after its dead. Its easier to shoot an animal in the head to kill it. Its also easier to shock the animal then stab it in the neck to kill it before skinning it.

Lame attempt to capture the attention of ignorant audiences.

Cut veins and such then you get blood on the fur, then it's not worth as much. just skinning doesn't cause a great amount of bleeding.
 

chrisms

Diamond Member
Mar 9, 2003
6,615
0
0
Anyone ever seen the film Roger & Me by Michael Moore? I thought the rabbit lady was disturbing. She'd treat these rabbits like her favorite pet, laughing at them and cuddling them and petting them. Then she puts it on the ground and smack it with a club a few times, and skins it.

Its not the skinning that is disturbing, just the fact that she seemed to care for the animals before chopping their heads off.
 

redly

Golden Member
Nov 15, 2004
1,159
0
0
Originally posted by: chrisms
Anyone ever seen the film Roger & Me by Michael Moore? I thought the rabbit lady was disturbing. She'd treat these rabbits like her favorite pet, laughing at them and cuddling them and petting them. Then she puts it on the ground and smack it with a club a few times, and skins it.

Its not the skinning that is disturbing, just the fact that she seemed to care for the animals before chopping their heads off.


Hmm, just had a thought. send anyone back to the fvcking stone age and give them some pet rabbits, I bet after a while they'd act the same way
 

SagaLore

Elite Member
Dec 18, 2001
24,036
21
81
Originally posted by: Adica
I had to shut it off not even 15 seconds into it.

Yea it's awful. Not sure what last you saw, but while they're skinning it from the hind legs down, it's struggling - then you think it's dead - then they're half way down the stomach and it starts struggling again.

:(
 

Sheepathon

Diamond Member
Oct 22, 2003
6,093
7
81
ugh, not cool watching someone step on a creature's face and neck on the ground and watching it slowly suffocate to death
 

Fingers

Platinum Member
Sep 4, 2000
2,188
0
0
Originally posted by: SagaLore
Originally posted by: Adica
I had to shut it off not even 15 seconds into it.

Yea it's awful. Not sure what last you saw, but while they're skinning it from the hind legs down, it's struggling - then you think it's dead - then they're half way down the stomach and it starts struggling again.

:(

I especially enjoyed the part when they didn't have any skin at all and it was moving around. Kinda looked like it might be painfull, but then again it's just an animal ;)
 

Taejin

Moderator<br>Love & Relationships
Aug 29, 2004
3,270
0
0
Originally posted by: gopunk
Originally posted by: Taejin
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: rbloedow
:( Any person who would skin an animal while it's conscious deserves the same.
I agree 100%. The part I watched before turning it off was absolutely sickening. I think a lot of what PETA says and the way they say it are often extreme but this is a perfect example of why I'm not one of the PETA hating morons who bash them regardless of the issue.

Human > Animal. Don't equate them as being the same thing.

No one gets the death penalty for torturing an animal.

i think you need a refresher on biology... humans are a subset of animals.


I think you need a refresher on laws. Humans are not treated as animals by the law, and as such the penalties of torture/murder of a human being vs an animal are different.
 

Taejin

Moderator<br>Love & Relationships
Aug 29, 2004
3,270
0
0
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: Taejin
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: rbloedow
:( Any person who would skin an animal while it's conscious deserves the same.
I agree 100%. The part I watched before turning it off was absolutely sickening. I think a lot of what PETA says and the way they say it are often extreme but this is a perfect example of why I'm not one of the PETA hating morons who bash them regardless of the issue.

Human > Animal. Don't equate them as being the same thing.

No one gets the death penalty for torturing an animal.

That's your opinion and you are entitled to it. IMO people who do things like that shouldn't be considered human.


Good luck trying to convince the law that. Whether your opinion states that people who skin animals for fun shouldn't be considered human is moot. Our reality reflects that the death/torture of humans is more harshly punished than that of an animal, and your opinion is nothing but the seedlings of vigilantism.
 

BigToque

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
11,700
0
76
I like what PETA stands for... the ethical treatment of animals. I absolutely hate how they go about trying to make points though. They make themselves look like idiots.

 

RelaxTheMind

Platinum Member
Oct 15, 2002
2,245
0
76
i always wondered where furless cats and dogs came from. the first one looked like something straight from resident evil movie.

you guys should check out where our beef/chicken/pork comes from. hehe.

i wish i could go watch it in person. im sick like that. the whole twitching and kicking made me giggle.

i want a keychain give me a pulsating foot!!!