Sorry, but you're wrong, and I cannot duplicate what you have come up with. This is the result of someone born in 1990, with a passport issued in 1991.
Evidence of U.S. Citizenship
You must submit one of the following original documents as primary evidence of U.S. citizenship (photocopies are not acceptable):
Certified U.S. Birth Certificate (must meet all of the following requirements):
Issued by City, County, or State of birth
Lists bearer's full name, date of birth, and place of birth
Lists parent(s) full names
Has date filed with registrar's office (must be within one year of birth)
Has registrar's signature
Has embossed, impressed, or multicolored seal of registrar
Previous U.S. Passport (may be expired, must be undamaged)
Consular Report of Birth Abroad
Certificate of Naturalization/Citizenship
MORE
Photo Identification
When you submit your application, you must present one of the following primary photo identification documents, and submit a photocopy of that document:
Valid Driver's License (plus a second ID if issued in a different state than where you apply)
Undamaged U.S. Passport (if issued less than 15 years ago)
Certificate of Naturalization
Valid government ID (city, state, or federal)
Valid Military ID
Additionally, I just traveled with someone who went through the same exact scenario (except she had her birth certificate available if need be, but didn't take it to the post office for the application because the passport was sufficient)