She Came to America to Learn

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Gryz

Golden Member
Aug 28, 2010
1,551
204
106
describe to me how MY guns here in MY house are a threat to any kid anywhere.
This is not about you.
Some things require a collaborative effort.
You know: doing things together.
That's a concept that's lost in America. The only thing that counts in American society and American culture is: "ME!".

I live in a country were nobody has a gun. Only policemen have guns (and the military). And the policemen don't even always wear their guns. And they hardly use them. Does that mean we have no guns at all in society ? Nope, of course not. Hardcore organized crime has guns. But your average thug in the streets does not. Illegal guns are expensive. And kids can't bring their dad's gun to school when they are pissed off. And because there are hardly any guns in my country, nobody is actually afraid of guns. Our policemen never shoot people because they are scared. We don't have people shooting at other people just for ringing their doorbell. I live in an civilized country. And everyone in my country understands that you can't live peacefully when you have a shitload of guns around.

It's a really simple concept.
 

ivwshane

Lifer
May 15, 2000
33,522
17,030
136
This is not about you.
Some things require a collaborative effort.
You know: doing things together.
That's a concept that's lost in America. The only thing that counts in American society and American culture is: "ME!".

I live in a country were nobody has a gun. Only policemen have guns (and the military). And the policemen don't even always wear their guns. And they hardly use them. Does that mean we have no guns at all in society ? Nope, of course not. Hardcore organized crime has guns. But your average thug in the streets does not. Illegal guns are expensive. And kids can't bring their dad's gun to school when they are pissed off. And because there are hardly any guns in my country, nobody is actually afraid of guns. Our policemen never shoot people because they are scared. We don't have people shooting at other people just for ringing their doorbell. I live in an civilized country. And everyone in my country understands that you can't live peacefully when you have a shitload of guns around.

It's a really simple concept.

I guarantee you the guy is a baby boomer. The only thing they know is "me", team work is a foreign concept to them. Its a fyigm attitude.
 

dphantom

Diamond Member
Jan 14, 2005
4,763
327
126
I guarantee you the guy is a baby boomer. The only thing they know is "me", team work is a foreign concept to them. Its a fyigm attitude.
This country was founded on individual liberty and freedom. If you had taken any history classes, you would know that concept long predates "baby boomers".
 

Blackjack200

Lifer
May 28, 2007
15,995
1,688
126
And everyone in my country understands that you can't live peacefully when you have a shitload of guns around.

It's a really simple concept.

Bottom line. Americans completely reject the idea that they live in a society. "If I'm not shooting anyone with my gun, how can I possibly have any individual responsibility here?"

There won't be any progress on this issue or any other until Americans can accept that they are responsible to the communities they live in.

Edit: Exhibit A

This country was founded on individual liberty and freedom. If you had taken any history classes, you would know that concept long predates "baby boomers".
 

ivwshane

Lifer
May 15, 2000
33,522
17,030
136
This country was founded on individual liberty and freedom. If you had taken any history classes, you would know that concept long predates "baby boomers".

No it was actually founded on collectivism and as a society and government for and by the people. Individualism was a factor in that the freedom to be one led to a better society. Its why the revolution was over a lack of representation and not about not wanting to pay taxes. Its why the founding fathers made it so that no one person had all the power and influence and all branches of government were able to put a check on one another. Its why the constitution gave the state's the ability to defend itself and why the constitution gave the federal government (specifically the president) to call on state militias to protect this nation. Its why the constitution specifically states that the federal government has the right and duty to put down rebellions and insurrections.

Do you even fucking history brah?
 
  • Like
Reactions: DarthKyrie

dphantom

Diamond Member
Jan 14, 2005
4,763
327
126
Bottom line. Americans completely reject the idea that they live in a society. "If I'm not shooting anyone with my gun, how can I possibly have any individual responsibility here?"

There won't be any progress on this issue or any other until Americans can accept that they are responsible to the communities they live in.

Edit: Exhibit A
Individual liberty and freedom mandates an individual responsibility to society else society falls into anarchy. Everything from our inalienable rights to private property are based on an individual.

Having society dictate what our rights and responsibilities are means we have no rights and both our rights and responsibilities can change at the whim of the mob - or government.
 

dphantom

Diamond Member
Jan 14, 2005
4,763
327
126
No it was actually founded on collectivism and as a society and government for and by the people. Individualism was a factor in that the freedom to be one led to a better society. Its why the revolution was over a lack of representation and not about not wanting to pay taxes. Its why the founding fathers made it so that no one person had all the power and influence and all branches of government were able to put a check on one another. Its why the constitution gave the state's the ability to defend itself and why the constitution gave the federal government (specifically the president) to call on state militias to protect this nation. Its why the constitution specifically states that the federal government has the right and duty to put down rebellions and insurrections.

Do you even fucking history brah?
individualism was the key factor. not sure how you are skewing collectivism to get it to mean what you say.
 

Paratus

Lifer
Jun 4, 2004
17,643
15,830
146
Since one of the weapons he had with him was a bomb using carbon dioxide, evidently we need to ban both guns and air.

All "explosive devices" appeared to be non-functional based on one story I read.
Yup
According to the police on local news, none of the ‘devices’ were actually explosive. They were just a collection of pressure cookers, digital clocks and nails but no explosives.

Look how dumb you are: all of the casualties were shooting victims so congratulations on destroying your own argument.

I like how Glenn specifically said ban air instead of ban CO2. Got to keep those climate change denier bonafides. :D
 

ivwshane

Lifer
May 15, 2000
33,522
17,030
136
Individual liberty and freedom mandates an individual responsibility to society else society falls into anarchy. Everything from our inalienable rights to private property are based on an individual.

Having society dictate what our rights and responsibilities are means we have no rights and both our rights and responsibilities can change at the whim of the mob - or government.


Lol! I love when you dumb asses own yourselves.

Its kind of hard to be an individual and enjoy freedom when you have a responsibility to other people!
 

ivwshane

Lifer
May 15, 2000
33,522
17,030
136
and if all else fails, lead with the personal insults.

Actually I didn't lead with it. I countered your point and then I insulted you. You then made my point and proved my insult to be correct. Good job moron!
 
Last edited:

Blackjack200

Lifer
May 28, 2007
15,995
1,688
126
Individual liberty and freedom mandates an individual responsibility to society else society falls into anarchy. Everything from our inalienable rights to private property are based on an individual.

Having society dictate what our rights and responsibilities are means we have no rights and both our rights and responsibilities can change at the whim of the mob - or government.

I'm was going to make a wise ass comment about tightening your fedora, but then I looked at your signature and wondered why I would ever engage with someone with an ode to Robert E. Lee. Pretty much says it all.
 

SheHateMe

Diamond Member
Jul 21, 2012
7,251
20
81
RIP to all the kids whose lives were snuffed out. I really fear for my 11 year old sister as she goes through primary school.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DarthKyrie

dphantom

Diamond Member
Jan 14, 2005
4,763
327
126
I'm was going to make a wise ass comment about tightening your fedora, but then I looked at your signature and wondered why I would ever engage with someone with an ode to Robert E. Lee. Pretty much says it all.
The quote is from the greatest progressive of the 20th century. I thought it humorous to add to my sig during the hoopla around tearing down Civil War statues by today's progressives
 

glenn1

Lifer
Sep 6, 2000
25,383
1,013
126
Bottom line. Americans completely reject the idea that they live in a society. "If I'm not shooting anyone with my gun, how can I possibly have any individual responsibility here?"

There won't be any progress on this issue or any other until Americans can accept that they are responsible to the communities they live in.

Edit: Exhibit A

Actually we work under the presumption that you're free to exercise your rights until they actually (and not theoretically) infringe on another's so your quoted formulation with bolded bits about individual responsibility is 100% accurate. You're not made the slightest bit safer or more "living in society" by restricting the rights of the law abiding to guns than you are to restricting speech for everyone to prevent a few dozen neo-Nazis from saying something bad about Jews. I have no personally use or desire for neo-Nazis or AK-47s but think we're a better and freer society because we have a nation that allows damn near anything including what I don't like or want myself. I'll take the risk of a "dangerous" society filled with large sodas, Happy Meals in plastic non-biodegradeable bags, assault rifles, same-sex marriage, transsexuals in bathrooms, GMO foods, neo-nazis and Klansmen and every other possible "risk" you can think of over the "safe" and antiseptic world you would create where our freedoms were limited to the handful of things that didn't scare you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: IJTSSG

UglyCasanova

Lifer
Mar 25, 2001
19,275
1,361
126
She Came to America to Learn


From Pakistan

There are an estimated 20 million firearms in public ownership in Pakistan (both legal and illegal), of which 7 million are registered among the country's population of over 180 million.[9] The rate of private gun ownership is 11.6 firearms per 100 people.[10] In a comparison of the number of privately owned guns in 178 countries, Pakistan ranks at No.6.[11][12] As of 2009, the homicide rate is 7.3 per 100,000 population, higher than the United States at 5.0 per 100,000 population.
 

ivwshane

Lifer
May 15, 2000
33,522
17,030
136
Actually we work under the presumption that you're free to exercise your rights until they actually (and not theoretically) infringe on another's so your quoted formulation with bolded bits about individual responsibility is 100% accurate. You're not made the slightest bit safer or more "living in society" by restricting the rights of the law abiding to guns than you are to restricting speech for everyone to prevent a few dozen neo-Nazis from saying something bad about Jews. I have no personally use or desire for neo-Nazis or AK-47s but think we're a better and freer society because we have a nation that allows damn near anything including what I don't like or want myself. I'll take the risk of a "dangerous" society filled with large sodas, Happy Meals in plastic non-biodegradeable bags, assault rifles, same-sex marriage, transsexuals in bathrooms, GMO foods, neo-nazis and Klansmen and every other possible "risk" you can think of over the "safe" and antiseptic world you would create where our freedoms were limited to the handful of things that didn't scare you.

The key word being "infringe", as in people who have guns are more likely to infringe on the rights of others. Aka, the reason we have most laws. Laws aren't created because everyone is doing a particular thing that infringes on everyone's rights, they are created because some people/entities are infringing on some peoples rights.

I find it odd how guns simply don't follow protocol or standards like every other issue this country has ever had.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: DarthKyrie

UglyCasanova

Lifer
Mar 25, 2001
19,275
1,361
126
Its a tool that has very few uses and one of those primary uses is to infringe on peoples most basic right, the right to live.


It’s also a tool to prevent people from taking away your most basic human right. And heck some people even hunt with em! :beer: