randomlinh
Lifer
Originally posted by: fuzzybabybunny
Originally posted by: randomlinh
Originally posted by: fuzzybabybunny
The grip is definitely a league above the shitastic 30D grip I've had to deal with for so long, which was even worse than my Rebel XT grip IMO
Ok, while I agree nikon is a step (or three) above canon in ergonomics, how in the world did you come to the 30D being WORSE than your XT? I know it's a subjective matter.. but... damn.
Perhaps not the ergonomics, although that is subjective. I personally liked the ergonomics of the XT grip better because I have smaller hands.
However, the construction is what I was referring to. The slide out tray design of the XT is a lot more robust than the 30D's. I've used the XT grip a LOT, and the only time it has failed me was when it got dunked in seawater. The 30D's grip feels cheaper, one of the plastic latches holding the battery in place cracked off, the battery door is cracked at the hinges (XT door has no hinges), and overall it's a lot less weatherproof than the XT because it has malfunctioned on numerous occasions, far more than the XT grip.
ah, gotcha. I agree the battery door does leave a bit to be desired. I have not looked at that specifically on the XT. Usually when I read about the grip, it's in reference to ergonomics. Your needs on weather sealing are different than mine though, so I can't quite comment on that aspect
