Aquila76
Diamond Member
Originally posted by: eigen
Originally posted by: Aquila76
Originally posted by: eigen
I think this is a funny thread, in that I am sure a bunch of the people that posted turn him in, have dl'ed music and have copied movies.Its not crackead and drugaddicts that buy dvd burners and dvd-rw's.
There's a big difference in downloading a movie and stealing one out of a mailbox.
It's like this: If I download a movie you own on DVD, you still have your movie and are able to use and enjoy it. But if I take the physical DVD you own, you lose the use and enjoyment of the movie.
Against the law is against the law, right DonVito.
You cant pick and choose what laws you are gonna follow right?
The laws on downloading are not concrete. RIAA and MPAA would have you believe this is illegal, but there hasn't been any definite decision on this yet, hence why the matter is before the Supreme Court. I believe like many do that unless you're taking a physical copy of something that would cost money to replace, it is not stealing. This is more like 'fair use' instead of stealing. Stealing implies taking something that is in the physical possession of someone else.
If you take a movie from BitTorrent or Kazaa, the physical movie remains where it is.
If you take a movie from Wal-Mart or wherever, you've stolen the physical movie.