Should we adopt the regulations of Japan for purchasing a gun?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Would enacting these rules infringe upon 2A rights?


  • Total voters
    12

K1052

Elite Member
Aug 21, 2003
52,156
45,238
136
I have several suppressors. The process to obtain a suppressor is onerous as hell, the $205 fee (soon to be removed in 01-01-2026) the ATF paperwork, background check, fingerprinting, and wait times are extreme for an item that doesn't actually contribute to more crime. If an AR or a pistol registration was like that it would really help slow down the number of instant gun buying to go out and commit a crime inho.

I think the friction in obtaining NFA items is part of what makes them rarely used in crimes. (especially the more $ they are). SBRs being a thing while everybody is running "braces" on AR pistols is kinda absurd though. I don't really have an interest in suppressors especially given the additional lead exposure concerns.
 

nakedfrog

No Lifer
Apr 3, 2001
62,324
18,216
136
California has a 10 day waiting period which seems sufficient. Something I'd like to see is a mandatory state sponsored gun safety training course complete with range live fire that has to be completed (including a test at the end) before you can purchase/own anything at all.
Seems to be the direction WA is headed, it's already a 10 business day waiting period before you can pick up a firearm, and there's a training requirement but due to the current law there's a free online presentation you can go through fairly quickly that fulfills the requirement. They're instituting licensing now and trying to turn the training into an actual training environment.
 

Muse

Lifer
Jul 11, 2001
40,599
10,037
136
I am in favor of stricter regulations for obtaining a firearm. Depending on the state though, some are quite strict already. In Wisconsin to buy a pistol you have to have a background check, be of a certain age, and answer and fill out the required forms and we are a less strict state than NY or Cali. The problem is that you can simply lie on the forms (Hunter Biden anyone?) get the gun that same day, and go use it for something. The latest mass shooter gave plenty of warning signs that he was off, yet no one was able to stop the process for him. I tend to agree that stricter and more onerous regulations just make it harder for the law abiding folks over the criminals ability to get a gun. However quite a percentage of recent mass shootings the perp had to obtain the gun legally, and how do you catch a nutjob that can act normally up until the time he doesn't? In so many instances when these things happen even their closest friends say things like "he was the nicest guy, we had no idea he would do this"" etc.

Regardless any steps that can be done to help, such as a 14 day waiting period perhaps, thorough background checks, can only help.
All this shit misses the fact that gun ownership for noone makes it hard to get a gun. It's not an overnight solution BUT IT IS A SOLUTION EVENTUALLY. If it's illegal to possess a gun, there will be less and less guns "out there." Patience is required. And FUCK THE 2ND AMENDMENT. That filthy rag should be stomped into the muddy soil with a twisting boot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fenixgoon

nOOky

Diamond Member
Aug 17, 2004
3,241
2,297
136
All this shit misses the fact that gun ownership for noone makes it hard to get a gun. It's not an overnight solution BUT IT IS A SOLUTION EVENTUALLY. If it's illegal to possess a gun, there will be less and less guns "out there." Patience is required. And FUCK THE 2ND AMENDMENT. That filthy rag should be stomped into the muddy soil with a twisting boot.
Are you forgetting the 300 million guns or so currently in circulation that can be bought or sold or stolen? Those guns will never be taken away from anyone, don't think they will or can be lol. Americans will never allow guns to be banned, look for other solutions like mental health or social media or making parents actually parent as those are more likely.
 

Muse

Lifer
Jul 11, 2001
40,599
10,037
136
Are you forgetting the 300 million guns or so currently in circulation that can be bought or sold or stolen? Those guns will never be taken away from anyone, don't think they will or can be lol. Americans will never allow guns to be banned, look for other solutions like mental health or social media or making parents actually parent as those are more likely.
Are you forgetting the 300 million guns or so currently in circulation...
Circulation! Ha! They won't circulate if they are jail-bait.

Typical myopia, nOOky. If it's illegal to own a gun people are just going to hang on to their jail-bait, huh? Sure. Let me show you my gun... uh, don't tell anybody. When's the last time you fired it? Uh, I don't dare because (1) there are no firing ranges anymore, (2) Monitors pick up gun shots and are cop-bait.

Can't sell your gun legally and who the fuck would want one? What are they gonna do with it? Fend off an intruder? Jail bait, mate.

I said it would take a long time, but guns would disappear. It's just in your addled head that 300 million guns are permanent fixtures of American life IF THEY ARE OUTLAWED. Hey, live your gun fantasy, man. Best of luck with it, you're gonna need it.
 

nOOky

Diamond Member
Aug 17, 2004
3,241
2,297
136
Circulation! Ha! They won't circulate if they are jail-bait.

Typical myopia, nOOky. If it's illegal to own a gun people are just going to hang on to their jail-bait, huh? Sure. Let me show you my gun... uh, don't tell anybody. When's the last time you fired it? Uh, I don't dare because (1) there are no firing ranges anymore, (2) Monitors pick up gun shots and are cop-bait.

Can't sell your gun legally and who the fuck would want one? What are they gonna do with it? Fend off an intruder? Jail bait, mate.

I said it would take a long time, but guns would disappear. It's just in your addled head that 300 million guns are permanent fixtures of American life IF THEY ARE OUTLAWED. Hey, live your gun fantasy, man. Best of luck with it, you're gonna need it.

Wow you went off the rails fairly quickly there lol. Laughing at me saying I have myopia concerning existing guns? Let me state to you something that might not be obvious to you. The US will never, ever, ever, never ban guns, and existing owners will never be criminals for keeping their existing ones. I'm not saying that because I wish it to be so, I'm saying that because that is just the reality of the situation. If you can't wrap your head around that, and you think that eventually they will all be collected and destroyed and the US will be gun less, keep on keeping on I guess. If you think otherwise good luck with that, you need to focus on solutions that may actually help. Sorry for the harsh reality :( but blaming me personally for your desires is fine, I have strong shoulders and I can take it.
 
Last edited:

Muse

Lifer
Jul 11, 2001
40,599
10,037
136
Wow you went off the rails fairly quickly there lol. Laughing at me saying I have myopia concerning existing guns? Let me state to you something that might not be obvious to you. The US will never, ever, ever, never ban guns, and existing owners will never be criminals for keeping their existing ones. I'm not saying that because I wish it to be so, I'm saying that because that is just the reality of the situation. If you can't wrap your head around that, and you think that eventually they will all be collected and destroyed and the US will be gun less, keep on keeping on I guess. If you think otherwise good luck with that, you need to focus on solutions that may actually help. Sorry for the harsh reality :( but blaming me personally for your desires is fine, I have strong shoulders and I can take it.
Did I say it would happen? You should analyze your reading skills.

"There is absolutely no inevitability as long as there is a willingness to contemplate what is happening." - The Medium is the Massage, Marshall McCluhan
 

nOOky

Diamond Member
Aug 17, 2004
3,241
2,297
136
Did I say it would happen? You should analyze your reading skills.

"There is absolutely no inevitability as long as there is a willingness to contemplate what is happening." - The Medium is the Massage, Marshall McCluhan

My point is valid regardless, but it doesn't matter as it will never happen and I explained that to you, yet you are still kind of a whiner. If that's all you got after I spanked your stupid ass maybe just keep quiet and move along it will soon be forgotten.