Jedi question

[Maverick]

Originally posted by: ffmcobalt

Originally posted by: MaxDepth
A friend of mine said it best in an email to me about a recent Star Wars 3 spoiler email:

someone please cast a voodoo spell and raise Irvin
Kirshner from the grave. He's the only director with a speck of talent
to have had anything to do with a Star Wars film. And then of course
there's the fact that Lucas, in addition to not directing, had
little-to-nothing to do with the writing of Empire Strikes Back, either.
Huh. Funny how these things line up...

STAR WARS 3, SPOILER EMAIL CONTENTS:





The upcoming last Star Wars film will be called Star
Wars Episode 3: The Rise Of The Empire. The film will
focus on Anakins tragic decision to follow the dark
side and his part in the gradual extermination of the
Jedi order during the clone wars. Samuel L. Jacksons
character Mace Windu will be killed by Anakin in which
this scene should be the most eagerly anticipated
death in the entire series. At the end of the film,
there will be a climactic battle between Obi-Wan and
Anakin in which the evil Anakin is so badly wounded
that he has to wear the jet black mask and breathing
suit. Star Wars Episode 3: The Rise Of The Empire is
planned to be released on Thursday the 19th of May
2005.

2005!? WHAT THE GODDAMN MONKEY FSKIN DONKEYASSLINKING!!!!111 GGGAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

:|

maybe we'll get some of the original movies on DVD while we wait for the last one. Here's hoping

 

[NikPreviousAcct]

Originally posted by: MattCo

Originally posted by: ffmcobalt

Originally posted by: MattCo
They have to wait for Hayden Christensen to grow up a little.

-MC

Or maybe they have to wait for him to get some acting skills. That guy's almost as bad as Leo in Titanic -and just as ugly.

nik

Awww, come on. You know you thought he was suave when he was using his playa skills on Natalie! What was that line... There are a lot of soft things here on Naboo?

-MC

Anakin is a scumbag. He could have been using the force on her to have her all to his selfish, greedy self.

nik

 

[Cuda1447]

I KNOW THE FReaGIN answer!


When Obi Wan died it was because he was ready to. He actually disappeared before he died. He was in a sense struck down in battle, but he saw it coming and was allowing it. When Qui Gon died he was mid battle and not ready for it. None of the jedi in the colleseum were ready to die yet either.



Thats the answer, ask if you got any questions, Ill clarify better.

 

[Dedpuhl]

Originally posted by: Cuda1447
I KNOW THE FReaGIN answer!


When Obi Wan died it was because he was ready to. He actually disappeared before he died. He was in a sense struck down in battle, but he saw it coming and was allowing it. When Qui Gon died he was mid battle and not ready for it. None of the jedi in the colleseum were ready to die yet either.



Thats the answer, ask if you got any questions, Ill clarify better.

Actually, that makes a lot of sense...

 

[Wingznut]

Originally posted by: Dedpuhl

Originally posted by: Cuda1447
I KNOW THE FReaGIN answer!


When Obi Wan died it was because he was ready to. He actually disappeared before he died. He was in a sense struck down in battle, but he saw it coming and was allowing it. When Qui Gon died he was mid battle and not ready for it. None of the jedi in the colleseum were ready to die yet either.



Thats the answer, ask if you got any questions, Ill clarify better.

Actually, that makes a lot of sense...

That explanation is not bad... Not bad at all.

 

[Desslok]

Like I said before, there needs to be a coup at Skywalker ranch and someine needs to tell Lucas to give up the reigns. At least make Episode III on par with The Empire Strikes Back, which in my opinion is the best in the series.

 

[MaxDepth]

Originally posted by: Cuda1447
I KNOW THE FReaGIN answer!


When Obi Wan died it was because he was ready to. He actually disappeared before he died. He was in a sense struck down in battle, but he saw it coming and was allowing it. When Qui Gon died he was mid battle and not ready for it. None of the jedi in the colleseum were ready to die yet either.



Thats the answer, ask if you got any questions, Ill clarify better.

[Yoda]Strong is the bullsh1t with this one is[....Hmmmm![/Yoda]

 

[Cuda1447]

Speaking of Yoda, didnt he disappear too? Hrmm, maybe he was ready to? Ahh yes.



If anyone's full of BS its you.

 

[Supermercado]

Originally posted by: Cuda1447
I KNOW THE FReaGIN answer!


When Obi Wan died it was because he was ready to. He actually disappeared before he died. He was in a sense struck down in battle, but he saw it coming and was allowing it. When Qui Gon died he was mid battle and not ready for it. None of the jedi in the colleseum were ready to die yet either.



Thats the answer, ask if you got any questions, Ill clarify better.

I've heard this explanation/theory or whatever before, and it's the one that I agree with. I might have been able to think of it when I first posted in this thread, but I'd just gotten out of bed and wasn't really awake yet.

Edit: Anakin also fits this theory. Once Luke "saved" him from the Dark Side at the end of ROTJ, I'm fairly certain he was technically no longer a Dark Lord of the Sith any longer. At that point, he was about to die, anyway, and was "at peace" with himself and life, etc.

 

[NikPreviousAcct]

Originally posted by: MaxDepth

Originally posted by: Cuda1447
I KNOW THE FReaGIN answer!


When Obi Wan died it was because he was ready to. He actually disappeared before he died. He was in a sense struck down in battle, but he saw it coming and was allowing it. When Qui Gon died he was mid battle and not ready for it. None of the jedi in the colleseum were ready to die yet either.



Thats the answer, ask if you got any questions, Ill clarify better.

[Yoda]Strong is the bullsh1t with this one is[....Hmmmm![/Yoda]

Yup. Agree = 100%.


nik

 

[Cuda1447]

Ok, Mr. All knowing nik. Whats the answer then if your so smart?



For real, why doesn't this make sense? Because you didnt think of it? Pfft get real!

 

[rgwalt]

Originally posted by: aves2k

Originally posted by: MaxDepthCould the explanation be something as simple as Lucas' own failure as writer and director?

That he ignores or forgets the mythology he created?

Could be.

Another example of this is that in the original trilogy Obi-Wan says that Yoda was his master and now we know that it was infact Qui-Gon Ginn.

Another explanation for this (sorry, I couldn't buy your explanation Nik) is that Yoda taught classes for all the young Jedi. Remember in ATOC when all the little Jedi kids were deflecting bolts? Well, Yoda was their teacher. In Empire, Ben tells Luke to go to Dagobah where "you will learn from Yoda, the Jedi Master who taught me". The concept of master and apprentice (padawan) pairs is new to TPM and ATOC. So, I don't think this a hole or flaw in the plot.

One thing I'm curious about is what happens to the droids? I'm assuming they will get a memory wipe before being put into the service of the Rebelion or Bail Organa because they know too much.

Ryan

 

[Cuda1447]

No, because Qui Gon was also taught by Yoda. He didn't disappear. Good try, but my theory is legit, I gurantee.

 

[NikPreviousAcct]

Originally posted by: Cuda1447
Ok, Mr. All knowing nik. Whats the answer then if your so smart?



For real, why doesn't this make sense? Because you didnt think of it? Pfft get real!

Ok, Mr. All Fscking Asshole Cuda1447. Why didn't you attack the person who I agreed with instead of me?

Fsck you.

nik

 

[NikPreviousAcct]

Originally posted by: rgwalt

Originally posted by: aves2k

Originally posted by: MaxDepthCould the explanation be something as simple as Lucas' own failure as writer and director?

That he ignores or forgets the mythology he created?

Could be.

Another example of this is that in the original trilogy Obi-Wan says that Yoda was his master and now we know that it was infact Qui-Gon Ginn.

Another explanation for this (sorry, I couldn't buy your explanation Nik) is that Yoda taught classes for all the young Jedi. Remember in ATOC when all the little Jedi kids were deflecting bolts? Well, Yoda was their teacher. In Empire, Ben tells Luke to go to Dagobah where "you will learn from Yoda, the Jedi Master who taught me". The concept of master and apprentice (padawan) pairs is new to TPM and ATOC. So, I don't think this a hole or flaw in the plot.

One thing I'm curious about is what happens to the droids? I'm assuming they will get a memory wipe before being put into the service of the Rebelion or Bail Organa because they know too much.

Ryan

My explanation? Did I say that they were wrong and Ias right? No. Just like everybody else in this thread, I'm tossing out ideas.

nik

 

[Cuda1447]

Because nik, you post ALOT!!! You always act like you know what your talking about, and Im willing to bet more then half the time YOU ARE THE ONE THAT IS FULL OF SH!T!!!


Now, dont turn this into a flame fest Your wrong, Im right. Guranteed.

 

[MattCo]

Originally posted by: Cuda1447
Because nik, you post ALOT!!! You always act like you know what your talking about, and Im willing to bet more then half the time YOU ARE THE ONE THAT IS FULL OF SH!T!!!


Now, dont turn this into a flame fest Your wrong, Im right. Guranteed.

Have you any proof? Where do you get off telling someone that they are full of Sh*t and then saying you dont want a flame war?!?!?!

Nik was just commenting on someone else's idea. Why single him out?

-MC

 

[Cuda1447]

I already explained why I singled him out. Go back and read it. And yes I do have proof, I can't get it for you now though. Im at school, when I get home later tonight Ill give yah a url.

 

[Dedpuhl]

Originally posted by: rgwalt

Originally posted by: aves2k

Originally posted by: MaxDepthCould the explanation be something as simple as Lucas' own failure as writer and director?

That he ignores or forgets the mythology he created?

Could be.

Another example of this is that in the original trilogy Obi-Wan says that Yoda was his master and now we know that it was infact Qui-Gon Ginn.

Another explanation for this (sorry, I couldn't buy your explanation Nik) is that Yoda taught classes for all the young Jedi. Remember in ATOC when all the little Jedi kids were deflecting bolts? Well, Yoda was their teacher. In Empire, Ben tells Luke to go to Dagobah where "you will learn from Yoda, the Jedi Master who taught me". The concept of master and apprentice (padawan) pairs is new to TPM and ATOC. So, I don't think this a hole or flaw in the plot.

One thing I'm curious about is what happens to the droids? I'm assuming they will get a memory wipe before being put into the service of the Rebelion or Bail Organa because they know too much.

Ryan

Count Dooku was Yoda's Padawan...

 

[MaxDepth]

Originally posted by: ffmcobalt

Originally posted by: Cuda1447
Ok, Mr. All knowing nik. Whats the answer then if your so smart?



For real, why doesn't this make sense? Because you didnt think of it? Pfft get real!

Ok, Mr. All Fscking Asshole Cuda1447. Why didn't you attack the person who I agreed with instead of me?

Fsck you.

nik

Yup. Agree = 100%.



Pssst, Nik. I think he tried to insult me, but I didn't bite. Actually since I'm not a subscriber, I'm too slow in posting a response.
bwahahahahaha

 

[NikPreviousAcct]

Originally posted by: Cuda1447
I already explained why I singled him out. Go back and read it. And yes I do have proof, I can't get it for you now though. Im at school, when I get home later tonight Ill give yah a url.

PM that to me, too. I'd like to see it. You know, often times, the only reason that people can accuse other people of something is if they are intimately knowledgable and familiar with what they're accusing other people of in the first place.

nik

 

[NikPreviousAcct]

Originally posted by: MaxDepth

Originally posted by: ffmcobalt

Originally posted by: Cuda1447
Ok, Mr. All knowing nik. Whats the answer then if your so smart?



For real, why doesn't this make sense? Because you didnt think of it? Pfft get real!

Ok, Mr. All Fscking Asshole Cuda1447. Why didn't you attack the person who I agreed with instead of me?

Fsck you.

nik

Yup. Agree = 100%.



Pssst, Nik. I think he tried to insult me, but I didn't bite. Actually since I'm not a subscriber, I'm too slow in posting a response.
bwahahahahaha

It's all good.

nik

 

[MaxDepth]

Originally posted by: ffmcobalt

Originally posted by: Cuda1447
I already explained why I singled him out. Go back and read it. And yes I do have proof, I can't get it for you now though. Im at school, when I get home later tonight Ill give yah a url.

PM that to me, too. I'd like to see it. You know, often times, the only reason that people can accuse other people of something is if they are intimately knowledgable and familiar with what they're accusing other people of in the first place.

nik

Yeah, after reading this more closely, I am wondering to what you are referring to Cuda? Proof of this dorky Jedi question or that I'm full of BS?

Only my adoring fans know the answer to the latter and you, sir, have never been to a single fan club meeting!
:Q






My friend, Alexander the Great, is not happy with you!

 

[fluxquantum]

hmmm, interesting

 

[EvilYoda]

this all reminds me that I should check the SW forums more often...lots of cool people here, but not many nuts like my friends and I...granted, I'm still like 3 books behind in the New Jedi Order series...

As for Exar Kun...it's not easy to explain him quickly, best to go grab the Dark Horse comics that show his background (when he was alive), and then yeah, his spirit is the one that's present in the books, that is entombed in the Massassi Temples on Yavin 4.

<---Loves SW ^_^