The Alduin fight was a huge and I mean huge letdown. This was entirely too easy even on Master level. There were no surprises, no drawn out battle. Just dragonrend zap dragonrend zap.. rinse and repeat. Makes me lament for how much I miss the end battle in Baldur's Gate 2 and Jagged Alliance.
And then when he dies he just evaporates and doesn't even drop anything. Seriously?
The most fun I had in this game was early on doing the Winterhold mage quests. When I got the end reward I was pretty excited and was looking forward to other similar quests with maybe upgrades. Little did I know that the Arch Mage robe was the best in game at that point. The staff is ok and the mask of Morokei is nice but once you get to a point where magicka regen isn't important because you can enchant 100% reduction in destruction spells it trivializes the whole regen aspect.
The Dremora pet is far too powerful. Now look, I don't mind spending time making my toon a tad bit OP but when the mobs don't scale to your power it sadly makes the game boring. I almost fell asleep in Skuldyn(sp?) killing endless draugr because it was not challening in the least.
Now here is the part I hate most. As much as I want to create a melee toon and do this again I really don't see the point. I'm sure I'll have fun doing the companion and stormcloak quests and/or dark brotherhood but then probably not enjoy the mainline quest at all knowing what is ahead and how easy it is. I'm sure I'll get some nice rewards but I also know I can just smith my own uber weapon/armor. IMHO, quest rewards should be the best items and you should have follow up quests to upgrade them. This would make replay much more interesting.
IMHO what they should have done is this. Cut back on some of the side quests and make the mainline quest branch with different endings and different rewards in each branch. That would give me a big incentive to go back and start a new toon.
Sigh. I dunno, the whole last 1/3 of the game seemed so boring and not very challenging. Pretty sad that the first 1/3 of the game was the most exciting and rewarding.
One thing I might do is go Orc 2h and just kill everything in sight to express my frustration
Oh well. Here's hoping people can come up with some great add ons.