RANT: Things every student getting into the computers field *should* know.

yllus

Elite Member & Lifer
Aug 20, 2000
20,577
432
126
1) IT is not the same as CS. If was to be mean, I would say IT is a watered-down version of CS combined with some watered-down courses in management. These types of positions were in demand when Comp. Sci. graduates couldn't be relied upon to string together a coherent sentence in front of a crowd or relate well with others outside his immediate group of peers (read: geeks). This has changed.

We, of CS, no longer need you, the ITers. Queer Eye for the Straight Guy has healed our wardrobe, and our acne has vanished all on its own. Your lack of depth in your CS education will soon - if not already - be revealed, and our consolidation over your domain will begin. We, of CS, have become self-sufficient. Pack your bags.

2) MIS is not the same as CS. MIS isn't even a degree. MIS students are guys who learned how to design and program a database and added some courses in accounting, finance and management to try and round out the equation. That's what, 16 credits tops? What the hell did you do in your 2nd, 3rd and 4th year of studies?

3) CIS is respectable. CIS majors generally design and maintain information systems for organizations. This is not strictly CS territory, so we grant you some level of association with us. We do however request your support in pitching our next-gen database systems so the world can be rid of COBOL once and for all.

4) CE is not the same as CS. We of CS have no real qualms with our distant cousins, the engineers. We would however like to remind you that a good CS degree nets you just as much as a good CE degree, and that engineering is completely different from science. Not better, merely different. Keep yourselves grounded, CEers.

5) Your momma's sister's best friend's son with a barely average IQ who certified with a MCSE and A+ is not making $60k+ a year, he's unemployed and living at home...again. The tech bubble came and went and relied upon a state of mass insanity. People have now regained their senses, and with them the realization that there is no need to pay someone mid to high five figures just because they can splice Cat5 cable and swap expansion cards out of systems. Don't complain there are no jobs out there, this is a misnomer you are helping to spread. Just get some real marketable skills.

6) The greatest thing about our society is that if you are good at what you do, then no matter what you do, there is a reasonably well paying job out there with your name on it. Don't blame the economy, blame yourself.

7) Help desk work is not CS. Companies will, and have, trained chimps to man help desks in the past. Help desk is to CS as secretaries are to management. You can replace "help desk" with "technician" or "hardware/software product support" as needed. Real CS has nothing to do with these vocations.

8) Don't bother worrying over how to reply to, "Aren't you worried about your jobs going overseas?" They aren't our jobs.

To elaborate: The extent of globalization is such that whatever can be exported overseas to be done cheaper will be exported, regardless of type of work. Manufacturing's already gone, low-level tech support is being hit next. Law majors watch out, legal filings to become a corporation/LLC might be next! After all it doesn't take an incredible amount of brainwork and they can simply mail you with the documents you need, am I right?

Companies will slowly but surely apply this strategy to every facet of our economy. You can fight globalization (fruitless IMO), or you can become an indispensible. Use your intelligence. We're either all in trouble, or in not very much trouble at all.


-- yllus (2004)
 

AFB

Lifer
Jan 10, 2004
10,718
3
0
Originally posted by: yllus
1) IT is not the same as CS. If was to be mean, I would say IT is a watered-down version of CS combined with some watered-down courses in management. These types of positions were in demand when Comp. Sci. graduates couldn't be relied upon to string together a coherent sentence in front of a crowd or relate well with others outside his immediate group of peers (read: geeks). This has changed.

We, of CS, no longer need you, the ITers. Queer Eye for the Straight Guy has healed our wardrobe, and our acne has vanished all on its own. Your lack of depth in your CS education will soon - if not already - be revealed, and our consolidation over your domain will begin. We, of CS, have become self-sufficient. Pack your bags.

2) MIS is not the same as CS. MIS isn't even a degree. MIS students are guys who learned how to design and program a database and added some courses in accounting, finance and management to try and round out the equation. That's what, 16 credits tops? What the hell did you do in your 2nd, 3rd and 4th year of studies?

3) CIS is respectable. CIS majors generally design and maintain information systems for organizations. This is not strictly CS territory, so we grant you some level of association with us. We do however request your support in pitching our next-gen database systems so the world can be rid of COBOL once and for all.

4) CE is not the same as CS. We of CS have no real qualms with our distant cousins, the engineers. We would however like to remind you that a good CS degree nets you just as much as a good CE degree, and that playing with hardware shouldn't give you superiority complexes. Keep yourselves grounded, CEers.

5) Your momma's sister's best friend's son with a barely average IQ who certified with a MCSE and A+ is not making 60k+ a year, he's unemployed and living at home...again. The tech bubble came and went and relied upon a state of mass insanity. People have now regained their senses, and with them the realization that there is no need to pay someone mid to high five figures just because they can splice Cat5 cable and swap expansion cards out of systems. Don't complain there are no jobs out there, this is a misnomer you are helping to spread. Just get some real marketable skills.

6) The greatest thing about our society is that if you are good at what you do, then no matter what you do, there is a reasonably well paying job out there with your name on it. Don't blame the economy, blame yourself.

-- yllus (2004)


What about the networking peoples ? What are they ?
 

xchangx

Golden Member
Mar 23, 2000
1,692
1
71
Too bad cs jobs are being shipped overseas....

MIS here is what you would call CIS in your language.
 

TitanDiddly

Guest
Dec 8, 2003
12,696
1
0
So.... CS > CE > *? I was considering CE, because I want to have the 'Engineering" tacked onto my name. Always wanted to be an engineer. Unfortunately, My private education, well....

Edit: The college I'm thinking about has CE and CS... I take is CE is a bit harder, and you do more hardware?

It'd be nice to talk with people who have graduated from both. Anybody wants to help out an HS Junior who needs to look into majors and colleges, feel free to IM me(Phasmatis Nox).
 

trilks

Golden Member
Aug 16, 2002
1,117
0
0
Hey, thanks for saying i don't have a degree...

You're right, MIS is not CS. And CS is not MIS. Two very different majors. I don't have a legit degree because I can't program in C?

Although, if I could do it again, I'd probably do CS instead, since I got sick of the business school. But hindsight, 20/20, etc.
 

yllus

Elite Member & Lifer
Aug 20, 2000
20,577
432
126
Originally posted by: amdfanboy
What about the networking peoples ? What are they ?
Networking as in coding with sockets, layers, writing software for wired and wireless data communication: Should be in CS. In any case, brothers-in-arms and I would unsheath my sword to protect them as if they were my own kin.

Networking as in designing but for some reason not contained within the CS major: First-cousins.

Networking as in help desk, technicians, guy who occasionally reboots and dusts off the servers (aka "admin"): You may exchange simple pleasantries but should not be associated with outside of one's place of work.
 

yllus

Elite Member & Lifer
Aug 20, 2000
20,577
432
126
Originally posted by: PhasmatisNox
So.... CS > CE > *?
Nah, different strokes. If I implied that it was then it was my mistake. Here we go:

CS ~= CE > *
The college I'm thinking about has CE and CS... I take is CE is a bit harder, and you do more hardware?
It's going to differ slightly at every college. Your best bet is to look up people who's already been through that college's courses and find out what they thought the bias was towards.

At the very least make an appoiment for a day trip down to the college in question to ask each respective school about the program and where they think it'll head during the years you'll be attending - it WILL change.
 

Dufman

Golden Member
Dec 29, 2002
1,949
0
0
Originally posted by: yllus
1) IT is not the same as CS. If was to be mean, I would say IT is a watered-down version of CS combined with some watered-down courses in management. These types of positions were in demand when Comp. Sci. graduates couldn't be relied upon to string together a coherent sentence in front of a crowd or relate well with others outside his immediate group of peers (read: geeks). This has changed.

We, of CS, no longer need you, the ITers. Queer Eye for the Straight Guy has healed our wardrobe, and our acne has vanished all on its own. Your lack of depth in your CS education will soon - if not already - be revealed, and our consolidation over your domain will begin. We, of CS, have become self-sufficient. Pack your bags.

2) MIS is not the same as CS. MIS isn't even a degree. MIS students are guys who learned how to design and program a database and added some courses in accounting, finance and management to try and round out the equation. That's what, 16 credits tops? What the hell did you do in your 2nd, 3rd and 4th year of studies?

3) CIS is respectable. CIS majors generally design and maintain information systems for organizations. This is not strictly CS territory, so we grant you some level of association with us. We do however request your support in pitching our next-gen database systems so the world can be rid of COBOL once and for all.

4) CE is not the same as CS. We of CS have no real qualms with our distant cousins, the engineers. We would however like to remind you that a good CS degree nets you just as much as a good CE degree, and that playing with hardware shouldn't give you superiority complexes. Keep yourselves grounded, CEers.

5) Your momma's sister's best friend's son with a barely average IQ who certified with a MCSE and A+ is not making 60k+ a year, he's unemployed and living at home...again. The tech bubble came and went and relied upon a state of mass insanity. People have now regained their senses, and with them the realization that there is no need to pay someone mid to high five figures just because they can splice Cat5 cable and swap expansion cards out of systems. Don't complain there are no jobs out there, this is a misnomer you are helping to spread. Just get some real marketable skills.

6) The greatest thing about our society is that if you are good at what you do, then no matter what you do, there is a reasonably well paying job out there with your name on it. Don't blame the economy, blame yourself.

-- yllus (2004)

You are an asshat.

I know CS grads, and IT grads. In most cases the IT grads find jobs quicker and get better paying jobs.
 

JoeKing

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
10,641
1
81
I thought you were just going to write


Students in the computer fields..... expect to pleasure yourself for lack of a better companion.
 

CrackaLackaZe

Senior member
Jun 29, 2002
922
0
76
Originally posted by: yllus
1) IT is not the same as CS. If was to be mean, I would say IT is a watered-down version of CS combined with some watered-down courses in management. These types of positions were in demand when Comp. Sci. graduates couldn't be relied upon to string together a coherent sentence in front of a crowd or relate well with others outside his immediate group of peers (read: geeks). This has changed.

We, of CS, no longer need you, the ITers. Queer Eye for the Straight Guy has healed our wardrobe, and our acne has vanished all on its own. Your lack of depth in your CS education will soon - if not already - be revealed, and our consolidation over your domain will begin. We, of CS, have become self-sufficient. Pack your bags.

2) MIS is not the same as CS. MIS isn't even a degree. MIS students are guys who learned how to design and program a database and added some courses in accounting, finance and management to try and round out the equation. That's what, 16 credits tops? What the hell did you do in your 2nd, 3rd and 4th year of studies?

3) CIS is respectable. CIS majors generally design and maintain information systems for organizations. This is not strictly CS territory, so we grant you some level of association with us. We do however request your support in pitching our next-gen database systems so the world can be rid of COBOL once and for all.

4) CE is not the same as CS. We of CS have no real qualms with our distant cousins, the engineers. We would however like to remind you that a good CS degree nets you just as much as a good CE degree, and that playing with hardware shouldn't give you superiority complexes. Keep yourselves grounded, CEers.

5) Your momma's sister's best friend's son with a barely average IQ who certified with a MCSE and A+ is not making 60k+ a year, he's unemployed and living at home...again. The tech bubble came and went and relied upon a state of mass insanity. People have now regained their senses, and with them the realization that there is no need to pay someone mid to high five figures just because they can splice Cat5 cable and swap expansion cards out of systems. Don't complain there are no jobs out there, this is a misnomer you are helping to spread. Just get some real marketable skills.

6) The greatest thing about our society is that if you are good at what you do, then no matter what you do, there is a reasonably well paying job out there with your name on it. Don't blame the economy, blame yourself.

-- yllus (2004)


Sounds like a personal issue.
 

yllus

Elite Member & Lifer
Aug 20, 2000
20,577
432
126
Originally posted by: Dufman
You are an asshat.

I know CS grads, and IT grads. In most cases the IT grads find jobs quicker and get better paying jobs.
And this proves what? That ITers still have some borrowed time to live upon? That the association of IT with management does indeed lead to higher starting wages? All is not as it appears, m'boy.
Originally posted by: Joeyman
Students in the computer fields..... expect to pleasure yourself for lack of a better companion.
It seemed self-evident. ;)
 

Feldenak

Lifer
Jan 31, 2003
14,090
2
81
You forgot to mention that those of us in MIS will leave school with a BSBA and are not having our jobs shipped overseas en masse.
 

yllus

Elite Member & Lifer
Aug 20, 2000
20,577
432
126
Originally posted by: Feldenak
You forgot to mention that those of us in MIS will leave school with a BSBA and are not having our jobs shipped overseas en masse.
Ooh damn you reminded me that I left out an important part of my OP. Thanks.
 

DrNoobie

Banned
Mar 3, 2004
774
0
0
Eh, all are equally worthless. Damn computer geeks just keep breaking my charting computer at work.
 

LS20

Banned
Jan 22, 2002
5,858
0
0
Originally posted by: PhasmatisNox
So.... CS > CE > *? I was considering CE, because I want to have the 'Engineering" tacked onto my name. Always wanted to be an engineer. Unfortunately, My private education, well....

Edit: The college I'm thinking about has CE and CS... I take is CE is a bit harder, and you do more hardware?

It'd be nice to talk with people who have graduated from both. Anybody wants to help out an HS Junior who needs to look into majors and colleges, feel free to IM me(Phasmatis Nox).

useless useless useless. my mathematics neighbor is working a programming job. my ee friend just got a job programming... but another ee i know just got promoted into management into the marketing side.

the most important things you need to know about college is:

1. find out what you love
2. pursue it
3. ENJOY it

all this argument about whether ce is better than cs, whether cis counts as a real degree, or whether harvard is ranked higher than princeton to fluffen up your resume, is all utter hs nerd poo. i wish more people would realize this sooner.

go to any decent school, pursue what you love, and you'll make something out of it.



 

xchangx

Golden Member
Mar 23, 2000
1,692
1
71
Real CS has nothing to do with these vocations, so don't bother asking, "Aren't you worried about your jobs going overseas?" They aren't our jobs.

This is not true, I took a trip up to NY and talked to a lot of companies, CIO Citi Group, CSFB, E&Y, PWC, etc...

They all said that they plan to move cs overseas. Cheaper labor for the same quality of work, perhaps even better.

 

trilks

Golden Member
Aug 16, 2002
1,117
0
0
Welcome, everyone, to the "My Major Is Better, And I Have A Bigger D!ck" Contest. Open to all ATers...
 

gopunk

Lifer
Jul 7, 2001
29,239
2
0
Originally posted by: xchangx
Real CS has nothing to do with these vocations, so don't bother asking, "Aren't you worried about your jobs going overseas?" They aren't our jobs.

This is not true, I took a trip up to NY and talked to a lot of companies, CIO Citi Group, CSFB, E&Y, PWC, etc...

They all said that they plan to move cs overseas. Cheaper labor for the same quality of work, perhaps even better.

have you talked to amazon, google, microsoft, ibm, or any tech related companies? all the places you listed seem to be financial type companies... i'm sure they need computer scientists too, but i just don't see them having that strong of a need for CS majors in the first place