- Apr 11, 2001
I'm not saying that Elite Dangerous isn't a good or bad game, nor am I saying that SC is or isn't a scam.. I am saying though that the logic that just because people gave money to SC means that ED didn't get the money is a fallacy. There's no proof nor anyway to prove that the money would have gone there if SC didn't exist.It isn't a logical fallacy. Elite dangerous and SC are basically the same game, but one is well planned and funtional, and the other is a stillborn clusterF
As far as the scam parts of SC.. I do find it interesting that it's really split on if it is or isn't. I tend to think it is based upon the fact it's so late and they're continuing to sell jpegs of ships without including when they'll be ready. I can't deny though that people like TechboyJK are really happy with what they have. I get the impression that even if SC shut down today people like TechboyJK would still feel they got their moneys worth. It's hard to call that a scam. I guess it really depends on what you expect out of it and what you get.