Lemon law: Obama has now determined, that Iranian sanctions are somehow permissible because taking Iranian oil off world markets will not adversely effect world oil prices.
http://news.yahoo.com/blogs/ticket/...h-sanctions-targeting-iran-oil-190045204.html
M: He couldn't very well apply sanctions if it would precipitate a world crisis, could he?
LL: But if we examine the logic and its converse, its totally bogus stinking thinking. Because if we assumed on no logical basis that Iran intends to develop nuclear weapons, why would an adverse effect on world prices make the Iranian nuclear permissible?
M: In the first place you assume that you are the scale on which logic is balanced and that what you call logic or illogic is other than just your opinion.
The fact that you called it stinking shows your emotions are involved, never a good sign when speaking of logic.
Finally, an effect on world wide prices would not make an Iranian nuclear program permissible but would only make possible the use of sanctions. If sanctions are off the table then a different path must be used.
It will always be preferable to deter a nation via economic pressure than to threaten them with or move to annihilation.
So a move to use sanctions in this case is not only not illogical, it's the epitome of sanity.
LL: The fact is and remains, there is absolutely no evidence that Iran is developing nuclear weapons.
M: That is irrelevant. They have a nuclear program they will not allow us to inspect and there is evidence that they hide things. Once you have determined that some government etc must not get nuclear weapons then they must open themselves to inspection or die. You can't wait around until they can kill you when you know they care nothing about deterrence.
They simply must open themselves to inspection and if there isn't work to create weapons they are off the hook.
LL: And at the same time, the USA invaded Iraq on the premise that Saddam had WMD, when it fact, Saddam did not have WMD. And now, 10 years later, US citizens have pissed some 4000 US lives down an Iraqi rat hole, and another 2 trillion dollars to boot on a invasion that was based on nothing but false suspicions, and now we have nothing to show for it. At the very time when the occupation of Afghanistan is on the verge of total failure.
M: Past mistakes change nothing about the future. Iran either is or is not developing nuclear weapons. All they have to do is open themselves to inspection or be destroyed. The next time the world wonders about a country they will be sure to open their doors.
And now on that same false suspicions basis, the USA and the EU have learned nothing and want to try more of the same in Iran.
M: Again is doesn't matter of they are real or false. What matters is that Iran not get a weapon and that can only be found out by inspection. Again it's inspections or die.
LL: Which may not be easy this time, as other mid-east nations may side with Iran as Turkey is already saying. As Israel chomps at the bit to bomb Iran when Israel is the most hated nation in the mid-east.
M: All the more reason for Iran to open their doors. Surely an honest country wouldn't want anything bad to happen because they won't allow inspectors in. And they won't so what does that tell you.
LL: The US simply can't accept the fact that their US puppet in the Shah of Iran got the ole heave ho from the Iranian people and simply will never come back. Meanwhile for 30 years the US has tried various things to torpedo Iran, and its backfired on the US every time.
M: If we gave Iran nuclear weapons fresh and ready to go, we would still have to get them back. Mistakes and justifications from the past do not matter. As long as folk with the help of Iran's posture in the world have come to the conclusion that Iran mustn't have nuclear weapons, they will have to be stopped from having them by whatever means required.
LL: Israel and the US have already pushed up US gas prices by 50 cents a gallon, and now Obama risks pushing up US gas prices to $15.00 or more. By alienating Arab nations and the world with only suspicions.
M: The price of gas is of no importance. What is important is insuring that millions or billions of innocent people don't die because somebody is too insane to care.