you can turn down the rhetoric.
The officer should have been fired.
Officers work in different depts and deal with different groups of offenders. Some offenders (esp. gangs) are very violent and a tough cop is necessary. Dealing with those people will bring complaints and incidents of violence that get added to their jacket.
And I understand, but part of their job is assessing the situation. I don't think his actions in either of these cases warranted his response. Just because 10% of his encounters require the use of force, doesn't mean he gets to use it in the other 90% of the cases.
Usually? No. The MAJORITY of a beat cops job isn't violent altercations or people under the influence. You ahve been watching too many cop shows.Usually an officer deals with people who resist arrest or are under the influence of something and a violent altercation takes place. The officer is trained to deal with that in a quick and decisive manner. His superior will support him if he does everything by the book.
The support for this particular officer by his superior is for a show of solidarity. They know he is a problem cop, but support him for internal political reasons. He is an embarrassment to all the other officers and will eventually be dealt with. Its not so easy to just fire a union employee.
here's what I suggest: why don't you go on a ride-along and actually see what police have to deal with everyday before making generalizations about them.
I agree with your first paragraph, and i understand that. Find him something else to do. But you sound like part of the problem instead of the solution. I understand you want to defend LEOs regardless of what they are capable of doing, but if you can't admit to individual bad apples (and I think that at least from the information provided here that this one clearly is), and police departments don't deal with them either, then expect the community to be in an uproar. I understand that his job may very well be extremely dangerous, but his actions have already caused ones man life to be over, and id rather not see anyone else left to the same fate.