He said that there was a short term benefit to Young but long term he couldn't learn an offense. A record like that isn't short term. Young also was leading the AFC in passer rating when his season was up with the Titans last year, while improving his passer rating each season.
I didn't put together your little story because it makes no sense and contradicts what he actually said.
it wasn't my story to put together, but I'm not surprised you're confused on that
also, a player winning games doesn't verify that they've learned an offense, it just means they won the game with whatever offense he did know how to execute
The goal in the NFL is to make it to and win the Superbowl. With a QB like VY or Tebow you can consistently win a bunch of games against the baddies and mediocres of the league, but you're going to have zero chance against the cream of the crop, you aren't going anywhere in the playoffs if you even get there. Its one thing to be a winning QB, its an entirely different level to be a Superbowl winning QB.
Anyone with any logical reasoning skills will realize that Tebow needs to improve as a passer (he's always below 50% ffs) for him to be a franchise player over the long haul and give his team a legitimate shot to make it to and win the Superbowl on a year to year basis. And given what little improvement (if any at all) we've seen from him throughout his college career and the better part of two NFL seasons, the prospect of him becoming a legitimate passer is not good at all.
This isn't the case of a green QB coming in and being initially overwhelmed by NFL speed and complexity, the dude just can't throw, its like he just doesn't understand the basic principal of leading a target.