Originally posted by: techs
Originally posted by: DLeRium
Link
And, this sounds like what happened when the Congress wanted the car companies to put seat belts in their cars. The car companies said it would cost 2,000 a car in 1961!
Set a difficult standard, and guess what? With old fashioned ingenuity American business can do it.
The problem your argument overlooks is that current petroleum engine technology is 100yrs old and is an extremely mature platform. Virtually all of the efficiency available from the platform has already been squeezed out of it, so the only way to cost effectively increase MPG is
reduce weight and power.
Mandating high MPG while offering no rational objective on how to acheive it is bad policy IMO, and totally ignores the reality of the situation for the sake of pandering to green intrests. Instead of more of the same old dumb energy policy maybe we should try thinking out of the box and place incentives that reward innovative alternatives and stop with the meaningless MPG standards.
Viable alternatives like CNG which would reduce emissions more than any increases in MPG ever could with the added benie of ending our dependancy on foreign oil could providing a logical next step in weaning ourselves off fossil fuels. And the environmental reality is that the total carbon footprint of all the cars in the US is less than the coal fired electricty plants so in the big picture MPG standards do little to address our emmisions problems.
Where is the change we were promised? Where is a strong concerted forward thinking energy policy? They might as well mandate flying cars by 2012