i think i'm doing it - making the switch from the 360 to a PS3

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Queasy

Moderator<br>Console Gaming
Aug 24, 2001
31,796
2
0
Originally posted by: chrisg22
And honestly, for even bringing Dr. Phil into this thread you have brought trolling threads to a new level.

As long as we don't bring in Chris Hansen. :shocked:
 

BenSkywalker

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
9,140
67
91
How much are you willing to bet that there are FAR more people happy with XBL than those that aren't?

20 Million 360 users aren't happy with Live Gold according to MS. I win this one by default.

And honestly, for even bringing Dr. Phil into this thread you have brought trolling threads to a new level.

I quoted the guy, the lawyer, and MS from that article. I wasn't giving his commentary.

I would like 1742 links.

Here is 79,500- happy reading.
 

bl4ckfl4g

Diamond Member
Feb 13, 2007
3,669
0
0
Originally posted by: BenSkywalker
I'm glad I like free speech.

So do I, and if you are into the KKK you can find plenty of their speech around. I'm not going to pay to get that inane drivel pushed into my house though.

But, this is all your opinion.

How many hundreds of links would you like? Give me a number. This has already been covered on national TV, had activists calling for FBI involvement too. You can say my stance is extreme, but you would be in denial. One third of 360 owners are current Gold subscribers- all the 360 loyalists tell us all the time what the best feature of the 360 is- why are only one third of the people using it? Perhaps you should realize even amongst 360 owners- you are the minority- people who enjoy the Live! gaming experience.

Queasy-

Ben, you're making the false assumption that Live is not moderated though.

I have multiple 360s, it takes little effort to track those I reported. I have never seen MS do anything to those reported, even when I'm in a game with several friends and we all report the same person. I have heard all about their moderation, I have simply never seen it.

Live also heavily features self-moderation in the form of the ability to mute individual players, report individual players to Live moderators, and the option to not play against/with other individual players by leaving negative feedback. All features that PSN does not to the best of my knowledge.

PSN doesn't have negative feedback, it has all the rest. I've never seen the kind of actions on PSN or the PC that is commonplace on Live. This isn't just a PS3 versus 360 thing, Live is the poorest social gaming service I have ever seen by a staggering margin. Death threats may get investigated after MS gets leaned on by the national media- that is how bad it is.

BTW- I've been playing MMOs for years, you have ~100% mic useage there too and never have I seen the kind of behaviour MS seems to encourage(through inaction if nothing else- everyone else bans them, so they have only one safe haven).

You misunderstand. I'm not saying you should pay for it. I'm just wondering why you are crying about it. There are plenty of tools provided that takes care of the issues. 1 being to not pay for it but then why spend so much energy whining about it. There are many tools given to earmuff yourself from that behavior...and yeah I think it is overstated. I remember 1 time in the 2 years I've been on XBL that a couple of people were hurling racial and other insults constantly but whatever I'm not offended easily. I just can't imagine it being as bad as you state since I play on XBL almost everyday for an hour or 2 and rarely notice anything other than normal cursing.
 

Queasy

Moderator<br>Console Gaming
Aug 24, 2001
31,796
2
0
Originally posted by: BenSkywalker
How much are you willing to bet that there are FAR more people happy with XBL than those that aren't?

20 Million 360 users aren't happy with Live Gold according to MS. I win this one by default.

It's a stretch to say that 20 million 360 users aren't happy with Live Gold according to MS. Especially for the reasons you are intimating. Especially without any sort of proof/linkage. If anything, the people that don't have Live Gold probably are far more likely to fall into one of the following categories:

1) Don't want to pay for it
2) Don't know about it
3) Don't want to pay for it
4) Parents won't let them play online yet
5) Don't want to pay for it

Originally posted by: bl4ckfl4g
I just can't imagine it being as bad as you state since I play on XBL almost everyday for an hour or 2 and rarely notice anything other than normal cursing.

This. Even when I played the two games that attract the douchebags the most (Halo and Gears of War) the over the top racist comments were few and far between.
 

purbeast0

No Lifer
Sep 13, 2001
53,664
6,547
126
Originally posted by: BenSkywalker
Oh god cry more or just ya know take your headset off or maybe set it to party only.

$500Million a year not enough to moderate? Sony manages to do it for free. Funny how that works. I get to pay for a clearly inferior gaming experience. Hey, you can talk all you want about the great new theater down the street, how great their projectors are, how comfy the seats are- when I'm paying a significant premium to have a Grand Wizard spewing hate while I'm tryinig to enjoy myself is it too much ask to have him kicked the hell out? Why should I have to change the way I'm watching the movie? Did I not pay for it? Are there not people in charge of making sure it is an enjoyable experience?

Would Queasy EVER tollerate that kind of shit in this forum? I don't think so. He does a damn good job, unlike MS. And I have a feeling Quesy is paid a bit less then $500Million a year :)

are you seriously calling xbox live inferior to PSN?
 

bucwylde23

Diamond Member
Apr 21, 2005
4,180
0
71
Originally posted by: BenSkywalker
How much are you willing to bet that there are FAR more people happy with XBL than those that aren't?

20 Million 360 users aren't happy with Live Gold according to MS. I win this one by default.

How about a link or some proof of that statement?

I can't find the current number of Xbox live subscribers, but it looks like on around May 28,2009 xbox live hit 20 million subscribers.
So you are telling me that the majority, almost ALL people who subscribe to XBL, aren't happy?

I'm sorry but without some very good proof I think everything you say is BS.
 

BenSkywalker

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
9,140
67
91
You misunderstand. I'm not saying you should pay for it. I'm just wondering why you are crying about it.

Live is always pointed out as the 360's big strength. Honestly after my time I wouldn't play on Live! if you paid me, and yes I mean that seriously. Both the PC and the PS3 provide VASTLY superior environments IME, mainly because you aren't dealing with the absurd level of racism and homophobia you do on Live!. This is something MS should have never allowed to get as far as it did. They are collecting hundreds of millions of years off of Live!, is it too much to ask that they police it constantly?

I make a big issue of this because if MS doesn't do anything about it it will only get worse, and believe me I would be all over Sony if they allowed the same. MS just seems to be of the more, "good ole boy", I guess you could say, philosophy when it comes to these sorts of things. Anyway, check out some of the links I provided, then go check out gamertags and when the last time some of those people have logged in. It is shocking how little MS does.

How about a link or some proof of that statement?

MS stated there were 10Million Gold Live! subscribers at their most recent update, their are 30 Million 360 owners. The 20 Million number if for Silver or Gold, so anyone who has their 360 on line.

are you seriously calling xbox live inferior to PSN?

Hell yes, by a staggering amount. Go to a white supremacist tech forum and tell me how great it is. I don't care what features it offers, I'll stick with a properly moderated one.
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
Lulz @ BenSkywalker... :laugh:

I'm sure you'll be happy with the PS3 as long as you like the controller. At least for me, that's the most important difference between the two consoles at this point now that the 360 isn't getting so many third party exclusives.
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
MS does have a team of people who police Live actively, but with millions of players it's impossible for them to catch every instance of bad behavior. If you encounter unacceptable behavior and it bothers you, you need to file a complaint. It's very easy to do. It's also easy to block communications from any individual user. You can also restrict communications so you can only hear your friends.

The problem is, no one ever files complains.
 

bucwylde23

Diamond Member
Apr 21, 2005
4,180
0
71
Originally posted by: BenSkywalker

How about a link or some proof of that statement?

MS stated there were 10Million Gold Live! subscribers at their most recent update, their are 30 Million 360 owners. The 20 Million number if for Silver or Gold, so anyone who has their 360 on line.

Where did MS say there was 20 million unhappy users on XBL and where is the proof? You said that there 20 million Gold/Silver subscribers combined and 10 million (probalby more by now) gold subscribers. You previously said there are 20 million unhappy people on XBL.

You also said "MS stated there were 10Million Gold Live! subscribers at their most recent update, their are 30 Million 360 owners."

If there are only 10 million gold subscribers then what does this have to do with headsets/racism? The silver members can't play games online so they wouldn't be able to hear any thing over their headsets.

Your statements don't even agree with each other.

let me quote it just so it makes more sense:

Originally posted by: BenSkywalker
20 Million 360 users aren't happy with Live Gold according to MS. I win this one by default.

Originally posted by: BenSkywalker
MS stated there were 10Million Gold Live! subscribers at their most recent update, their are 30 Million 360 owners. The 20 Million number if for Silver or Gold, so anyone who has their 360 on line.


 

BenSkywalker

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
9,140
67
91
The problem is, no one ever files complains.

I did frequently. I really didn't care what kind of language I heard unless it was a racial or homophobic slur(the lewd things you did wth my mom in graphic detail- some of them honestly had me laughing my ass off)- then it was reported. People who do this get ignored by MS. I've been in games where everyone else in the game reported the guy, nothing ever happened to him. MS does not care. I linked an article already where a guy making death threats to someone else may get looked into.

All of the things you mention you can do to Live is correct, although I haven't logged on in a while now have they upped the ignore cap? I was at 50, and that was within a week of playing. I set it to just have my friends then why pay to play online? We can LAN.

Your statements don't even agree with each other.

I apologize, I assume English isn't your native language, guess that could be a bit confusing.

20 Million 360 users aren't happy with Live Gold according to MS. I win this one by default.

There are 30 million 360 users, there are 10 million Live Gold users. 20 million 360 users are not Live Gold users, therefore they can not possibly be happy Gold Live users now can they?
 

bucwylde23

Diamond Member
Apr 21, 2005
4,180
0
71
Originally posted by: BenSkywalker
The problem is, no one ever files complains.

I did frequently. I really didn't care what kind of language I heard unless it was a racial or homophobic slur(the lewd things you did wth my mom in graphic detail- some of them honestly had me laughing my ass off)- then it was reported. People who do this get ignored by MS. I've been in games where everyone else in the game reported the guy, nothing ever happened to him. MS does not care. I linked an article already where a guy making death threats to someone else may get looked into.

All of the things you mention you can do to Live is correct, although I haven't logged on in a while now have they upped the ignore cap? I was at 50, and that was within a week of playing. I set it to just have my friends then why pay to play online? We can LAN.

Your statements don't even agree with each other.

I apologize, I assume English isn't your native language, guess that could be a bit confusing.

20 Million 360 users aren't happy with Live Gold according to MS. I win this one by default.

There are 30 million 360 users, there are 10 million Live Gold users. 20 million 360 users are not Live Gold users, therefore they can not possibly be happy Gold Live users now can they?


You said they aren't happy with LIVE GOLD. English is my native language, unfortunately stupidity and not making sense, isn't. I deal with facts, and your facts/statements are wrong and you have provided no proof on the fact that "20 Million 360 users aren't happy with Live Gold" For them to be unhappy with Live Gold,they have to have it.

How many times can you reply without posting some proof?

If no proof is necessary, I'll then tell you that 9 million Xbox 360 Live Gold subscribers are happy with the service. Believe me?
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
Originally posted by: BenSkywalker
The problem is, no one ever files complains.

I did frequently. I really didn't care what kind of language I heard unless it was a racial or homophobic slur(the lewd things you did wth my mom in graphic detail- some of them honestly had me laughing my ass off)- then it was reported. People who do this get ignored by MS. I've been in games where everyone else in the game reported the guy, nothing ever happened to him. MS does not care. I linked an article already where a guy making death threats to someone else may get looked into.

How do you know nothing ever happened to him?

20 Million 360 users aren't happy with Live Gold according to MS. I win this one by default.

There are 30 million 360 users, there are 10 million Live Gold users. 20 million 360 users are not Live Gold users, therefore they can not possibly be happy Gold Live users now can they?

In English, "aren't happy with" is generally interpreted to mean "are unhappy with," which is the way everyone else interpreted your statement. You are correct that if there are 20 million people who have not subscribed to Xbox Live Gold, those 20 million people couldn't possibly be happy Xbox Live Gold users. This is of course meaningless information; it tells us nothing other than that there are 20 million Xbox owners who don't use Xbox Live Gold. It doesn't tell us why they don't use it or how they feel about it.
 

Ackmed

Diamond Member
Oct 1, 2003
8,499
560
126
Keep the 360, get both. Or all three. There are valid reasons to own all, and you get to play any game that comes out. Unless you're strapped for cash, and can only have one or the other, I would own both.

Originally posted by: Cuda1447
I recently bought a PS3 and haven't played it much. Aside from a few exclusives, there is no difference really. Blu-ray doesn't even look THAT much better.

Then you're doing it wrong. The PS3 does a great job of upscaling DVD's, but there is still a noticable difference.

Originally posted by: Auryg
I have all 3 systems. In order of playtime, I play the Xbox 360 95% of the time, the PS3 4.9% of the time, and the Wii .1%. I honestly have no idea why you'd switch - the 360 has more exclusives, and multiplatform games are usually better on the 360. Combine that with the fact that Live is better, you don't have to do installs, and updates don't take an hour..yeah. Don't do it.

More exclusives? Care to list them? Most of the 360's top exclusives are available for the PC. Which is where I prefer to play most games. Multiplatform better on the 360? Again, not hardly. Both "win" their fair share, none in ways a gamer is going to notice unless there are side by side shots, which is just pointless.

Originally posted by: bl4ckfl4g

I'm glad I like free speech.

I like it too. I do think however it comes with repercussions. There is no way a little punk would talk to me in person, the way they do over live or the psn network. The whole internet anonymity is not good for our youth, imo. They try that in the real world, to the wrong person and they will get beat down.

I just mute everyone.

 

Cuda1447

Lifer
Jul 26, 2002
11,757
0
71
Originally posted by: BenSkywalker
The problem is, no one ever files complains.

I did frequently. I really didn't care what kind of language I heard unless it was a racial or homophobic slur(the lewd things you did wth my mom in graphic detail- some of them honestly had me laughing my ass off)- then it was reported. People who do this get ignored by MS. I've been in games where everyone else in the game reported the guy, nothing ever happened to him. MS does not care. I linked an article already where a guy making death threats to someone else may get looked into.

All of the things you mention you can do to Live is correct, although I haven't logged on in a while now have they upped the ignore cap? I was at 50, and that was within a week of playing. I set it to just have my friends then why pay to play online? We can LAN.

Your statements don't even agree with each other.

I apologize, I assume English isn't your native language, guess that could be a bit confusing.

20 Million 360 users aren't happy with Live Gold according to MS. I win this one by default.

There are 30 million 360 users, there are 10 million Live Gold users. 20 million 360 users are not Live Gold users, therefore they can not possibly be happy Gold Live users now can they?



I'm sorry, I have to chime in now, this is getting ridiculous. It is worse than the garbage I see in P&N.

Just because someone doesn't have live doesn't mean they are unhappy with it. There are about a billion reasons why someone might not subscribe to live.

Money, internet, do they play online? Will their parents let them get it? Yatta yatta...

To assume every person who doesn't have live, doesn't like live, just because they don't have it....

Well its idiotic at the least.


That said. I think 95% of unbiased people will tell you the 360 live is a superior product to PS3's online play. This coming from someone who recently purchased a PS3 and desperately wants to justify his purchase.
 

bl4ckfl4g

Diamond Member
Feb 13, 2007
3,669
0
0
Lol I got dragged into this POS thread after all. Not over fanboi which one is better arguements but by something else entirely. LOL good job op. You win.
 

RyanPaulShaffer

Diamond Member
Jul 13, 2005
3,434
1
0
BenSkywalker is trying to make the (laughable) assertion that there are 30 million XBOX 360 owners, and since only 10 million of them subscribe to XBOX Live Gold, therefore the other 20 million must be unhappy with XBOX Live Gold. This is a stretch by any figment of the imagination.

As for the jerks on XBOX Live yes, they are there, and maybe in slightly greater numbers than on PSN and/or the PC because of the headset coming with most of the systems. However, they are rare, and are easily ignored and never seen again. BenSkywalker is either making a mountain out of a molehill, or he is just a really big whiner. He expects a Microsoft official to instantly appear the very moment that he files a complaint against a player. ;)
 

bl4ckfl4g

Diamond Member
Feb 13, 2007
3,669
0
0
Originally posted by: Ackmed

Originally posted by: bl4ckfl4g

I'm glad I like free speech.

I like it too. I do think however it comes with repercussions. There is no way a little punk would talk to me in person, the way they do over live or the psn network. The whole internet anonymity is not good for our youth, imo. They try that in the real world, to the wrong person and they will get beat down.

I just mute everyone.

I actually usually only just do party chat anymore.
 

RyanPaulShaffer

Diamond Member
Jul 13, 2005
3,434
1
0
Originally posted by: Cuda1447
I recently bought a PS3 and haven't played it much. Aside from a few exclusives, there is no difference really. Blu-ray doesn't even look THAT much better.
Originally posted by: Ackmed
Then you're doing it wrong. The PS3 does a great job of upscaling DVD's, but there is still a noticable difference.
[/quote]

I totally agree. Blu-ray is far superior in image quality to upscaled DVDs, especially on an HDTV.
 

purbeast0

No Lifer
Sep 13, 2001
53,664
6,547
126
Originally posted by: BenSkywalker

are you seriously calling xbox live inferior to PSN?

Hell yes, by a staggering amount. Go to a white supremacist tech forum and tell me how great it is. I don't care what features it offers, I'll stick with a properly moderated one.

you are clearly a moron who has never used both psn and xbl extensively if you think xbox live is inferior to ps3.
 

Queasy

Moderator<br>Console Gaming
Aug 24, 2001
31,796
2
0
Originally posted by: BenSkywalker
20 Million 360 users aren't happy with Live Gold according to MS. I win this one by default.

There are 30 million 360 users, there are 10 million Live Gold users. 20 million 360 users are not Live Gold users, therefore they can not possibly be happy Gold Live users now can they?

<sigh>
 

Industrial

Senior member
Jan 9, 2009
249
0
0
why are you guys taking Ben's word literally? I just read it as tongue in cheek sarcasm that made me laugh.

I can easily say that every Halo multiplayer is a stupid 10 year old learning to cuss and say vagina for the first time. Some will laugh, and can relate that it would seem true, but we all know that's not the case.
 

Spongo

Golden Member
Jan 3, 2001
1,862
0
0
I honestly had no intention of creating a 'troll' thread. Take a look at all my posts and you'll see that I have never posted anything like this.

I see all the pros and cons of each and like i said, i'm going to get a ps3 in addition to the 360. Another problem is that I have friends on both systems so now it's going to be a pita to figure out who to play with on any given night.

mods - go ahead and close this before it gets out of hand (i guess it's already out of hand).
 

Krakn3Dfx

Platinum Member
Sep 29, 2000
2,969
1
81
Originally posted by: Cuda1447
Blu-ray doesn't even look THAT much better.

Wut?

Pop in Wall-E on DVD and then pop it in on BD on a nice, tuned 1080 television. Tell me it's not THAT much better. It's friggin phenomenal.
 

nakedfrog

No Lifer
Apr 3, 2001
63,014
19,304
136
Originally posted by: Krakn3Dfx
Originally posted by: Cuda1447
Blu-ray doesn't even look THAT much better.

Wut?

Pop in Wall-E on DVD and then pop it in on BD on a nice, tuned 1080 television. Tell me it's not THAT much better. It's friggin phenomenal.

After having read a lot of threads on it, I've come to the conclusion that some people really don't see that much of a difference.