Originally posted by: erwos
The Best Buy news may or may not be damning to HD-DVD. Depends on whether corporate made the decision on their own, or whether this is just a marketing stunt that the BR Group paid for. In the latter case, this is just hot air. In the former, it could be trouble, as it'll mean less and less HD-DVD stuff stocked.
Still, it's not good news for HD-DVD. One more studio defection, and it's basically over at this point.
Originally posted by: JC86
Originally posted by: erwos
The Best Buy news may or may not be damning to HD-DVD. Depends on whether corporate made the decision on their own, or whether this is just a marketing stunt that the BR Group paid for. In the latter case, this is just hot air. In the former, it could be trouble, as it'll mean less and less HD-DVD stuff stocked.
Still, it's not good news for HD-DVD. One more studio defection, and it's basically over at this point.
Since most consumers take what BB tells them with a grain of salt anyways, I don't think it'd be that big of a deal. The Netflix announcement, however, is a much bigger score for the BR group. I wonder if the BR group cut them a deal for cheaper BR movies to stock in exchange for the exclusive agreement.
Originally posted by: Wreckage
I think this thread has served it's purpose. There is no format war anymore.
You'd be surprised at how many people are still in denial. Check out AVSForum or HighDefDigest Forum; lots of HD DVD owners still singing the praises of their dead format.Originally posted by: Wreckage
I think this thread has served it's purpose. There is no format war anymore.
Originally posted by: jpeyton
You'd be surprised at how many people are still in denial. Check out AVSForum or HighDefDigest Forum; lots of HD DVD owners still singing the praises of their dead format.Originally posted by: Wreckage
I think this thread has served it's purpose. There is no format war anymore.
Originally posted by: spacejamz
in their official release, they actually say "...at least they will continue to carry HD DVD"...that really shows a sign of confidence there if you ask me...
Originally posted by: jpeyton
You'd be surprised at how many people are still in denial. Check out AVSForum or HighDefDigest Forum; lots of HD DVD owners still singing the praises of their dead format.
Originally posted by: TheVrolok
Originally posted by: jpeyton
You'd be surprised at how many people are still in denial. Check out AVSForum or HighDefDigest Forum; lots of HD DVD owners still singing the praises of their dead format.Originally posted by: Wreckage
I think this thread has served it's purpose. There is no format war anymore.
sigh, I don't think you realize how it must be equally annoying to hear the Blu-ray supports gloat. That said, I STILL think HD-DVD is superior to BRD in many ways (read: in deserving of praise). Just because HD-DVD lost the war does not indicate it to be the inferior format. Look at beta and vhs for proof of that.
Originally posted by: Genx87
Originally posted by: TheVrolok
Originally posted by: jpeyton
You'd be surprised at how many people are still in denial. Check out AVSForum or HighDefDigest Forum; lots of HD DVD owners still singing the praises of their dead format.Originally posted by: Wreckage
I think this thread has served it's purpose. There is no format war anymore.
sigh, I don't think you realize how it must be equally annoying to hear the Blu-ray supports gloat. That said, I STILL think HD-DVD is superior to BRD in many ways (read: in deserving of praise). Just because HD-DVD lost the war does not indicate it to be the inferior format. Look at beta and vhs for proof of that.
These are the sales numbers since the beginning of the year.
01/06 463K
01/13 379K
01/20 241K
01/27 216K
02/03 199K
Makes you wonder who really won. 200K units a week wont cut the butter. Seems like the warner effect has had an opposite effect than intended. Should be interesting to see how the numbers fair for the next 6 months. I expect them to rebound, but they have a ways to go.
Originally posted by: JC86
Originally posted by: erwos
The Best Buy news may or may not be damning to HD-DVD. Depends on whether corporate made the decision on their own, or whether this is just a marketing stunt that the BR Group paid for. In the latter case, this is just hot air. In the former, it could be trouble, as it'll mean less and less HD-DVD stuff stocked.
Still, it's not good news for HD-DVD. One more studio defection, and it's basically over at this point.
Since most consumers take what BB tells them with a grain of salt anyways, I don't think it'd be that big of a deal. The Netflix announcement, however, is a much bigger score for the BR group. I wonder if the BR group cut them a deal for cheaper BR movies to stock in exchange for the exclusive agreement.
Originally posted by: Genx87
These are the sales numbers since the beginning of the year.
01/06 463K
01/13 379K
01/20 241K
01/27 216K
02/03 199K
Makes you wonder who really won. 200K units a week wont cut the butter. Seems like the warner effect has had an opposite effect than intended. Should be interesting to see how the numbers fair for the next 6 months. I expect them to rebound, but they have a ways to go.
Originally posted by: TheVrolok
Originally posted by: jpeyton
You'd be surprised at how many people are still in denial. Check out AVSForum or HighDefDigest Forum; lots of HD DVD owners still singing the praises of their dead format.Originally posted by: Wreckage
I think this thread has served it's purpose. There is no format war anymore.
sigh, I don't think you realize how it must be equally annoying to hear the Blu-ray supports gloat. That said, I STILL think HD-DVD is superior to BRD in many ways (read: in deserving of praise). Just because HD-DVD lost the war does not indicate it to be the inferior format. Look at beta and vhs for proof of that.
Originally posted by: cubby1223
Originally posted by: Genx87
These are the sales numbers since the beginning of the year.
01/06 463K
01/13 379K
01/20 241K
01/27 216K
02/03 199K
Makes you wonder who really won. 200K units a week wont cut the butter. Seems like the warner effect has had an opposite effect than intended. Should be interesting to see how the numbers fair for the next 6 months. I expect them to rebound, but they have a ways to go.
01/06 - Resident Evil / War / Shoot Em Up
01/13 - 3:10 to Yuma / Sunshine
01/20 - Good Luck Chuck / Mr. Woodcock
01/27 - Saw IV / The Game Plan
02/03 - Daddy Day Camp / The Invasion
I'm not understanding this "Warner effect" you think is in effect. I just see a lull in new releases. March 11 & 18 are when the next set of blockbusters are released.
Originally posted by: zinfamous
Originally posted by: TheVrolok
Originally posted by: jpeyton
You'd be surprised at how many people are still in denial. Check out AVSForum or HighDefDigest Forum; lots of HD DVD owners still singing the praises of their dead format.Originally posted by: Wreckage
I think this thread has served it's purpose. There is no format war anymore.
sigh, I don't think you realize how it must be equally annoying to hear the Blu-ray supports gloat. That said, I STILL think HD-DVD is superior to BRD in many ways (read: in deserving of praise). Just because HD-DVD lost the war does not indicate it to be the inferior format. Look at beta and vhs for proof of that.
I agree with you, but I wouldn't take jpeyton's comment as gloating. There really are die-hard consumers out there discussing strategies that HD DVD needs to take to recover and eventually win. It's sad, when Toshiba has clearly given up.
In many ways, HD DVD is more consumer friendly; but at this point, the absolute best thing for consumers is for it to die ASAP. The more companies that are involved in pushing resources into developing BD, the cheaper it will become.
I guess it's still a format war...but it's between BD and DVD now
What gets weird is when you look at what the DVD Forum really is. These are the companies who make the decisions: Hitachi, IBM, Industrial Technology Research Institute, Intel, LG, Matsushita (Panasonic), Microsoft, Mitsubishi, NEC, Pioneer, Philips, Samsung, Sanyo, Sharp, Sony, Thomson, Toshiba, Victor, Walt Disney, Warner Bros.Originally posted by: destrekor
personally, Toshiba and the DVD Forum seem to have too much pride to just call it quits.
I Agree. I too believe dvd & Blu-ray will co-exist for a long time. Eventually Blu-ray will be cheap, and enough turnover in dvd player lifespans that dvd will be phased out, but I don't see any urgency for the industry to make that push anytime soon.Originally posted by: destrekor
I don't think it'll ever be a 'war' between BD and DVD, they will co-exist for as long as there is a split between HD and non-HD televisions. And if all studios produce on both, then eventually overall volume sales of DVD and BD will produce the same profits as if it were one format only. Just, one type of disc for those with HDTV's and a corresponding BD player... and the other type of disc for those without the HD equipment.Originally posted by: zinfamous
I guess it's still a format war...but it's between BD and DVD now
Originally posted by: cubby1223
Originally posted by: Genx87
These are the sales numbers since the beginning of the year.
01/06 463K
01/13 379K
01/20 241K
01/27 216K
02/03 199K
Makes you wonder who really won. 200K units a week wont cut the butter. Seems like the warner effect has had an opposite effect than intended. Should be interesting to see how the numbers fair for the next 6 months. I expect them to rebound, but they have a ways to go.
01/06 - Resident Evil / War / Shoot Em Up
01/13 - 3:10 to Yuma / Sunshine
01/20 - Good Luck Chuck / Mr. Woodcock
01/27 - Saw IV / The Game Plan
02/03 - Daddy Day Camp / The Invasion
I'm not understanding this "Warner effect" you think is in effect. I just see a lull in new releases. March 11 & 18 are when the next set of blockbusters are released.
Originally posted by: Genx87
Dropping by over 50% is more than a lull. The effect I am refering to is everybody grabbing a BluRay player because Warner went Blu. When did Warner release their info? Seems like every week since there has been a large dropoff in movie sales. And with all of the new blu ray players in the field, you would think it could sustain itself a little better in between big releases.
Originally posted by: cubby1223
Originally posted by: cubby1223
Originally posted by: Genx87
These are the sales numbers since the beginning of the year.
01/06 463K
01/13 379K
01/20 241K
01/27 216K
02/03 199K
Makes you wonder who really won. 200K units a week wont cut the butter. Seems like the warner effect has had an opposite effect than intended. Should be interesting to see how the numbers fair for the next 6 months. I expect them to rebound, but they have a ways to go.
01/06 - Resident Evil / War / Shoot Em Up
01/13 - 3:10 to Yuma / Sunshine
01/20 - Good Luck Chuck / Mr. Woodcock
01/27 - Saw IV / The Game Plan
02/03 - Daddy Day Camp / The Invasion
I'm not understanding this "Warner effect" you think is in effect. I just see a lull in new releases. March 11 & 18 are when the next set of blockbusters are released.
Originally posted by: Genx87
Dropping by over 50% is more than a lull. The effect I am refering to is everybody grabbing a BluRay player because Warner went Blu. When did Warner release their info? Seems like every week since there has been a large dropoff in movie sales. And with all of the new blu ray players in the field, you would think it could sustain itself a little better in between big releases.
No offense, but I'm beginning to see why you like HD DVD so much.
Let's take a peek over at the dvd sales numbers:
Week ending 01/27, top 10 titles sold 2.8m
Week ending 02/03, top 10 titles sold 1.5m
Blu-ray sales dropped 8% between those two weeks, dvd sales dropped 46%!!!!!! Oh My God, what the Hell is happening to DVD sales???!!! Not only did Warner Kill HDM, They must have ALSO Killed DVD!!!
http://www.the-numbers.com/dvd...ekly/2008/20080127.php
http://www.the-numbers.com/dvd...ekly/2008/20080203.php
Actually, just because it's fun, top 10 dvd sales:
01/06 - 3.79m
01/13 - 2.6m
01/20 - 2.4m
01/27 - 2.8m
02/03 - 1.51m
Explain to me the drop in dvd sales. DVD dropped 60% with an additional popular dvd only release, Family Guy's Blue Harvest, *significantly* boosting mid-January sales. Blu-ray dropped just 57% with fewer new releases. The best explanation is, this is January, not December. Martin Luther King Jr. Day and St. Valentine's Day are not commonly accompanied with purchases of new electronic equipment.