Russia on brink of ... NOPE! Russia INVADES Ukraine!

Page 819 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Drach

Golden Member
Apr 24, 2022
1,029
1,648
106
Unfortunately I expect the Russians to pretty immediately start shelling Kherson and turn it into even more of a ruin than their occupation made it.

Won’t stop until they are defeated across all of Ukraine and a peace deal is reached.

I am guessing that next up is pressuring the coastal areas to the east of Kherson that do not require crossing a big river.
Always projecting doom and gloom even when Ukrainians are kicking serious ORC ass.We're all doomed.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leeea

K1052

Elite Member
Aug 21, 2003
46,044
33,089
136
Based on what I've seen it looks like the Ukrainians did not actually go after the withdrawal very hard at least in proximity to Kherson City. For their part the Russians didn't burn the place down on their way out. Might have been some battlefield agreement that took place.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leeea

RnR_au

Golden Member
Jun 6, 2021
1,709
4,158
106
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Leeea

Jaskalas

Lifer
Jun 23, 2004
33,442
7,506
136
I'd like Ukraine to get in range of the crimean bridge and finish putting holes in that monstrosity.

Even touching the Sea of Azov places the Kerch Bridge roughly twice the distance HIMARs can travel.
And Ukraine is nowhere near Azov.

My hope is that they can cut the land bridge, and once reaching water, they would have some means of reliably striking that bridge. But that is just a hope, predicated on yet another hefty requirement - removing Russia from well supplied and well fixed positions. No guarantee Ukraine can accomplish either through strength of arms. Or rather - we have not and will never give them the firepower needed to outright win. So pushing Russia out remains a very slow and very painful slog, paid for in Ukrainian blood.

If this is a contest of who will bleed out first, I am not confident that we have done enough to ensure a totally favorable outcome.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Number1 and Leeea

[DHT]Osiris

Lifer
Dec 15, 2015
14,107
12,209
146
  • Like
Reactions: Leeea

zinfamous

No Lifer
Jul 12, 2006
110,594
29,221
146
Wonder what the activity is like on the Kerch bridge, heading east?

IF RU forces fleeing this quickly back to Crimea and building new fortifications there, I imagine they are also fortifying along that one remaining rail line that is going to be necessary to keep Crimea supplied for the next several months; but I also don't see how they can do that as any kind of big retreat like that in this area is going to put Ukraine within range and complete control of wrecking their supply to Crimea.

Russia wouldn't even be able to hold out in Crimea for 6 months if that happens, I think.

Seems to me that this isn't so much a trap or plan to defend, but rather Putin desperately pulling back and preparing to "offer those concessions" to retain pre-February territory and please be nice to us, Ukraine and NATO but of course demand nothing of us because you do not deserve any more good will than we offer!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leeea

Indus

Diamond Member
May 11, 2002
9,940
6,531
136
Wonder what the activity is like on the Kerch bridge, heading east?

IF RU forces fleeing this quickly back to Crimea and building new fortifications there, I imagine they are also fortifying along that one remaining rail line that is going to be necessary to keep Crimea supplied for the next several months; but I also don't see how they can do that as any kind of big retreat like that in this area is going to put Ukraine within range and complete control of wrecking their supply to Crimea.

Russia wouldn't even be able to hold out in Crimea for 6 months if that happens, I think.

Seems to me that this isn't so much a trap or plan to defend, but rather Putin desperately pulling back and preparing to "offer those concessions" to retain pre-February territory and please be nice to us, Ukraine and NATO but of course demand nothing of us because you do not deserve any more good will than we offer!

Ideally the lines should go back to 2014 and Russia should be forced to sign a demilitarized zone within 100KM of Ukraine, NATO and the Black Sea but counting on Russia to obey treaties is like asking a wolf to be in charge of the chicken coop.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dank69 and Leeea

zinfamous

No Lifer
Jul 12, 2006
110,594
29,221
146
Ideally the lines should go back to 2014 and Russia should be forced to sign a demilitarized zone within 100KM of Ukraine, NATO and the Black Sea but counting on Russia to obey treaties is like asking a wolf to be in charge of the chicken coop.

Yes but part of the demand should be that Putin and all ministers responsible for planning and orchestration of the war turn themselves over to international law enforcement to stand trial for war crimes.

Yes, conditions of treaty for their suing for peace, would be for them to surrender unconditionally with their own bodies on the line. Obviously, they won't do it but that is the demand of signing a treaty that everyone already knows that they will never obey, so why not demand it as an unnegotiable condition?

I guess....the only possible concession to that could maybe be that Putin and ministers depart Russia and live in exile. Internationally-monitored free elections in RU with annual de-militarizing landmarks and industrial privitization, all state-owned company administrators fired and forced to re-apply for competence and criminal history checks, to qualify for international subsidies--which would only paid for through a fund created from captured Putin/Oligarch/RU sovereign wealth, from the leftovers of the first 95% of value given to Ukraine for rebuilding.

See, if Putin and friends can agree to "live in exile," then plenty of salty, battle-hardened UK special forces can spend some fun times over the next couple of years with training from SAS/Mossad/SEALs/etc and start their own hunt and peck squad to deal with that problem for good. No way in hell any of these shits would ever be safe under the protection of their various international "friends" that will certainly always have a price for turning on them. No question about it.

Let them live in exile and may they never be protected from justice for as long as they do so.
 
Last edited:

Dave_5k

Golden Member
May 23, 2017
1,583
3,094
136
Even touching the Sea of Azov places the Kerch Bridge roughly twice the distance HIMARs can travel.
And Ukraine is nowhere near Azov.
Ukraine really could use a few dozen or more ATACMS… would fix that range problem
 

Dave_5k

Golden Member
May 23, 2017
1,583
3,094
136
In less good news, Russia reportedly completely destroyed the power generation and substation in Kherson before retreating, which will be extremely difficult to replace for this winter, Ukraine and Western supporters were already scouring entire world supply to try to find replacements for the damaged stations in Kyiv and rest of Ukraine

(Edit: high voltage transformers don’t grow on trees… the last time I looked was quoted 52 week lead time)
 

Jaskalas

Lifer
Jun 23, 2004
33,442
7,506
136
In less good news, Russia reportedly completely destroyed the power generation and substation in Kherson before retreating, which will be extremely difficult to replace for this winter

Bombing the entirety of all civilian infrastructure, might, by itself, force Ukraine into a ceasefire.
I cannot imagine how they live without heat and electricity. Or even function as a government and a military.
And this devastation has only truly begun in the past month. Its effects will amplify over time, especially as Iranian Ballistic Missiles find their mark to keep piling on the pain and reaching the few remaining targets. I wonder how any civilization survives such bombardment. How many people will Russia kill via winter's frozen touch?
 

DaaQ

Golden Member
Dec 8, 2018
1,310
944
136
Bombing the entirety of all civilian infrastructure, might, by itself, force Ukraine into a ceasefire.
I cannot imagine how they live without heat and electricity. Or even function as a government and a military.
And this devastation has only truly begun in the past month. Its effects will amplify over time, especially as Iranian Ballistic Missiles find their mark to keep piling on the pain and reaching the few remaining targets. I wonder how any civilization survives such bombardment. How many people will Russia kill via winter's frozen touch?
They can still make fire, and most sensible people know how to make electricity. not on a city scale, but single homes should be able to weather the cold.
 
  • Like
Reactions: borosp1 and Drach

Dave_5k

Golden Member
May 23, 2017
1,583
3,094
136
Bombing the entirety of all civilian infrastructure, might, by itself, force Ukraine into a ceasefire.
I cannot imagine how they live without heat and electricity. Or even function as a government and a military.
And this devastation has only truly begun in the past month. Its effects will amplify over time, especially as Iranian Ballistic Missiles find their mark to keep piling on the pain and reaching the few remaining targets. I wonder how any civilization survives such bombardment. How many people will Russia kill via winter's frozen touch?
Putin is trying to exceed 7-figures of people massacred in Ukraine I think, so that he can start comparing more properly with his hero Stalin (circa 1932-1933)
 

itsmydamnation

Platinum Member
Feb 6, 2011
2,773
3,150
136
Bombing the entirety of all civilian infrastructure, might, by itself, force Ukraine into a ceasefire.
I cannot imagine how they live without heat and electricity. Or even function as a government and a military.
And this devastation has only truly begun in the past month. Its effects will amplify over time, especially as Iranian Ballistic Missiles find their mark to keep piling on the pain and reaching the few remaining targets. I wonder how any civilization survives such bombardment. How many people will Russia kill via winter's frozen touch?
That doesn't make any sense , because Putin's already done that and a ceasefire won't change that.

I don't expect much ground change over winter, but Ukraine have the tactical advantage with both artillery and himars , with flooding in of better AA, Ukraine will shell Russians and their supply lines all winter.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Drach

Dave_5k

Golden Member
May 23, 2017
1,583
3,094
136
They can still make fire, and most sensible people know how to make electricity. not on a city scale, but single homes should be able to weather the cold.
It takes a lot of firewood or coal to keep warm through the winter - while doable on single house basis, this isn't really workable for even a small city, would need a daily caravan of fuel. And Russia stole or destroyed basically all of the solar panels in regions they occupied, cutting off that avenue
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leeea