OP you are buff but honestly I think your arms are too big, and thats what gives you the what you call "unassuming" look with clothes on. Guys with your kind of physique have never intimidated me because it doesnt look athletic or like you can do much with it (not saying that is the case at all, but its just not the classic fighter physique) versus like a GSP physique, look at GSP his muscles are much smaller than yours but he looks like he could probably kick your ass even if you didnt know he was a badass mma fighter. Because look at his proportions to yours, his muscles are smaller but higher set, and more focused in the delts, traps, upper part of the chest. The kind of muscles you use when throwing strikes. When muscles get as bulky as your arms, it looks like all you do is lift weights because that amount of mass is going to impede movement ie. striking ability. I mean honestly when you see a MMA fighter that has super bulky muscles, they almost always gas out and lose. The only one who had a success with huge muscles was Overeem. But even his biceps weren't as disporportionately large as yours (though they are big and bodybuilder looking)
is there something that I am missing that states I'm a tough SOB? or training for combat/fighting? I train to keep my head straight and to put on some muscle. Overall, I don't think I am all that disproportionate. One pic doesn't tell the whole story. for example, the manager at the gym kept giving me sh!t about my legs.... "you wear sweats all the time because you have no legs". I showed her my legs, well, I guess you don't have small legs....
I will admit in that pic, it looks like I'm all arms
in saying all that, I have areas I would like to develop more, but for some chump that lifts at a "fitness center" style gym, I have a pretty decent overall build. @ ~200 lbs, I don't feel I am bulky enough to hinder my movement
in my clothes you really wouldn't think I lifted.... that's what I mean by unassuming.
for the record, I'm not a tough guy... I don't lift to be a bad@ss and I have no delusions about kicking anyone's ass, though, there are probably a lot of people there that would be easier targets that me.