Should I lie about smoking pot?

Page 7 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Throckmorton

Lifer
Aug 23, 2007
16,829
3
0
Originally posted by: njdevilsfan87
I had to get this topic back up.

I was just denied a clearance because I was in the same situation as the OP (for people wondering how, new policy for summer interns implemented two months ago)

So you know, I wasn't too worried. The general consensus from this topic, and from people I asked in real life - people were honest about it on their clearance forms, passed their drug tests, and still were granted security clearance. So I wasn't worried. Yesterday, I find out the internship I should have been starting in maybe a week or two, was no longer available to me, because I became ineligible due to admitting the use of a controlled substance within the past 12 months.

So I'm still very frustrated, and upset over this. I've been getting headaches just from thinking about it too much.

I worked my ass off in school the past year... getting a single B+ all year, with the rest As. I got my cumulative GPA in mechanical engineering up to a 3.5, putting myself in decent to position to land what I felt would have been a meaningful summer internship. Now I'm sitting here, wondering what am I going to do this summer? I don't think there is absolutely any way I could work full-time at a lame job like work in a retail store (no offense to anyone that does, but I had something a lot better lined up, and I can't help but to feel too much potential being wasted now).

My only option right now may be to work volunteer in university research, and maybe work some lame job part time to pay for commute, and allow for a bit of a pocket change to hold me over until I graduate next year.

I cannot stand the feeling of disappointment and personal failure. It's one of the worst feelings in the world to me.

Two months. Everyone before that, they were probably fine. I mean, what exactly does having experimented with pot have to do with my ability to be a useful person? I have blatant proof in my transcript that it did absolutely nothing. I cannot help but to believe that this policy just is not fair. *I did my part*. I did well in school, made good professor references. Had good work experience. I did my part.

Senior Mechanical Engineer? Doesn't matter...
Got a 4.0 last semester? Doesn't matter...
Worked DoD last summer? Doesn't matter...

This really hurts... Everything I worked for, everything that defined me... did not matter. (But it will 10 months from now...) Because I smoked pot 2 months ago.

I was actually going to shred the notice I received in the mail shortly after I received it... but I'm going to keep around as a personal reminder... not just for the obvious, but to avoid ever feeling like this again.


That's BS that they denied you the internship. Even the FBI only excludes you for marijuana use within the past 6 months.

Politics driven policy = LOSE
 

Fenixgoon

Lifer
Jun 30, 2003
33,265
12,824
136
Originally posted by: njdevilsfan87

This really hurts... Everything I worked for, everything that defined me... did not matter. (But it will 10 months from now...) Because I smoked pot 2 months ago.

which is why it's a good idea not to drugs ever in the first place.

people might think "oh well, so i did drugs a little... so what?" only to have it bite them in the ass in the future. steer clear of drugs ftw.

i don't mean to be condescending and say "i told you so" or something similar in nature.. just pointing out that in the DoD and related business, it pays to be squeaky clean, even though many peers might see you as boring/loser/whatever.
 

gentobu

Golden Member
Jul 6, 2001
1,546
0
0
Originally posted by: JLee
Originally posted by: gentobu
You should lie. They really won't be able to find out as long as you don't have a record. Just be cool, look the interviewer straight in the eye and say "No sir, I have never done any kind of drugs in my life". Everything will be fine dude. Don't worry about it. Just follow my advice and you'll have a TS/SCI in no time.

Just hope you never take a poly, and get asked if you've ever lied to get a job/clearance..

Polys are easy to defeat. I've been polygraphed many times and I've intentionally lied just to see if I could beat it. And I did every single time. I strongly recommend that the OP lie, because it will make him look better than someone who willingly admits to smoking pot. Think about it, who would you hire--someone who you know smokes pot, or someone who has never done drugs in his whole life? Makes sense now doesn't it.
 

Jawo

Diamond Member
Jun 15, 2005
4,125
0
0
On a govt form its better to tell the truth than perjure yourself! (then the application WILL be trashed). Its more of an honesty question if anything..........
 

njdevilsfan87

Platinum Member
Apr 19, 2007
2,342
265
126
people might think "oh well, so i did drugs a little... so what?" only to have it bite them in the ass in the future. steer clear of drugs ftw.

i don't mean to be condescending and say "i told you so" or something similar in nature.. just pointing out that in the DoD and related business, it pays to be squeaky clean, even though many peers might see you as boring/loser/whatever.

Amen to that. I'm not going to argue to that. It's something I learned the hard way. Only thing I can do to make myself useful is to make myself heard. Anyone I know who is more a regular user... (and what hurts me is I *barely* ever used it) I'm going to tell them, stop... or take the chance. It's just not worth it.

I just can't believe the consequences of it... never did I see this fore coming.
 

Throckmorton

Lifer
Aug 23, 2007
16,829
3
0
Originally posted by: njdevilsfan87
people might think "oh well, so i did drugs a little... so what?" only to have it bite them in the ass in the future. steer clear of drugs ftw.

i don't mean to be condescending and say "i told you so" or something similar in nature.. just pointing out that in the DoD and related business, it pays to be squeaky clean, even though many peers might see you as boring/loser/whatever.

Amen to that. I'm not going to argue to that. It's something I learned the hard way. Only thing I can do to make myself useful is to make myself heard. Anyone I know who is more a regular user... (and what hurts me is I *barely* ever used it) I'm going to tell them, stop... or take the chance. It's just not worth it.

I just can't believe the consequences of it... never did I see this fore coming.

Get another internship, or job, or whatever. Most government agencies aren't stupid.
 

jlee

Lifer
Sep 12, 2001
48,518
223
106
Originally posted by: gentobu
Originally posted by: JLee
Originally posted by: gentobu
You should lie. They really won't be able to find out as long as you don't have a record. Just be cool, look the interviewer straight in the eye and say "No sir, I have never done any kind of drugs in my life". Everything will be fine dude. Don't worry about it. Just follow my advice and you'll have a TS/SCI in no time.

Just hope you never take a poly, and get asked if you've ever lied to get a job/clearance..

Polys are easy to defeat. I've been polygraphed many times and I've intentionally lied just to see if I could beat it. And I did every single time. I strongly recommend that the OP lie, because it will make him look better than someone who willingly admits to smoking pot. Think about it, who would you hire--someone who you know smokes pot, or someone who has never done drugs in his whole life? Makes sense now doesn't it.

Who would you rather hire? Someone who's honest, or someone who lies?

Maybe things are different in your profession, but integrity is important in mine.
 

gentobu

Golden Member
Jul 6, 2001
1,546
0
0
Originally posted by: JLee
Originally posted by: gentobu
Originally posted by: JLee
Originally posted by: gentobu
You should lie. They really won't be able to find out as long as you don't have a record. Just be cool, look the interviewer straight in the eye and say "No sir, I have never done any kind of drugs in my life". Everything will be fine dude. Don't worry about it. Just follow my advice and you'll have a TS/SCI in no time.

Just hope you never take a poly, and get asked if you've ever lied to get a job/clearance..

Polys are easy to defeat. I've been polygraphed many times and I've intentionally lied just to see if I could beat it. And I did every single time. I strongly recommend that the OP lie, because it will make him look better than someone who willingly admits to smoking pot. Think about it, who would you hire--someone who you know smokes pot, or someone who has never done drugs in his whole life? Makes sense now doesn't it.

Who would you rather hire? Someone who's honest, or someone who lies?

Maybe things are different in your profession, but integrity is important in mine.

I would rather hire someone who can lie and get away with it. In my profession that counts for a lot.
 

jlee

Lifer
Sep 12, 2001
48,518
223
106
Originally posted by: gentobu
Originally posted by: JLee
Originally posted by: gentobu
Originally posted by: JLee
Originally posted by: gentobu
You should lie. They really won't be able to find out as long as you don't have a record. Just be cool, look the interviewer straight in the eye and say "No sir, I have never done any kind of drugs in my life". Everything will be fine dude. Don't worry about it. Just follow my advice and you'll have a TS/SCI in no time.

Just hope you never take a poly, and get asked if you've ever lied to get a job/clearance..

Polys are easy to defeat. I've been polygraphed many times and I've intentionally lied just to see if I could beat it. And I did every single time. I strongly recommend that the OP lie, because it will make him look better than someone who willingly admits to smoking pot. Think about it, who would you hire--someone who you know smokes pot, or someone who has never done drugs in his whole life? Makes sense now doesn't it.

Who would you rather hire? Someone who's honest, or someone who lies?

Maybe things are different in your profession, but integrity is important in mine.

I would rather hire someone who can lie and get away with it. In my profession that counts for a lot.

And therein lies the difference between us.
 

m1ldslide1

Platinum Member
Feb 20, 2006
2,321
0
0
Originally posted by: njdevilsfan87
I had to get this topic back up.

I was just denied a clearance because I was in the same situation as the OP (for people wondering how, new policy for summer interns implemented two months ago)

...

I was actually going to shred the notice I received in the mail shortly after I received it... but I'm going to keep around as a personal reminder... not just for the obvious, but to avoid ever feeling like this again.

Sorry to hear that man. I've had a similar experience or two, and it is a terrible feeling. Don't worry though - it'll suck in the short term, but you'll recover and it'll be a distant memory before you know it.
 

nakedfrog

No Lifer
Apr 3, 2001
62,653
18,751
136
Originally posted by: gentobu
Originally posted by: JLee
Originally posted by: gentobu
You should lie. They really won't be able to find out as long as you don't have a record. Just be cool, look the interviewer straight in the eye and say "No sir, I have never done any kind of drugs in my life". Everything will be fine dude. Don't worry about it. Just follow my advice and you'll have a TS/SCI in no time.

Just hope you never take a poly, and get asked if you've ever lied to get a job/clearance..

Polys are easy to defeat. I've been polygraphed many times and I've intentionally lied just to see if I could beat it. And I did every single time. I strongly recommend that the OP lie, because it will make him look better than someone who willingly admits to smoking pot. Think about it, who would you hire--someone who you know smokes pot, or someone who has never done drugs in his whole life? Makes sense now doesn't it.

It wouldn't make any difference to me.
 

BeauJangles

Lifer
Aug 26, 2001
13,941
1
0
When applying for something similar, I was denied for using drugs within 12 months of my application. I had to wait 3 years to apply again.
 

BrownTown

Diamond Member
Dec 1, 2005
5,314
1
0
I just received unescorted access to a nuclear plant last week, so I have recent experience with this stuff, they made me take a psychological evaluation and I took 3 drug tests and a breathalyser, and they called up about 10 different people I know, brought up my credit history, plus all the other stuff that you normally have like sending your fingerprints to the FBI and stuff. And I dunno about ya'lls experiences, but just statistically speaking if you lie its highly unlikely they will ever know. Fortunately I don't do drugs so I had no problem with that, but they ask you some of these psychological questions and all and sometimes its just easier to say "I love my mother" then have to go to a shrink for an hour and explain why you have good reasons not to like her etc.

I dunno, some of it is BS imo, it wouldn't be all that hard to lie and I'm sure tons of people do and nobody ever knows. Thats why they have the additional lines of defenses like the metal detectors and the bomb detectors and the radiation detectors and the scan cards and the fingerprint scanners etc that you have to go threw everytime you go into the plant. And even with that, you can't get into the control room without a shit ton more screenings on top. Still, of the 40 people who started the same time I did only 1 of them was rejected (for not paying child support), so it doesn't seem like all that many people are screened out (or else they just don't apply to begin with)
 

rasczak

Lifer
Jan 29, 2005
10,437
23
81
Originally posted by: jpeyton
Originally posted by: nkgreen
Should I lie about smoking pot?
Yes, unless you want them to trash your clearance request immediately.

that's a negative. You do NOT want to lie on a clearance form at all. It's a step process, they maky not check up on it for your "secret" clearance, but if you try to get your "top" secret, they will bug every person you've had contact with by 20 degrees. IUf one of those people should be someone that rats you out, you will lose your clearance and your job. It's better to be upfront about any and everything rather than have them find out later that you lied about one seemingly inconsequential indiscretion.

Oh and btw, you have now made this information public, so if they wanted to they could find it here. So now, you've pretty much put yourself in a box and need to tell the truth about smoking pot.

Originally posted by: everman
Originally posted by: nkgreen

The security clearance is secret.

Not anymore

be careful with what you disclose. You shouldn't be disclosing information like this over a public forum. you have actually placed yourself in situation where someone can possibly blackmail you. I know it sounds a bit paranoid, but you should never ever let anyone know what type of clearance you've got or if youre trying to obtain one. Just hope noone ever comes across this thread that may be interviewing you for any higher clearances.
 

rasczak

Lifer
Jan 29, 2005
10,437
23
81
Originally posted by: nakedfrog
Originally posted by: biggestmuff
Originally posted by: nakedfrog
Originally posted by: alkemyst
not talking just that have smoked, but flat out admitted to it on the interview.

You have to take the polygraph to get a TS, so are you thinking I know multiple people that can beat a poly?

No, you don't. You only have to have it, in addition to the clearance, if the job requires it.

Well, to get the TS to work in the shop I worked in you did.

That's TS/SCI w/lifestyle polygraph. If my memory servers me correctly.
 

Muse

Lifer
Jul 11, 2001
40,841
10,209
136
Originally posted by: Viper GTS
So I guess this thread brings up another question: Are they more suspicious of "No" answers than "Yes" answers?

I can honestly say I've never done any illegal drugs, save for underage alcohol + tobacco. No pot, nothing. If my friends are any indication of most people my age I'm in a distinct minority. Wonder if anyone would believe me if I ever needed a security clearance.

Viper GTS

Why not? I believe you.

OP, I read most of the thread. Just tell them the truth. You have less to lose that way and your conscience will be clear whatever happens.
 

Locut0s

Lifer
Nov 28, 2001
22,205
44
91
Someone mentioned SF 86 above so I did a google and pulled up the PDF. Man that is a lot of detail to have to fill out my hand hurts just looking at the length of it, luckily I'm not interested in military service hehe (Canadian also). If that's the form your filling out looks like here's the relevant section:

"
The following questions pertain to the illegal use of drugs or drug activity. You are required to answer the questions fully and truthfully, and your failure to do so could be grounds for an adverse employment decision or action against you, but neither your truthful responses nor information derived from your responses will be used as evidence against you in any subsequent criminal proceeding.
"

So basically you aren't going to get into trouble for telling the truth but could potentially get into deep sh!t for not. I'd tell the truth.

However I would not tell the truth about the following section if the truthful answer is yes. LOL ;) :

"
(A)
Have you ever been an officer or a member or made a contribution to an organization dedicated to the violent overthrow of the United States Government and which engages in illegal activities to that end, knowing that the organization engages in such activities with the specific intent to further such activities?

(B)
Have you ever knowingly engaged in any acts or activities designed to overthrow the United States Government by force?

If you answered "Yes" to a or b, explain in the space below.
"

http://usmilitary.about.com/library/pdf/sf86.pdf
 

gentobu

Golden Member
Jul 6, 2001
1,546
0
0
Originally posted by: Locut0s
Someone mentioned SF 86 above so I did a google and pulled up the PDF. Man that is a lot of detail to have to fill out my hand hurts just looking at the length of it, luckily I'm not interested in military service hehe (Canadian also). If that's the form your filling out looks like here's the relevant section:

"
The following questions pertain to the illegal use of drugs or drug activity. You are required to answer the questions fully and truthfully, and your failure to do so could be grounds for an adverse employment decision or action against you, but neither your truthful responses nor information derived from your responses will be used as evidence against you in any subsequent criminal proceeding.
"

So basically you aren't going to get into trouble for telling the truth but could potentially get into deep sh!t for not. I'd tell the truth.

However I would not tell the truth about the following section if the truthful answer is yes. LOL ;) :

"
(A)
Have you ever been an officer or a member or made a contribution to an organization dedicated to the violent overthrow of the United States Government and which engages in illegal activities to that end, knowing that the organization engages in such activities with the specific intent to further such activities?

(B)
Have you ever knowingly engaged in any acts or activities designed to overthrow the United States Government by force?

If you answered "Yes" to a or b, explain in the space below.
"

http://usmilitary.about.com/library/pdf/sf86.pdf

For these questions you should answer 'yes' if you want to be in the CIA. Basically they are recruiting questions. They let the Agency know who has opportunity and access to information about these groups.
 

Locut0s

Lifer
Nov 28, 2001
22,205
44
91
Originally posted by: gentobu
Originally posted by: Locut0s
Someone mentioned SF 86 above so I did a google and pulled up the PDF. Man that is a lot of detail to have to fill out my hand hurts just looking at the length of it, luckily I'm not interested in military service hehe (Canadian also). If that's the form your filling out looks like here's the relevant section:

"
The following questions pertain to the illegal use of drugs or drug activity. You are required to answer the questions fully and truthfully, and your failure to do so could be grounds for an adverse employment decision or action against you, but neither your truthful responses nor information derived from your responses will be used as evidence against you in any subsequent criminal proceeding.
"

So basically you aren't going to get into trouble for telling the truth but could potentially get into deep sh!t for not. I'd tell the truth.

However I would not tell the truth about the following section if the truthful answer is yes. LOL ;) :

"
(A)
Have you ever been an officer or a member or made a contribution to an organization dedicated to the violent overthrow of the United States Government and which engages in illegal activities to that end, knowing that the organization engages in such activities with the specific intent to further such activities?

(B)
Have you ever knowingly engaged in any acts or activities designed to overthrow the United States Government by force?

If you answered "Yes" to a or b, explain in the space below.
"

http://usmilitary.about.com/library/pdf/sf86.pdf

For these questions you should answer 'yes' if you want to be in the CIA. Basically they are recruiting questions. They let the Agency know who has opportunity and access to information about these groups.

Hmm guess I never thought about it really, makes sense. Of course I'm sure if you answer yes you'd some under some REALLY heavy scrutiny before getting in.