I think we're allowing our emotions to overwhelm common sense. Pedophilia is a heinous, heinous crime, and well deserving of punishment, and it certainly seems as though Sandusky is guilty. But all we have now is Grand Jury testimony. There hasn't been a trial, there hasn't been a conviction. Calling for everyone's head on a pike is an emotional response to a heinous issue, but to say that if everyone involved in Penn State athletics isn't fired in the next two days it's a travesty? That's a little bit of an over-reaction.
What if we took this hardline, "we must act immediately" stance with everything? Remember the Duke Lacrosse rape scandal a few years back? "Fire the entire athletic department!" Oh, wait, turns out the charges were completely fraudulent... well, I guess we goofed. If the entire athletic department HAD been immediately fired, how many lawsuits would Duke have had to deal with?
The Duke case is certainly different in that this case seems to be a LOT stronger; let's face it, no one thinks Sandusky DIDN'T do it. But just because it is an emotional issue, we can't abandon all logic and reason. An immediate emotional response to this visceral issue is what we want, but it is not going to be sensible. I would rather the school looked into the evidence carefully and made specific calls as to who was complicit rather than getting caught up in the hysteria of "kill them all." We cannot abandon reason in the face of tragedy. There's a system of rules and laws in place for a reason, and even when we feel they aren't bringing us the immediate justice we crave, they're a hell of a lot better than the alternative.