POLL: Are you of proper weight for your height? with BMI calculator

Page 5 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

p0ntif

Platinum Member
Feb 18, 2001
2,130
0
76
22.5 average. 5'8" 148lbs. (just weighed myself at the gym again today)
These things need to be updated to calculate in body fat. I've seen a guy who was ripped. 180, 5'9" . . .I think that makes him overweight. I'd have to check the numbers in the calculator again, but he only had 4% body fat. I think i've got 3% body fat last time I was measured for it.

 

DAPUNISHER

Super Moderator CPU Forum Mod and Elite Member
Super Moderator
Aug 22, 2001
32,036
32,521
146
Originally posted by: p0ntif
22.5 average. 5'8" 148lbs. (just weighed myself at the gym again today)
These things need to be updated to calculate in body fat. I've seen a guy who was ripped. 180, 5'9" . . .I think that makes him overweight. I'd have to check the numbers in the calculator again, but he only had 4% body fat. I think i've got 3% body fat last time I was measured for it.

From what I've read 3% body fat would be emaciated. 6% is considered extremely low to still be healthy. BTW that calculator evidently does not account for muscle mass and it's superior density to fat.
 

p0ntif

Platinum Member
Feb 18, 2001
2,130
0
76
From what I've read 3% body fat would be emaciated. 6% is considered extremely low to still be healthy. BTW that calculator evidently does not account for muscle mass and it's superior density to fat.

well I certainly am not emaciated. I'm normal, just with very little body fat and well defined. :)
 

absolutiza

Senior member
Jul 29, 2001
459
0
0
i'm 6'2", 215 pounds, but i have 5% body fat. it says that i'm overwieght. i think not. BMI is bulls!t
 

nightowl

Golden Member
Oct 12, 2000
1,935
0
0
I'm 6' 2" @ ~190lbs with a BMI of about 24.5 and sometimes closer to 25. I vary from day to day from 188 - 193. According to the chart I am boarder line normal and overweight. Granted I lift 4-5 time per week and I am fairly well cut. BMI charts are a complete waste for me. Now, if you are fairly inactive this would accurately represent you.
 

Danman

Lifer
Nov 9, 1999
13,134
0
0
I am muscle and it is saying I am overweight......:Q 25 average and I am 6'2" and about 190 lbs.
 

Jerboy

Banned
Oct 27, 2001
5,190
0
0
Originally posted by: cashman
I am muscle and it is saying

I am overweight......:Q 25 average and I am 6'2" and about 190 lbs.

Nice size :D

Anyways, I am starting to notice there is some government decision in there. I found out they changed their definition of "obese" and people went from normal to fat overnight. I don't remember when though.
 

MooseKnuckle

Golden Member
Oct 24, 1999
1,392
0
0
Oh no, I'm 36.0...very high obese. I'm 5' 7" and weigh 230 with lots of muscle mass. BMI works well in Somalia.
 

Rand

Lifer
Oct 11, 1999
11,071
1
81
I find it mildly amusing that almost everyone that gets a BMI of over 25 starts claiming they are all muscle, and have 3-4% body fat.

In general the BMI is an excellent descriptor for the vast majority of us.
It certainly has it's disadvantages, no one disputes that. But it's likely that for the majority of AT it would be quite accurate IMHO.

Body Mass Index (BMI)
BMI is a reliable indicator of total body fat, which is related to the risk of disease and death. The score is valid for both men and women but it does have some limits. The limits are:

It may overestimate body fat in athletes and others who have a muscular build.
It may underestimate body fat in older persons and others who have lost muscle mass.


FWIW, my BMI is 18.2, which puts me in the underweight category just below the bottom of the normal category.

Personally, I'm not terribly muscular for the most part and am quite possibly have less muscle mass then most men my height/weight/age. What muscle I do have is most likely predominantly in my lower body, in my upper body I'm well aware then I am likely relatively 'weak'
Most everyone I know considers me under-weight, though on a personal level I'd still like to lose about 14-19lbs.
I tend not to eat very much though on the rare occasion I'll splurge.
I consider my self reasonably fit and generally quite active.
I run 6-8 miles every other day, and avidly play soccer relatively often.

I have an unfortunate tendency to gain weight pretty quickly, in the past when I've cut down my running I've generally quickly jumped up to 150-160lbs.
I've been trying almost constantly for years to break through 130lbs, but I've been quite unsuccessful. I've pretty much come to the conclusion that 130lbs is the low point I'm capable of.

Presntly I weight 134lbs, and am 6'0 tall.
 

skriefal

Golden Member
Apr 10, 2000
1,424
3
81
Well, with a BMI of around 20.0 I hadn't expected too many people to be lower. Glad I'm not the only "thin" geek! With a drop from a BMI of 27.0 to 20.0 in a little over a year, for some time I was constantly hearing about how thin I'd become with some suggestions that I might now be underweight. I don't really think so -- I think the difference just surprised people. 5'10" @ 143 is just about right; now if only it weren't so difficult to find smaller clothing! Just try to find anti-Microsoft or pro-Linux t-shirts in sizes S or XS sometime! :)
 

nemo160

Senior member
Jul 16, 2001
339
0
0
5'9" 189, 27.9
i'm trying to get down to 170, but that's still technically overweight
bmi needs some sort of framesize adjustment
at my old wrestling weight (160) i was at around 8-9% body fat, plenty low
most of the people claiming 2-3% body fat are most likely wrong, the state of iowa added a rule a couple years
ago to not allow high school wrestlers to cut below 7% bodyfat without a doctor's waiver, 7% or below is reallly peeled
while i'm still a good bit over my target weight, i can tell my body fat is not at a near obese level,you can see the muscle striations in my shoulders and forearms and my ribs are also visible
unfortuneatley most body fat tests aren't veryaccurate either, skinfold calipers and electricaltesting give you an ide, but there is a large margin of error
 

MrDudeMan

Lifer
Jan 15, 2001
15,069
94
91
these things are so stoopid. im 6'3'' 250 and mostly muslce. it said i was like 34+ or something...bullcrap
 

Fritzo

Lifer
Jan 3, 2001
41,920
2,161
126
Heheheheh....it says I'm overweight :) I have abs for crisake! I'm buff! That chart is full of poopie. (BTW I'm 6'4" 220lbs and got a 27).
 

skriefal

Golden Member
Apr 10, 2000
1,424
3
81
Originally posted by: MrDudeMan
these things are so stoopid. im 6'3'' 250 and mostly muslce. it said i was like 34+ or something...bullcrap

As has been stated more than once in this thread: "BMI is generally not applicable to athletes and body builders". It's targeted at the average person, who makes little or no special effort to keep in shape. Although you don't appear to fit in this group, the vast majority of the US populace does.