Seinfeld had a few funny moments, but I'm convinced that it's the most overrated sitcom ever. I think a lot of the reason people think it's funny is that laughter is contagious. i.e. the artificial laugh track is played & people chuckle along with it. The reason I hated the show is that I'm apparently not susceptible to such simple manipulation, and in fact, found it annoying enough (I don't think they ever go 2 sentences without the laugh track) that I hated the show.
I think a cool experiment would be to not use the name of the show, remove the laugh track, and show it to people who had never seen Seinfeld & see how humorous they find it. I'm betting not very much.
*sigh* I guess I'll never understand this ridiculous unholy crusade against the laugh track. Not saying those against it have invalid opinions, but to demonize it as some do really aggravates me to no end. And now you come along with this I'm-immune-to-the-canned-laugher-ray-gun diatribe and my face finally meets palm.
First of all, if ever there was a show that had to be re-syndicated without a laugh track and still be considered funny to a select group of people, Seinfeld would be that show. The humor IS there and the acting/situations are funny without any "laugh coaxing" if you ask me. I doubt the show got to where it ended up because of over-influencing laughter. And yeah, Seinfeld didn't have any "artificial" laugh track, it used a studio audience.
By your rationale though the only reason a show would need a laugh track is to induce laughter to make up for sub-par humor. Now, I may be biased growing up on a bunch of shows that used laugh tracks (Married With Children, Cheers, etc..) but to me the laughter adds a sort of ambiance to the shows that use it. I don't know what it is, but some shows just seem to work better with laughter filling in certain gaps. Does the audience go overboard with laughter in some scenes? Sure they do, but humor is indeed subjective and what I find funny will more often then not differ from what you find funny. So on the flip side of that I'm wondering why an audience isn't laughing even more at some scenes.
So yeah, it's all subjective and I can see why people dislike it but the intolerance some people have for it just boggles my mind at times.